X. Wang (Ed.): Mixed Reality and Human-Robot Interaction, ISCA 47, pp. 35–51.
springerlink.com © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2011
Mental Transformations in Human-Robot Interaction
B.P. DeJong
1
, J.E. Colgate
2
, and M.A. Peshkin
2
1
Central Michigan University, USA
2
Northwestern University, USA
Abstract. Human-robot interfaces can be challenging and tiresome because of
misalignments in the control and view relationships. The human user must
mentally transform (e.g., rotate or translate) desired robot actions to required
inputs at the interface. These mental transformations can increase task difficulty
and decrease task performance. This chapter discusses how to improve task
performance by decreasing the mental transformations in a human-robot interface.
It presents a mathematical framework, reviews relevant background, analyzes both
single and multiple camera-display interfaces, and presents the implementation of
a mentally efficient interface.
Keywords: Mental transformation, control rotation, control translation, view
rotation, teleoperation.
1 Introduction
In the summer of 1997, Argonne National Laboratory spent 2000 man-hours and
$1.38 million dismantling their recently decommissioned nuclear reactor
(Department of Energy, 1998). Rather than place humans in the radioactive
environment, Argonne used a remotely controlled robotic system called the Dual
Arm Work Platform (DAWP), consisting of two six-degree-of-freedom robotic
arms and several tilt/pan/zoom cameras (Figure 1). Human operators sat at a
console with several fixed video monitors and controlled the robots via two
passive manipulanda
1
(Noakes et al., 2002).
The use of teleoperation
2
was cost-effective, but Argonne personnel noted
several problems. First, training the operators was time-consuming and expensive;
only 60% of the tested operators were skilled enough to complete tasks. Second,
operators spent nearly 90% of the their time prepping rather than performing
tasks. Finally, the teleoperation was mentally tiring, especially when performing
complex tasks that required switching between multiple camera views
(DeJong et al., 2004b).
1
Manipulandum is a general term for the device that controls another, e.g., a joystick or
kinematically-similar replica of the robot.
2
Teleoperation is operation of a machine or robot at a distance.