Social Studies of Science
2014, Vol. 44(3) 315–341
© The Author(s) 2013
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0306312713511868
sss.sagepub.com
Robot visions
Claudia Castañeda
Emerson College, Boston, MA, USA
Lucy Suchman
Department of Sociology, Lancaster University, Lancaster, UK
Abstract
This article explores the resonating figures of primate, child, and robot in contemporary
technoscientific corporealizations of the ‘almost human’. We take as our model (in)organism
‘Lucy the Robot Orangutan’, roboticist Steve Grand’s project to create an artificial life form
with a mind of its own. One aspect of Lucy’s figuration by Grand, we argue, which ties her to
Haraway’s analysis of the primate, is of the robot as a model for animal, and more specifically
(or aspirationally) human, cognition. We follow the trope of ‘model organism’ as it is under
discussion within science and technology studies and as an ironic descriptor for our own interest
in Lucy as an entity/project through which to illuminate figurations within robotics more widely.
Primate and robot together are forms of natureculture that help to clarify how the categories of
animal and machine are entangled, while making explicit investments in their differences from one
another, and from the third category of the human. We conclude, again following Haraway, by
imagining what other possibilities there might be for figuring humans, robots, and their relations
if we escape the reiterative imaginary of the robot as proxy for becoming human.
Keywords
figuration, model organism, primatology, robotics
Children, artificial intelligence (AI) computer programs, and nonhuman primates all here
embody ‘almost minds’. Who or what has fully human status? … What is the end, or telos,
of this discourse of approximation, reproduction, and communication, in which the
boundaries among and within machines, animals, and humans are exceedingly permeable?
Where will this evolutionary, developmental, and historical communicative commerce
take us in the techno-bio-politics of difference?
(Haraway, 1989: 376)
Corresponding author:
Lucy Suchman, Department of Sociology, Lancaster University, Lancaster LA1 4YT, UK.
Email: l.suchman@lancaster.ac.uk
511868SSS 44 3 10.1177/0306312713511868Social Studies of ScienceCastañeda and Suchman
research-article 2013
Article
by guest on December 7, 2015 sss.sagepub.com Downloaded from