Retiree Welfare and the 2009 Pension Increase:
Impacts from an Australian Experiment
SERENA YU
School of Economics, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia
The welfare effects from the 2009 increase in the age pension are
evaluated using a quasi-experimental, difference-in-difference
regression framework. Using microdata to exploit the exogenous
and large increase in the single-person pension rate, the research
finds significant improvements in the material welfare of single age
pensioners. In particular, non-housing and total consumption rose
by 7 per cent and 4 per cent, respectively. The effects were amplified
among the poorest retirees. The study extends the literature on the
welfare benefits of pension programs, and provides evidence that the
policy changes were highly effective in lifting the material welfare
of the targeted beneficiaries.
I Introduction
Reforms to Australia’s retirement income sys-
tem have been at the forefront of policy discourse
in recent years, and the motivation for this paper
is to measure the welfare effects, if any, which
arose from a recent change in the public Age
Pension. Such an exercise is important given the
current policy environment, in which recent
proposals have focused on improvements in fiscal
sustainability and savings (e.g. changes to index-
ing arrangements, and tightening of the means
test), without commensurate evaluation of poten-
tially offsetting welfare effects.
The focus of this paper is changes made to the
Age Pension in 2009, which followed the 2008
Harmer review of the pension system. The
Harmer review of measures of financial security
for Australia’s seniors, carers and those with
disabilities found that the ‘relativity of the rate of
pension for single people living by themselves to
that of couples is too low’ (Harmer, 2009, p. xii).
In response to the review, in 2009 the Rudd Labor
government announced significant changes to the
public pension program. Foremost among these
was a significant $30 weekly increase to the base
single-person pension rate and a $2.49 increase in
supplemental single-person pension payments.
1
These reforms resulted in a historically unprece-
dented, one-off 19.5 per cent increase in single-
person annual pension income, compared to 7.9
per cent received by couples at the same time
(Commonwealth Government of Australia, 2014).
There is a broad literature on the incentive
effects of public pension programs on the savings
and labour supply decisions of older individuals,
with far more limited studies into the welfare
effects of these and other government transfer
programs. The research presented in this paper
contributes to this literature in three main ways.
First, by using a quasi-experimental approach
exploiting the exogenous variation in the policy
settings, a robust evaluation of the reform’s
effects on retiree welfare is presented. Second,
by using rich data on individual incomes and
expenditures, broader dimensions of welfare are
examined, including consumption and depriva-
tion. Third, the research draws attention to the
JEL classifications: I3, I38, D12
Correspondence: Serena Yu, School of Economics,
University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia.
Email: serena.yu@sydney.edu.au
1
Other reforms included an increase in the Age
Pension eligibility age from 65 to 67 years, a tightening
in the income means test, and an increase in the annual
indexation arrangements from 25 per cent to 27.7 per
cent of male total average weekly earnings.
1
© 2015 Economic Society of Australia
doi: 10.1111/1475-4932.12237
ECONOMIC RECORD, 2015