209
FEATURE
© Blackwell Publishing Ltd, The Geologists’ Association & The Geological Society of London, Geology Today, Vol. 26, No. 6, November–December 2010
Feature
Debris flow burial of ancient wall
system in the Upper Po River valley
William C.
Mahaney
1
, Pierre
Tricart
2
, Rene
W. Barendregt
3
,
Christopher
Carcaillet
4
, Davide
Rabufetti
5
& Volli
Kalm
6
1
Quaternary Surveys, 26
Thornhill Ave, Thornhill,
Ontario, Canada, L4J
1J4 (arkose@rogers.
com; b.kapran@hotmail.
com),
2
Laboratoire
de Géodynamique
des Chaînes alpines,
University of Grenoble,
Observatoire des Sciences
de l’Univers, 38041
Grenoble, France; (Pierre.
Tricart@ujf-grenoble.fr),
3
Department of Geography,
University of Lethbridge,
Alberta, Canada, T1K
3M4; (Barendregt@uleth.
ca),
4
Centre de Bio-
Archéologie et d’Ecologie
(UMR5059 CNRS/EPHE),
Institut de Botanique,
Université Montpellier
2, 163 Rue Broussonet,
34090 Montpellier, France;
(Christopher.Carcaillet@
univ-montp2.fr),
5
ARPA
Piemonte Area delle attività
regionali per la previsione e
il monitoraggio ambientale
Via Pio VII, 9-10135
Torino, (d.rabufetti@arpa.
piemonte.it),
6
Institute of
Ecology and Earth Sciences,
Tartu University, Tartu,
Estonia, 51014. (Volli.
kalm@ut.ee)
The regrouping area, where Hannibal is thought to have reformed his army
after forging a path through a massive rockfall in the Cottian Alps, has been
reshaped by a blanket of sediment deposited from debris flows following
heavy rain in spring, 2008. Analysis of precipitation data for the period mid-
May to mid-June, 2008, shows that 722 mm of rain fell at 2150 m, falling
off to half that amount at 3325 m on the flanks of Mon Viso. Following
exhaustive analysis of environmental factors connected with the invasion
of Italy at the start of the Second Punic War (218 bc), identification of the
regrouping area for the Carthaginian Army centred on the presence of an
ancient stone wall system which possibly dates from Hannibalic times. Lichen
cover, lichen diameters, weathering characteristics, degree to which boulders
had sunk into the resident soil, and presence of ancient hearths all combined
to make this area a choice locale for reconstructive geoarchaeology. Large
scale mass wasting off a prominent bedrock bar adjacent to the wall system
in the Upper Po River Valley resulted in burial of most of the prominent wall
structures which will complicate any exploration geoarchaeology attempts in
future.
A nested series of rock wall systems on the floodplain
of the Upper Po River below the Col de la Traversette
in the Cottian Alps of Italy were buried by debris flows
emplaced during heavy spring runoff in 2008. Be-
cause these interconnected wall systems are thought
to date from Hannibal’s passage through the Alps,
and may contain artefacts important in elucidating
the military culture of ancient Carthage, burial may
make it difficult to locate the sites for future geoar-
chaeological excavation. The purpose of this article
is to draw attention to the site, providing supporting
geomorphological evidence as to its composition and
age.
The key environmental variables elucidated by
researchers (whose work is indicated in the ‘Sug-
gestions for Further Reading’, below), to identify the
invasion route of the Punic Army, centre on: 1, pres-
ence of a major defile in which the Gauls attacked; 2,
presence of firnpack adjacent to the high col; 3, long
view into Italy from the crest; 4, steep ledges and cliffs
on the lee side of the Alps; 5, presence of a two-tier
‘landslide’ (rockfall) blocking the army on the lee side;
and 6, a regrouping area sufficient to provide forage
and water for the army.
Many researchers have described various areas
they consider suitable as the ‘regrouping or restaging
area’, but with the exception of the Upper Po, all oth-
er sites are below cols which lack: firnpack; sufficient
view into Italy; and suitable blocking rockfall deposit.
Only the regrouping area we described in 1988, with
its ancient sunken wall system, closely fits the de-
scription provided by Polybius (III, 55) who followed
the path of the Punic Army some seventy years later.
Because analysis of the walls and adjacent hearth
sites might yield artefact information, important in
elucidating information on the military culture of an-
cient Carthage, it is important to document the effect
of their burial by debris flow activity that occurred
in late spring 2008. Shallow excavation that might
have been possible following a metal detector survey