CLINICAL NOTE
Breathlessness Associated With Abdominal Spastic Contraction
in a Patient With C4 Tetraplegia: A Case Report
Isabelle Laffont, MD, Marie-Christine Durand, MD, Celia Rech, MD, Annie Perez De La Sotta, MD,
Nicholas Hart, MD, Olivier Dizien, MD, Fre ´de ´ric Lofaso, MD, PhD
ABSTRACT. Laffont I, Durand M-C, Rech C, Perez De La
Sotta A, Hart N, Dizien O, Lofaso F. Breathlessness associated
with abdominal spastic contraction in a patient with C4
tetraplegia: a case report. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2003;84:
906-8.
A tetraplegic patient with C4 cervical cord injury reported
breathlessness during episodes of spastic contraction of the
abdominal muscles. To determine the mechanism, we per-
formed electrophysiologic testing of the phrenic nerves. We
measured abdominal pressure, esophageal pressure, and trans-
diaphragmatic pressure (Pdi) during a maximal inspiratory
effort (Pdi max), a maximal sniff maneuver (sniff Pdi) during
resting breathing, and during the episodes of breathlessness.
Electrophysiologic testing of the phrenic nerves showed axonal
neuropathy on the left. Sniff Pdi and Pdi max were 38cmH
2
O
and 42cmH
2
O, respectively. Transient spastic contractions of
abdominal muscles were associated with an increase in abdom-
inal pressure greater than 30cmH
2
O, with a decrease in abdom-
inal volume; this rise in abdominal pressure was transmitted to
the esophageal pressure. Inspiration became effective only
when esophageal pressure fell below the resting baseline value.
Achieving this decrease required an increase in inspiratory
effort, characterized by swings in esophageal pressure and Pdi
of 30cmH
2
O and 40cmH
2
O (approximately 100% of Pdi max),
respectively. During these periods, minute ventilation was
markedly reduced. This is the first report that spastic abdominal
muscle contractions can impose a significant load on the dia-
phragm, uncovering moderate diaphragmatic weakness. This
has important clinical implications; abolition of the spastic
abdominal muscle contraction in this patient completely re-
solved her intermittent respiratory symptoms.
Key Words: Case report; Dyspnea; Rehabilitation; Respi-
ratory insufficiency; Respiratory muscles.
© 2003 by the American Congress of Rehabilitation Medi-
cine and the American Academy of Physical Medicine and
Rehabilitation
T
ETRAPLEGIA CAUSED by transection of the cervical
cord severely compromises some inspiratory muscles and
most expiratory muscles.
1,2
The main physiologic consequence
of expiratory muscle paralysis is an impaired cough,
3
which is
frequently associated with respiratory complications such as
mucus plugging, atelectasis, and pneumonia,
4
a major cause of
mortality in this population.
3
After the initial stage of spinal shock has passed, patients
with tetraplegia may develop abnormal spinal reflexes that
involve the abdominal muscles
5
; spastic contraction of those
muscles is relatively common.
5
This spastic contraction re-
duces the elastic properties of the abdominal compartment of
the respiratory system, which, in turn, can increase the load
imposed on the diaphragm. A study
6
that investigated the
impact of abdominal muscle spastic contraction by placing
weights on the abdomen showed that patients with cervical
cord injury below C4 had an increase in diaphragmatic activ-
ity.
6
However, there are no data in the literature that describe the
effect of abdominal muscle spasm on ventilation in patients
with tetraplegia. In this report, we present a patient with a C4
cervical cord injury who was referred to our hospital for
management of dyspnea associated with episodes of spastic
contraction of the abdominal muscles. We hypothesized that
the physiologic basis for such a phenomenon could be the
result of an excess load imposed on the diaphragm. To inves-
tigate this hypothesis, we studied the changes in pulmonary
mechanics during quiet breathing and during the episodes of
breathlessness.
CASE DESCRIPTION
The patient was a 45-year-old woman with American Spinal
Injury Association class A
7
posttraumatic tetraplegia at the C4
level on the left and the C8 level on the right. At the initial
stage of the tetraplegia, she had no thoracic traumatism but
needed a tracheostomy because of her neurologic level; it was
removed 2 months later. She was reviewed 4 years after injury
when she developed a recurrent dislocation of the left hip that
was associated with severe spasticity of the adductors; she also
experienced breathlessness during episodes of abdominal spas-
tic contractions. These episodes occurred during spontaneous
hip reduction (when moving from the supine to the sitting
position), or when the left hip was passively moved into
abduction, extension, and external rotation.
Static lung volumes were assessed while she was in sitting
and supine positions, according to standard guidelines.
8
Elec-
trophysiologic testing of the phrenic nerves was performed
with a Neuropack Sigma electromyography device
a
and the
Newsome Davis method.
9
The patient was seated in a chair with head up at 60°. Flow
was measured by using a Fleisch No. 2 pneumotachograph,
b
and esophageal pressure (Pes) and gastric pressure (Pga) were
recorded with a catheter-mounted transducer.
c
Thoracic and
abdominal movements were assessed by using uncali-
brated inductive plethysmography. Transdiaphramatic pressure
(Pdi=Pga-Pes) was measured during maximal inspiratory ef-
forts (Pdi max) and during maximal sniffs (sniff Pdi),
10
both
performed at functional residual capacity. Spastic contractions
of abdominal muscles were induced by reducing the dislocated
left hip.
From the Unite ´ de Me ´decine Physique et de Re ´adaptation (Laffont, Rech, Dizien)
and Service de Physiologie-Explorations Fonctionnelles (Durand, Perez De La Sotta,
Lofaso), Ho ˆpital Raymond Poincare ´, Garches, France; Respiratory Muscle Labora-
tory, Royal Brompton Hospital, London, UK (Hart); and Institut National de la Sante ´
et de la Recherche Me ´dicale, Ho ˆpital Henri Mondor, Cre ´teil, France (Lofaso).
No commercial party having a direct financial interest in the results of the research
supporting this article has or will confer a benefit upon the author(s) or upon any
organization with which the author(s) is/are associated.
Correspondence to Fre ´de ´ric Lofaso, MD, PhD, Service de Physiologie-Explora-
tions Fonctionnelles, Ho ˆpital Raymond Poincare ´, 92380 Garches, France, e-mail:
f.lofaso@rpc.ap-hop-paris.fr. Reprints are not available.
0003-9993/03/8406-7518$30.00/0
doi:10.1016/S0003-9993(02)04898-0
906
Arch Phys Med Rehabil Vol 84, June 2003