www.afm-journal.de
FULL PAPER
©
2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 4371
www.MaterialsViews.com
wileyonlinelibrary.com Adv. Funct. Mater. 2010, 20, 4371–4374
By Daniel Coillot, François O. Méar,* Renaud Podor, and Lionel Montagne
1. Introduction
Many efforts in the research and development of smart mate-
rials are currently driven towards higher performance. In recent
years, it has been realized that a strategy based on damage
management can make materials stronger and more reliable.
These materials have a built-in capability to repair the damage
that may occur during use. When damage through thermal,
mechanical, chemical, or another origin is formed, the mate-
rial has the ability to heal and restore itself to its original set of
properties. Thus, self-healing polymers, metals, ceramics, and
their composites have attracted broad attention.
The self-healing concept has been developed in many applica-
tion fields such as polymers for coatings, microelectronic pack-
aging,
[1]
medical uses,
[2]
concrete or cementitious structures,
[2]
and composites materials for aerospace applications.
[3,4]
A robust self-healing effect must have the following character-
istics:
[2]
efficiency (recovers both mechanical and chemical prop-
erties); repeatable (ability to self-repair from multiple damage
events; long shelf life (remains in operation during the service
life, which may span decades); reliable
(consistent self-healing in a broad range
of environments); pervasiveness (ready
for activation when and where needed);
and economical (economically feasible, for
instance for the highly cost-sensitive con-
struction industry).
Most of the work in the development of
self-healing materials has concentrated on
the field of polymers, for which several self-
healing mechanisms have been reported. One
of the earliest one is by Dry,
[5]
who used glass
capillaries to carry a liquid resin to the dam-
aged region. This process was then extended
to hollow glass fibres.
[6–8]
Another self-repair
process is achieved by incorporating a micro-
encapsulated healing agent and a catalytic
chemical trigger within a polymer matrix.
[9–11]
Chen et al.
[12]
have developed a polymer
composition that remains in a dynamic
polymerisation–depolymerisation equilibrium, which ensures
the reformation of broken bonds on heating. Finally, Hayes
et al.
[13]
have developed a smart composite system which com-
bines structural health monitoring with a self-healing resin.
Passive self-healing has also been developed for cementi-
tious composite by Li et al.,
[2]
based on the process developed by
Dry
[7]
in polymers. Superglue contained in hollow, brittle glass
fibres serves as the sealing/healing agent.
Another active application field of self-healing is that of
ceramic matrix composites (CMCs). For instance, carbon-
fiber-reinforced carbon-matrix composites (C/C composites)
are widely used as aeronautic and spatial structural materials
because of their outstanding mechanical properties at high
temperature, in association with their low weight. These C/C
composites are protected with antioxidation coatings, but micro-
cracks often occur owing to the thermal expansion coefficient
(TEC) difference between the C/C substrates and their coatings.
Therefore, self-healing of the coating was developed to enable
long-term antioxidation protection. For this purpose, Cho et al.
[10]
have extended the polymer-self-healing concept by incorpo-
rating into the coatings a healing agent such as SiC, B
4
C, ZrB
2
,
or HfB
2
.
[14–19]
Self-healing is activated when the healing agents
come into contact with air and form oxides that heal the cracks.
Self healing has also been claimed to enable an increase of
the operating duration of glass seals for solid-oxide fuel cells
(SOFCs). It was indeed shown that the SOFC lifetime was
limited by cracks that form within the glass seal used to join elec-
troactive ceramic parts to the metallic structure.
[20]
However, con-
trary to the conventional self-healing processes described above,
here the self-healing effect was not obtained by the addition
of a healing agent, but simply by heating the sealing glass
above its softening temperature.
[21–25]
This effect was shown to
Autonomic Self-Repairing Glassy Materials
A new process that enables glassy materials to self-repair from mechanical
damage is presented in this paper. Contrary to intrinsic self-healing, which
involves overheating to enable crack healing by glass softening, this process
is based on an extrinsic effect produced by vanadium boride (VB) particles
dispersed within the glass matrix. Self-repair is obtained through the oxida-
tion of VB particles, and thus without the need to increase the operating
temperature. The VB healing agent is selected for its capacity to oxidize at a
lower temperature than the softening point of the glass. Thermogravimetric
analyses indeed show that VB oxidation is rapid and occurs below the glass
transition temperature. Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy
indicates that VB is oxidized into V
2
O
5
and B
2
O
3
, which enable the local for-
mation of glass. The autonomic self-healing effect is demonstrated by an in
situ experiment visualized using an environmental scanning electron micro-
scope. It is shown that a crack could be healed by the VB oxidation products.
DOI: 10.1002/adfm.201000147
[*] D. Coillot, Dr. F. O. Méar, Prof. L. Montagne
Unité de Catalyse et Chimie du Solide
UMR-CNRS 8181
Université Lille Nord de France
F-59652 Villeneuve d’Ascq, France
E-mail: francois.mear@univ-lille1.fr
Dr. R. Podor
Institut de Chimie Séparative de Marcoule
UMR 5257 CEA-CNRS-UM2-ENSCM Site de Marcoule
BP 17171, F-30207 Bagnols sur Cèze cedex, France