Experimental boundaries of the quantum rotor
induced polarization (QRIP) in liquid state NMR
Maik Icker, Pascal Fricke, Toni Grell, Julia Hollenbach, Henry Auer
and Stefan Berger*
The Haupt-effect is a rather seldom used hyperpolarization method. It is based on the interdependence between nuclear spin
states and rotational states of nearly free rotating methyl groups having C
3
symmetry. A sudden change in temperature from
4.2 K to room temperature by fast dissolution yields considerably enhanced
13
C and
1
H resonance signals. This phenomenon is
now termed quantum rotor induced polarization. More than 40 substances have been studied by this approach in order to
identify them as polarizable by the ‘Haupt-effect in the liquid state’. Influencing factors have been analyzed systematically.
It could be concluded that substances having a high tunneling frequency, which is due to a small and narrow potential barrier,
are most likely to feature quantum rotor induced polarization-enhanced signals. Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Keywords: Haupt effect; hyperpolarization; quantum rotors
Introduction
The sensitivity issue of NMR can be addressed by several means
such as DNP,
[1–3]
(photo-)CIDNP,
[4,5]
optical pumping,
[6]
and
para-H
2
experiments.
[7]
Recently, we have shown that a simple
experimental approach yields a
13
C signal enhancement for the
methyl carbon of γ-picoline (1) of about ×100.
[8]
The signal shape
is an antiphase multiplet, which can be manipulated by a spin echo
for the purpose of obtaining an in-phase pattern. The latter step is
essential to transfer the hyperpolarization efficiently from the methyl
group to other carbons within the pyridine ring.
[9]
We attributed
this polarization phenomenon to the Haupt-effect,
[10–21]
which
arises from the inherent interdependence between nuclear spin
states and rotational states of nearly free rotating methyl groups
having C
3
symmetry.
Because of some differences in the mechanism, a more general
description of the ‘liquid state Haupt-effect’ with ‘quantum rotor
induced polarization’ (QRIP)
[21]
might be the more appropriate term.
Despite a currently missing full theory, this paper aims at giving
our complete experimental results that we obtained during our
studies of this polarization phenomenon in the liquid state.
Results and Discussion
Primarily, we have been interested in identifying further substances
featuring this extraordinary polarization phenomenon, which
simply results from cooling the pure substance in liquid helium
(4.2 K) and subsequently dissolving it rapidly with standard NMR
solvents and measuring them at room temperature.
Methylpyridines
The molecule yielding the largest signal enhancement by the use
of this procedure is γ-picoline (1) (Scheme 1), which exhibits a
polarization factor of up to ε = 200 for the
13
C methyl resonance.
Therefore, we investigated different methylpyridine isomers.
Remarkably, the α-form (2) and β-form (3) of picoline do not
permit any signal polarization.
A close analog to γ-picoline (1) is the 1,4-dimethylpyridinium
salt 4, but a spectral change after cooling cannot be obtained.
However, there is a 20-fold gain in polarization of the
13
C methyl
signal of γ-picoline-N-oxide 5 (Fig. 1). These findings nicely
illustrate the complex nature in exploring new substances for
QRIP as intermolecular interactions (structure within the solid)
dominate the probability of the effect instead of the isolated
molecular structure alone.
Considering lutidines, the 2,6-dimethylpyridine (6) features an
interesting effect (Fig. 2). The carbon resonance of 2/6-C yields a
significant enhancement by a factor of ε ≈ 14, whereas the methyl
group signal only shows a slight influence (ε ≈ 2). In general, an
effect on the nearby carbon spins (ipso-C) can also be found for
other compounds such as γ-picoline but they typically have a
larger methyl group polarization. In contrast, no polarization
effect is observed for the isomer 3,5-lutidine (7) as well as for
2,4,6-trimethyl pyridine (8) or 2-methyl quinoline (9) (Scheme 2)
Methyl groups in differently hybridized bonds
We tried to figure out experimentally if a trend does exist being
useful to predict whether a compound is capable of showing
the QRIP by simply comparing methyl groups in different intra-
molecular environments.
sp
3
–sp
3
bonds
Methyl group resonances of alkyl chains do not exhibit any
change in polarization by pre-cooling at 4.2 K. This is due to the
* Correspondence to: Stefan Berger, Institute of Analytical Chemistry, University
of Leipzig, Johannisallee 29, 04103 Leipzig, Germany. E-mail: stberger@rz.uni-
leipzig.de
Institute of Analytical Chemistry, University of Leipzig, Johannisallee 29, 04103,
Leipzig, Germany
Magn. Reson. Chem. 2013, 51, 815–820 Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Research article
Received: 15 August 2013 Revised: 14 September 2013 Accepted: 18 September 2013 Published online in Wiley Online Library: 28 October 2013
(wileyonlinelibrary.com) DOI 10.1002/mrc.4021
815