A procedure for calculation of monitor units for passively scattered proton
radiotherapy beams
Narayan Sahoo,
a
X. Ronald Zhu, Bijan Arjomandy, George Ciangaru, MingFwu Lii,
Richard Amos, Richard Wu, and Michael T. Gillin
Department of Radiation Physics, UT MD Anderson Cancer Center, 1515 Holcombe Boulevard,
Box 1150, Houston, Texas 77030
Received 11 February 2008; revised 8 September 2008; accepted for publication 9 September 2008;
published 21 October 2008
The purpose of this study is to validate a monitor unit MU calculation procedure for passively
scattered proton therapy beams. The output dose per MU d/MU of a therapeutic radiation beam is
traditionally calibrated under specific reference conditions. These conditions include beam energy,
field size, suitable depth in water or water equivalent phantom in a low dose gradient region with
known relative depth dose, and source to point of calibration distance. Treatment field settings
usually differ from these reference conditions leading to a different d/MU that needs to be deter-
mined for delivering the prescribed dose. For passively scattered proton beams, the proton specific
parameters, which need to be defined, are related to the energy, lateral scatterers, range modulating
wheel, spread out Bragg peak SOBP width, thickness of any range shifter, the depth dose value
relative to the normalization point in the SOBP, and scatter both from the range compensator and
inhomogeneity in the patient. Following the custom for photons or electrons, a set of proton
dosimetry factors, representing the changes in the d/MU relative to a reference condition, can be
defined as the relative output factor ROF, SOBP factor SOBPF, range shifter factor RSF,
SOBP off-center factor SOBPOCF, off-center ratio OCR, inverse square factor ISF, field size
factor FSF, and compensator and patient scatter factor CPSF. The ROF, SOBPF, and RSF are
the major contributors to the d/MU and were measured using an ion chamber in water tank during
the clinical commissioning of each beam to create a dosimetry beam data table to be used for
calculating the monitor units. The following simple formula is found to provide an independent
method to determine the d/MU at the point of interest POI in the patient, namely, d / MU
=ROF·SOBPF·RSF·SOBPOCF·OCR·FSF·ISF·CPSF. The monitor units for delivering the in-
tended dose D to the POI can be obtained from MU= D ÷ d / MU. The accuracy and robustness
of the above formula were validated by calculating the d/MU in water for many different combi-
nations of beam parameters and comparing it with the corresponding measured d/MU by an ion
chamber in a water or water/plastic phantom. This procedure has been in use for MU calculation for
patient treatment fields at our facility since May 2006. The differences in the calculated and
measured values of the d/MU for 623 distinct fields used for patient treatment during the period of
May 2006 to February 2007 are within 2% for 99% of these fields. The authors conclude that an
intuitive formula similar to the one used for monitor unit calculation of therapeutic photon beams
can be used to compute the monitor units of passively scattered proton therapy beams. © 2008
American Association of Physicists in Medicine. DOI: 10.1118/1.2992055
Key words: proton beam therapy, monitor units
I. INTRODUCTION
Determination of monitor units MU for the delivery of pre-
scribed dose D is an essential dosimetry task in external
beam radiation therapy. The formalism or procedure for
calculating the MU for photon and electron beams is well
established, but is less well established for heavy particle
beam therapy like proton therapy.
1,2
It is desirable to devise
an MU calculation formula, based on well-understood do-
simetry principles and measurements, which can be used in
many of the frequently used treatment conditions. This con-
servative approach is essential for any new treatment deliv-
ery system. The number of different treatment conditions for
the passively scattered proton beams at the University of
Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center Proton Therapy Facility
in Houston PTC-H is large. In passively scattered beams, a
double scattering system consisting of a first and a second
scatterer is used to spread the protons laterally. Each beam-
line has three different snouts, namely, small, medium, and
large, to hold apertures and range compensators of sizes up
to 10 cm 10 cm, 18 cm 18 cm, and 25 cm 25 cm, re-
spectively. Each beamline has options for eight discrete en-
ergy selections, namely 100, 120, 140, 160, 180, 200, 225,
and 250 MeV. For each of the above energy and maximum
field size combination, a specific range modulating wheel
RMW is used to spread the Bragg peak longitudinally. This
results in 24 RMWs per beamline. Different second scatters
are designed to be used with the three maximum field size
choices and certain energy ranges. Each of the 24 RMWs is
5088 5088 Med. Phys. 35 „11…, November 2008 0094-2405/2008/35„11…/5088/10/$23.00 © 2008 Am. Assoc. Phys. Med.