ORIGINAL ARTICLE Musculoskeletal
Ankle muscle activation in people with haemophilia
E. KURZ,* C. ANDERS, † M. HERBSLEB, ‡ C. PUTA, ‡ D. CZEPA* and T. HILBERG*
*Department of Sports Medicine, University of Wuppertal, Wuppertal, Germany; †Division for Motor Research,
Pathophysiology and Biomechanics, Clinic for Trauma, Hand and Reconstructive Surgery, University Hospital Jena, Jena,
Germany; and ‡Department of Sports Medicine and Health Promotion, Friedrich-Schiller-University Jena, Jena, Germany
Summary. Since normative surface EMG (SEMG) values
for muscles acting at the knee joint are available for
people with haemophilia, increasing interest is
noticeable for other joints affected by haemophilic
arthropathy. Adequate activity of shank muscles is an
important key for appropriate postural control. The
aim of this study was to determine differences in
muscle activation patterns of lower leg muscles
between people with and without haemophilia during
upright standing. SEMG of tibialis anterior (TA),
fibularis longus (FL), lateral (LG) and medial (MG)
heads of gastrocnemius, and soleus (SO) muscles of
both sides were recorded in 25 haemophilic patients
(H) and 25 non-haemophilic control subjects (C) while
standing on even ground. The Gilbert-Score was used
to assign sides to major (H-MA) and minor (H-MI)
affected ankle joints in H. To normalize the SEMG
amplitudes, amplitude ratios (percentage of cumulated
activity) were calculated. Compared to controls, TA
ratios showed higher and MG reduced levels in both
H groups (P < 0.01). In the H-MA subgroup of H, FL
also joined the TA behaviour whereas SO had similar
activation direction as MG. Although possible
descending influences from the knee joints cannot be
excluded, this can be interpreted as a compensational
mechanism due to the severity of the orthopaedic
status of the ankle, which with increasing heaviness is
accompanied by reduced plantar flexion capability.
However, ankle joint integrity appears to be reduced
in H, with TA and MG seeming to play key roles for
neuromuscular control of upright posture.
Keywords: ankle, arthropathy, haemophilia, surface EMG,
upright standing
Introduction
The hallmark of people suffering from severe haemo-
philia is recurrent bleeding into joints. Particularly, the
knees, ankles and elbows are already affected in early
age. If these resulting haemarthroses are treated inade-
quately or even not treated at all, joint damage occurs,
leading to arthropathy in the following decades of life.
Joint space narrowing and joint deformity are com-
mon orthopaedic problems in haemophilia. Prevention
of arthropathy in haemophilic patients (H) is possible
by replacing the deficient clotting factor at an early
stage of life, best done before any significant joint
destruction has occurred [1]. Evidence exists that pro-
phylactic therapy (primary prophylaxis) is most benefi-
cial for the prevention of haemophilic arthropathy [1].
According to Rodriguez-Merchan [2], evidence exists
that supports the idea that “avoiding or minimizing
joint loading might help protecting against haemophilic
arthropathy”. However, minimizing joint load might
not be the only way to break the “vicious circle” of
joint destruction in people with haemophilia [for review
see 3]. Whenever someone reduces the demand upon a
specific tissue, it undoubtedly leads to a maladaptation
of the respective structures [4]. In contrast, adequately
conditioned muscles are able to protect the joints from
progressive degeneration [5,6]. Thus, from a more
holistic point of view, primary prophylaxis combined
with individually adjusted exercise regimes [7–9] might
have a more powerful effect on the prevention of haem-
ophilic arthropathies than treatment with coagulation
factors alone.
The accurate evaluation of the joint condition is a
prerequisite for any correct therapeutic approach.
Therefore, joint conditions need to be precisely staged.
This impacts the individual application of prophylaxis
and dosage of sports therapy. The severity of impaired
joint mobility should be determined in comparison
with normal reference values. Unfortunately, there are
little published data describing physiological joint
Correspondence: Eduard Kurz, Department of Sports Medicine,
University of Wuppertal, Pauluskirchstr. 7, 42285 Wuppertal,
Germany.
Tel.: +49 202 439-5912; fax: +49 202 439-5910;
e-mails: e.kurz@uni-wuppertal.de; sportmedizin@uni-wuppertal.de
Accepted after revision 3 April 2012
948 © 2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Haemophilia (2012), 18, 948–954 DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2516.2012.02852.x