LETTERS
PUBLISHED ONLINE: 13 MAY 2012 | DOI: 10.1038/NPHYS2318
Equal-spin Andreev reflection and long-range coherent
transport in high-temperature superconductor/half-
metallic ferromagnet junctions
C. Visani
1,2
, Z. Sefrioui
3,4
, J. Tornos
3,4
, C. Leon
3,4
, J. Briatico
1,2
, M. Bibes
1,2
, A. Barthélémy
1,2
,
J. Santamaría
3,4
and Javier E. Villegas
1,2
*
Conventional superconductivity is incompatible with ferromag-
netism, because the magnetic exchange field tends to spin-
polarize electrons and breaks apart the opposite-spin singlet
Cooper pairs
1
. Yet, the possibility of a long-range penetration
of superconducting correlations into strong ferromagnets has
been evinced by experiments that found Josephson coupling
between superconducting electrodes separated afar by a ferro-
magnetic spacer
2–7
. This is considered a proof of the emergence
at the superconductor/ferromagnetic (S/F) interfaces of equal-
spin triplet pairing, which is immune to the exchange field and
can therefore propagate over long distances into the F (ref. 8).
This effect bears much fundamental interest and potential for
spintronic applications
9
. However, a spectroscopic signature of
the underlying microscopic mechanisms has remained elusive.
Here we do show this type of evidence, notably in a S/F
system for which the possible appearance of equal-spin triplet
pairing is controversial
10–12
: heterostructures that combine a
half-metallic F (La
0.7
Ca
0.3
MnO
3
) with a d-wave S (YBa
2
Cu
3
O
7
).
We found quasiparticle and electron interference effects in the
conductance across the S/F interfaces that directly demon-
strate the long-range propagation across La
0.7
Ca
0.3
MnO
3
of
superconducting correlations, and imply the occurrence of
unconventional equal-spin Andreev reflection. This allows for
an understanding of the unusual proximity behaviour observed
in this type of heterostructures
12,13
.
The proximity effect, usually described as the penetration or
‘leakage’ of the superconducting condensate from a S into an
overlaying normal metal (N), is on a microscopic level the result
of two processes. The first one is the Andreev reflection
14
, through
which a normal electron incident into the S/N interface is paired
with an electron inside the Fermi sea by the S energy gap, leaving
a hole excitation that propagates backwards from the interface. In
the conventional picture, the incident electron and the reflected
hole must have opposite spins. The second process is the coherent
propagation into the N material of the resulting hole/electron
phase-conjugated pair
15
. The latter carries the superconducting
correlations into the N, leading to a finite condensation amplitude
over a certain length scale ξ
N
, as schematically shown in Fig. 1a.
In the N, such coherent propagation is limited only by the
usual dephasing mechanisms and diverges at zero temperature
(T ): for diffusive systems ξ
N
=
√
¯
hD/2π KT and for ballistic ones
ξ
N
=
¯
hv
F
/2π KT , where D is the electronic diffusion constant, K
is the Boltzmann constant and v
F
is the Fermi velocity
15
. In clean
metals, at low temperatures, ξ
N
can be micrometres long. If the
1
Unité Mixte de Physique CNRS/Thales, 1 Avenue A. Fresnel, 91767 Palaiseau, France,
2
Université Paris Sud 11, 91405 Orsay, France,
3
GFMC, Dpto. Física
Aplicada III, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, 28040 Madrid, Spain,
4
CEI Campus Moncloa, UCM-UPM, 28040 Madrid, Spain.
*e-mail: javier.villegas@thalesgroup.com.
material in contact with the S is a F, the two processes above—
and therefore the conventional proximity effect—are markedly
suppressed
1
. On the one hand, the exchange field E
ex
strongly
limits the length ξ
F
=
√
¯
hD/2E
ex
(ξ
F
=
¯
hv
F
/2E
ex
for a ballistic
system) over which the phase coherence of the electron/hole
pair is maintained (Fig. 1b). In weak ferromagnets, ξ
F
is only
a few nanometres
16
. For the half-metallic F (H) La
0.7
Ca
0.3
MnO
3
(LCMO), ξ
F
<1 nm owing to the large E
ex
∼ 3 eV (ref. 17). On the
other hand, the Andreev-reflection probability is reduced owing
to the spin-polarization of the conduction electrons in the F: in
the extreme case of a H (100% spin-polarization), it is strictly
forbidden owing to the zero density-of-states at the Fermi level
within the minority-spin band, thereby hindering the penetration
of superconducting correlations (Fig. 1c). However, if these could
be sustained exclusively within the F majority-spin band, a long-
range penetration comparable to ξ
N
would be expected. Such
equal-spin (triplet) correlations are foreseen in the presence of
a so-called ‘spin-active’ S/F interface that induces spin-flip and
spin-mixing processes
18,19
. From the microscopic point of view,
an unconventional equal-spin Andreev-reflection process would be
required for this type of triplet correlations to propagate into a H.
Our experimental approach to investigate these proximity
effects consists of measuring the differential conductance of
c -axis Au/YBa
2
Cu
3
O
7
/La
0.7
Ca
0.3
MnO
3
(Au/YBCO/LCMO) and
Au/YBCO/LCMO/YBCO micrometre-size junctions. The oxide
heterostructures were grown by sputtering deposition and a series
of lithography, etching, metal and isolator deposition steps were
used to fabricate the vertical junctions sketched in Fig. 2 (see
Supplementary Information for details on the sample preparation).
Note that, contrary to the case of ramp-based junctions in which
the ab plane of the cuprate is oblique to the S/F interface
20
,
in the present experiment the YBCO ab plane is parallel to it.
We chose this geometry because it is exactly the one for which
earlier experiments suggested long-range proximity effects across
YBCO/LCMO interfaces
12,13
. Note also that, owing to the ex situ
deposition of the top Au electrode, a relatively large Au/YBCO
interface resistance is obtained that allows controlling—through the
bias voltage V —the energy of the quasiparticles injected into the top
YBCO (see Supplementary Section S3 for further details).
The low-temperature (3 K) conductance versus bias for a
YBCO/LCMO/YBCO trilayer junction is shown in Fig. 2b (as we
show later, a similar behaviour is also found for YBCO/LCMO
bilayer junctions). The conductance is the numerical derivative of
the measured I (V) (inset). The background conductance shows
NATURE PHYSICS | VOL 8 | JULY 2012 | www.nature.com/naturephysics 539
© 201 2 M acmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved.