International Journal of Medical Physics, Clinical Engineering and Radiation Oncology, 2012, 1, 8-13
doi:2660001:10.2436/ijmpcero.2012.11002 Published Online May 2012 (http://www.SciRP.org/journal/ijmpcero)
Dose Perturbations of Gold Fiducial Markers in the
Prostate Cancer Intensity Modulated Proton Radiation
Therapy (IMPT)
Miao Zhang
1
, Sung Kim
1
, Ting Chen
1
, Xiaohu Mo
2
, Bruce G. Haffty
1
, Ning J. Yue
1
1
Department of Radiation Oncology, The Cancer Institute of New Jersey,
UMDNJ-Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital, New Brunswick, USA
2
Medical Physics Department, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, USA
Email: zhangm3@umdnj.edu
Received April 7, 2012; revised May 13, 2012; accepted May 22, 2012
ABSTRACT
The objective of this study is to investigate the dose perturbations introduced by the implanted gold fiducial markers in
the prostate cancer intensity modulated proton therapy (IMPT) and the impacts of different plan designs on the pertur-
bations. Five proton plans: a single lateral field 3D-modulation (3D-mod) plan, 2 fields laterally opposing 3D-mod plan,
6-, 9-, and 18-field distal edge tracking (DET) plans were designed on the CT images of a prostate patient. The dose
distributions were first generated for the plans free of fiducial markers with 78 Gy prescribed to 95% of the PTV. To
derive the dose perturbations of the gold fiducial markers, three cylindrical shaped gold fiducial markers (3 mm long
and 1 mm in diameter) were artificially inserted into the prostate, and the dose distributions were re-computed. Monte
Carlo method was used for dose computation. It was found that the gold fiducial markers perturbed the dose distribu-
tions, especially along the beam paths. The markers caused a shadowing effect reducing the doses in the areas beyond
the markers. Overall, due to the presence of the fiducial markers, D
99%
of prostate were reduced by 2.96 Gy, 4.21 Gy,
0.16 Gy, 0.34 Gy, 0.15 Gy for the plans of single field 3D-mod, 2-field parallel opposed 3D-mod, 6-, 9-, and 18-field
DET respectively. Our study showed these dose perturbation effects decreased with the increase of number of beam
angles. Up to 6 beam angles may be required to reduce the dose perturbations from the gold fiducial markers to a clini-
cally acceptable level in IMPT.
Keywords: Gold Fiducial Marker; Intensity Modulated Proton Therapy; Prostate Cancer; Monte Carlo
1. Introduction
In prostate radiotherapy, high density fiducial markers
are often used on a daily basis for accurate localization of
prostate gland. While high density fiducial markers are
preferred for providing high contrast images, the pres-
ence of these high density markers may perturb the ra-
diation field and introduce undesired dose distributions.
For conventional megavoltage photon radiotherapy, both
theoretical and experimental studies have shown the
presence of small high density materials, like gold, does
not introduce significant dose perturbations due to the
strong penetrating power of megavoltage photons and the
multiple beam angles arrangement [1]. However, the use
of high density fiducial markers in proton therapy may
require careful consideration [2-5]. Newhauser et al. [2]
used the Monte Carlo method to calculate the dosimetric
effects caused by cylindrical shaped gold fiducial mark-
ers (3 mm long and 0.9 mm in diameter) in a single di-
rection spread out Bragg peak (SOBP) proton field. Com-
pared to the dose distribution without markers in water,
they found that gold markers casted a “dose shadow” to
the area behind the markers. The magnitude of the under-
dose depended on the orientation of the gold markers
with respect to the radiation field, as well as the relative
locations of the gold markers to the distal edge of the
SOBP. In the worst case scenario (marker was parallel to
the beam direction and close to the distal end of the
SOBP) the under-dose to the tissue behind the marker
could be as large as 50%. Even when the orientation of
the marker was perpendicular to the beam direction, the
under-dose to the tissue behind the marker was still
around 20%. In a later investigation, Lim et al. [6] con-
firmed those Monte Carlo results by using diode detec-
tors to measure the dose distributions in a water phan-
tom.
Recently, more sophisticated proton delivery systems
become available. The introduction of the active scan-
ning technology in the proton delivery system allows
Copyright © 2012 SciRes. IJMPCERO