Energy Potential Metric for Rapid
Macro-level Resource Assessment of
Tidal In-Stream Energy in the Philippines
Michael L. S. Abundo, MS EE
Allan C. Nerves, PhD
EEE Institute
University of the Philippines
Diliman, Quezon City
abundo@ieee.org
Ma. Rosario C. O. Ang
Enrico C. Paringit, Dr. Eng.
Department of Geodetic Engineering
University of the Philippines
Diliman, Quezon City
Lawrence P. C. Bernardo
Cesar L. Villanoy, PhD
Marine Science Institute
University of the Philippines
Diliman, Quezon City
Abstract—This paper presents preliminary efforts in developing a
rapid evaluation tool for tidal in-stream energy (TISE) in the
Philippines. We study the possibility of using an energy density
metric based on the sea surface elevation (SSE) or tide height
difference at the boundaries of a site of interest as a gauge for the
TISE potential of that site. Results show good correlation with
high potential sites and the proposed metric. Verde Island
Passage was assessed, through a combination of DELFT3D
simulation and Matlab-based power computations, to have four
potential TISE sites with a total energy density of 271.90 kW-h
/m
2
in a month.
Keywords-Tidal Power; Ocean Energy ; Resource Assessment;
Rapid Evaluation Tool; Tidal In-Stream Energy; Sea Surface
Elevation; Energy Potential Metric
I. INTRODUCTION
Ocean renewable energy resources have been grouped into:
tides, waves, tidal stream, ocean currents, thermal gradients,
and salinity gradients by [1, 2]. To date, only the tidal barrage
has reached commercial maturity and is being used in the
U.K.[2]. Thermal and Salinity gradient technologies have not
reached the pre-commercial maturity level. Ocean thermal
energy conversion (OTEC) technologies are still very
expensive and the lack of pilot sites with installed power
systems harnessing this type of energy pulled away support
from a number of investors worldwide. Wave energy
conversion (WEC) and tidal in-stream energy conversion
(TISEC) systems however have reached full-scale and are in
the pre-commercial scales of maturity [2]. Given that the tidal
energy resource is more predictable than wave energy resource,
it is better to investigate the potential of harnessing the tidal
resource at this stage for the Philippines.
Numerous groups have studied various aspects of tidal
energy. Global status reviews have given good growth
potential of tidal power [1, 2]. A number of resources
assessments have been carried out worldwide, some of which
include Australia [4], Malaysia [5], the USA [6], Canada [7],
and Europe [8]. Reviews have been done with regard to efforts
that cover: resource assessment methods [1, 3], technology [1,
2], environment , and economics [1, 2, 9].
Generally, there are two ways of harnessing tidal energy:
using the tidal barrage approach and using the tidal stream
approach [1, 2]. In the tidal barrage approach, water is stored in
a reservoir when the tide is high and is released when the site is
at low tide. This storing-releasing cycle operates similar to a
dam-based hydroelectric plant where water flow drives
turbines with a significant amount of head. In the tidal stream
approach, storage of water in a reservoir is not necessary but
rather the energy from the flow of tidal current is extracted
similar to that of wind farms. Tidal stream power has gained
more interest in the past years compared to the tidal barrage
approach since it is a more economical and environmentally
benign option [1, 9].
The Philippines’ ocean renewable energy resource,
including tidal, wave, and thermal energy, has been assessed in
a general manner by Mindanao State University - Iligan
Institute of Technology (MSU-IIT) to be around 150GW.The
Philippines’ Department of Energy (DOE) benchmarks the
ocean renewable energy resource of the country to be around
170GW [10]. Eight straits and channels were identified to be
potential sites for tidal stream energy. These sites are those
with high tidal current velocity but have not yet been assessed
properly.
In 2004, Blue Energy, a tidal stream energy company from
Canada assessed the potential of San Bernardino Strait to be
2.2 GW using their TISEC device array (274 Ocean Class
Davis turbines, rated at 7 to 14 MW each). Other sites still exist
in the Philippines with TISE potential but, to date, there is still
no published work assessing sites with relatively adequate tidal
current velocities. There is a need, therefore, to assess, in a
more methodical manner and with improved accuracy and
reliability, the tidal in-stream energy (TISE) potential of the
Philippines.
Since the Navier-Stokes equation as mentioned by [3] are
primarily dependent on the sea surface elevation as the pressure
term to calculate for the current velocity, and since power is a
function of velocity, we conjecture that the energy density of a
site might be correlated with the summation of tide height
differences of the boundaries of that site.
This research is made possible by the Engineering Research and
Development for Technology (ERDT) program of the Dept. of Science and
Technology (DOST) of the Philippines.
978-1-4244-8782-0/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE