THE IMPACT OF MAIL ORDER ON SUBSEQUENT
DONATIONS: AN EXPERIMENT
Pierre Desmet*
INTRODUCTION
The charity sector is characterised by non profit organisations (associations or
foundations), by a field of activity (such as international cooperation, a social
objective, or medical research) and by non-commercial funding
(contributions, donations, subsidies, dues) (Ralet, 1994). The Foundation of
France has estimated the funding level to be at 14.3 billion FF ($2.4 billion
US) for this country in 1993, an increase of more than 50% from 1990 to
1993. To fulfill their mission, charities traditionally function with a group of
volunteers (inside base), who are either performing a job related to the mission
(education, medicine) or they are collecting money from donors (outside
base) on canvassing or event campaigns, while usually being donors
themselves.
Charitable organisations have to deal with two tendencies: first,
development implied by the success of the mission increases financial needs;
second, there is a decrease in volunteers for door-to-door canvassing. This
then requires more and more public fund raising and leads to the necessity,
reinforced by public action, of having more professional workers taking the
place of volunteers inside the organisation and results in a more rigorous
managerial approach.
The use of professional management and marketing approaches has
profoundly changed this area over the past ten years (Shapiro, 1973). For
marketing purposes, professional directors have intensively used relationship
marketing to manage their program for large contributors, in addition to
database marketing to identify small donors and enlist their loyalty (Cermak,
File and Prince, 1994). These direct marketing techniques, often combined
with professional services, are being provided by mail order companies.
As a consequence, another tendency is the increasing difficulty in raising
more money by direct marketing and decreasing returns due to a more
competitive marketplace, paralleled by a decrease in the average amount per
contribution. So, naturally, managers not only use direct mail but also tend to
use other mail order techniques, such as mail order catalogues. Other means
Financial Accountability & Management,14(3), August 1998, 0267-4424
ßBlackwell Publishers Ltd. 1998, 108 Cowley Road, Oxford OX4 1JF, UK
and 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148, USA. 203
* The author is a Professor at the University of Paris IX-Dauphine and ESSEC.
Address for correspondence: Pierre Desmet 20, Les clairie© res rouges, 95000 Cergy-Pontoise,
France.
e-mail: desmet@dauphine.fr/p_desmet@edu.essec.fr