Journal of Applied Microbiology 1999, 87, 402–409
Study of the potential relationship between the morphology
of infectious somatic coliphages and their persistence in the
environment
M. Muniesa, F. Lucena and J. Jofre
Departament de Microbiologia, Facultat de Biologia, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain
7089/02/99: received 23 February 1999, revised 5 May 1999 and accepted 13 May 1999
M. MUNIESA, F. LUCENA AND J. JOFRE. 1999. The proportions of different morphological
types of infectious somatic coliphages were determined in faecally polluted
freshwaters. Myoviridae, followed by Siphoviridae, were the most frequently isolated
morphological types in raw sewage, treated sewage and river water collected a few metres
downstream from a sewage outfall. However, in river water collected further
downstream from the pollution point, in river water after ‘in situ’ inactivation experiments
and in chlorinated raw and treated sewage significant changes in the proportions of the
different somatic coliphage morphological types occurred. In all cases, Siphoviridae, especially
those with flexible and curled tails, became more abundant to the detriment of
Myoviridae.
INTRODUCTION
Somatic coliphages (Hilton and Stotzky 1973; Wenstel et al.
1982; IAWPRC 1991), F-specific RNA bacteriophages (Hav-
elaar and Hogeboom 1983; IAWPRC 1991) and Bacteroides
fragilis bacteriophages (Jofre et al. 1986; Tartera and Jofre
1987; IAWPRC 1991) have been proposed as model organ-
isms in water quality studies. Measuring somatic coliphages
is easier, cheaper and faster than measuring the other groups
of bacteriophages. However, they present some short-
comings, one of them being the heterogeneity of the group,
whereas both F-specific RNA (Havelaar and Hogeboom 1983)
and B. fragilis (Jofre et al. 1986) bacteriophages are much
more homogeneous groups. Indeed, the host strain Esch-
erichia coli C (ATCC 13076), recommended in Standard
Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater (Anon.
1992), or its nalidixic acid-resistant mutants WG5 (Grabow
and Coubrough 1986) or CN13 (Payment and Franco 1993),
recommended by ISO (Anon. 1998) for the detection of
somatic coliphages, detect a set of different bacteriophages
which, among other characteristics, differ in morphology
(Ackermann and Nguyen 1983; Pedroso and Martins 1995).
Moreover, in water samples collected far from the pollution
source or in water samples taken after chemical disinfection,
the predominant bacteriophages may be different from the
Correspondence to: Dr J. Jofre, Departament de Microbiologia, Universitat
de Barcelona, Avinguda Diagonal 645. 08028 Barcelona, Spain
(e-mail: joan@porthos.bio.ub.es).
© 1999 The Society for Applied Microbiology
predominant phages detected in sewage and in recently pol-
luted waters (Dee and Fogleman 1992; Lasobras et al. 1997).
Further knowledge on this occurrence is necessary to better
evaluate the potential usefulness of somatic coliphages as
indicators of the hygienic quality of water or as tools to
monitor water treatment processes.
Here we compare the predominant morphological types of
infectious somatic coliphages present in sewage, in receiving
waters sampled at sites distant from the pollution point, in
river water after ‘in situ’ inactivation experiments and in both
raw and treated sewage after chlorination.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Bacterial host and media
Escherichia coli CN13 (Payment and Franco 1993), grown on
tryptone medium (10 g tryptone, 1 g glucose and 5 g NaCl in
a final volume of 1 l distilled water) containing nalidixic acid
(100 mg l
−1
), was used for the detection of somatic coliphages.
To study the effect of the assay medium on the distribution
pattern of morphological types, modified Scholten’s medium
(10 g peptone, 3 g yeast extract, 12 g meat extract, 3 g NaCl,
0·7 g Na
2
CO
3
and 1·25 mmol magnesium in 1 l distilled water)
was also used (Havelaar and Hogeboom 1983). All the results,
except those in Table 7, were obtained using tryptone soft
agar as the assay medium.