ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Changes in the Thickness and Stiffness of Plantar Soft Tissues
in People With Diabetic Peripheral Neuropathy
Jia-Hui Sun, MPhil, Benson K. Cheng, PhD, Yong-Ping Zheng, PhD, Yan-Ping Huang, MPhil,
Jenny Y. Leung, MBBS, Gladys L. Cheing, PhD
ABSTRACT. Sun J-H, Cheng BK, Zheng Y-P, Huang Y-P,
Leung JY, Cheing GL. Changes in the thickness and stiffness
of plantar soft tissues in people with diabetic peripheral neu-
ropathy. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2011;92:1484-9.
Objective: To compare the thickness and stiffness of plantar
soft tissues between people with diabetic peripheral neuropathy
(DPN) and healthy subjects.
Design: Cross-sectional study.
Setting: University research laboratory.
Participants: Subjects with DPN (n=70 [35 men, 35 women];
mean age SD, 65.48.6y) and healthy control subjects
(n=54 [12 men, 42 women]; mean age SD, 57.96.1y) were
recruited.
Interventions: Not applicable.
Main Outcome Measures: The thickness and stiffness of the
plantar soft tissues were measured by the tissue ultrasound
palpation system over the pulp of the big toe (BT), first meta-
tarsal head (MTH), second MTH, and the heel.
Results: No significant difference in the thickness of the
plantar soft tissues was found in any measurement site between
the diabetic group and control group. The plantar soft tissues of
the DPN group were significantly stiffer than those of the
control group at the BT (85.29kPa vs 50.49kPa), first MTH
(96.29kPa vs 62.05kPa), second MTH (84.77kPa vs 52.93kPa),
and the heel (65.62kPa vs 44.95kPa) (all P.01).
Conclusions: People with DPN tend to have stiffer plantar
tissues than do healthy control subjects. The stiffer plantar soft
tissues may reduce the cushioning effects of the foot during
walking for people with DPN.
Key Words: Biomechanics; Diabetes mellitus; Elasticity;
Foot; Rehabilitation; Ultrasonography.
© 2011 by the American Congress of Rehabilitation
Medicine
L
OWER LIMB COMPLICATIONS in people with diabetes
are common and can influence the quality of life of these
patients and the extent to which they will make use of the
health care system. Diabetic peripheral neuropathy (DPN) is
one of the most common diabetic complications, occurring in
up to 50% of people with diabetes,
1
and it can be an important
predisposing factor leading to foot ulcers.
2
Foot ulceration is
one of the major causes of hospitalization for people with
diabetes. Fifty percent of all nontraumatic lower limb amputa-
tions were performed because of diabetic complications.
3
Therefore, early identification of people who are at risk for
developing foot ulcerations is essential for preventing compli-
cations from diabetes.
A change in the thickness and stiffness of the plantar soft
tissues, together with peripheral neuropathy,
4
high plantar foot
pressure,
5
previous foot trauma, or foot deformities,
4
could be
a possible risk factor for diabetic foot ulcerations. Recent
technical advancements make it possible to quantitatively as-
sess the thickness and stiffness of plantar soft tissues. The
thickness of plantar tissues reflects morphologic changes in soft
tissues, whereas their stiffness reflects the major mechanical
property of soft tissues. The thickness and stiffness of plantar
soft tissues of healthy subjects have been investigated in pre-
vious studies using ultrasonography.
6,7
Previous work on the diabetic foot has examined the thick-
ness of different tissues such as the plantar fascia
8
or the
plantar fat pads.
9
D’Ambrogi et al
8
found an increase in both
the thickness of the plantar fascia and the vertical forces under
the metatarsal head (MTH) in people with diabetes (who may
or may not have neuropathy). They demonstrated a positive
correlation between the thickness of plantar soft tissues and the
vertical forces under the MTH (r=.52). As compared with a
healthy control group, Bus et al
9
showed that the fat pads in the
plantar tissues of DPN subjects with toe deformities were
significantly thinner under the MTHs but thicker under the
phalanges. They postulated that this alteration in fat pad thick-
ness could be due to the distal movement of fat pads caused by
toe deformities. Most of these studies tested on the individual
layer of the plantar tissues. However, the total plantar soft
tissue thickness is composed of various layers of tissues in-
cluding the plantar skin, fat pads, fascia, and muscle. This total
thickness of plantar soft tissues should be considered as a
whole when it serves as the cushion for optimizing load-
bearing during ambulation. Very few studies have examined
the total thickness of the plantar soft tissues at various sites of
the sole in subjects with DPN. It is unclear whether the total
thickness of the entire plantar tissue is altered in DPN subjects,
or whether such a change only occurs in specific locations of
the foot.
Stiffness indicates the perceived hardness or elasticity of
the material when a compression force is applied. The
presence of stiffer structures in a diabetic subject’s foot
reduces the ability of the foot to disperse forces over a
From the Departments of Rehabilitation Sciences (Sun, Cheng, Cheing) and Health
Technology and Informatics (Zheng, Huang), The Hong Kong Polytechnic Univer-
sity, Hong Kong; and Department of Integrated Medical Services, Ruttonjee Hospital,
Hong Kong (Leung), China.
Supported by a General Research Fund provided by Research Grants Council in
Hong Kong (PolyU 5131/06E).
No commercial party having a direct financial interest in the results of the research
supporting this article has or will confer a benefit on the authors or on any organi-
zation with which the authors are associated.
Reprint requests to Gladys L. Cheing, PhD, Dept of Rehabilitation Sciences,
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hung Hom, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR,
China, e-mail: gladys.cheing@inet.polyu.edu.hk.
0003-9993/11/9209-01093$36.00/0
doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2011.03.015
List of Abbreviations
BT big toe
DPN diabetic peripheral neuropathy
MTH metatarsal head
SWMF Semmes-Weinstein monofilament
1484
Arch Phys Med Rehabil Vol 92, September 2011