Dissipative Design of Observers for Multivalued Nonlinear Systems
Marisol Osorio and Jaime A. Moreno
Abstract— In this article, a new dissipativity based method-
ology to design observers for nonlinear systems is extended to
cover systems with discontinuous and non monotone nonlinear-
ities. A generalization and improvement of previous results for
this class of systems is obtained. The class of systems covered
are those in Lur’e form, with a LTI system in the feedforward
and a discontinuous or multivalued nonlinearity in the feedback
path.
I. INTRODUCTION
Although discontinuous systems are present in control
since the early days, classical control theory is mainly
developed for systems with smooth nonlinearities. This is
probably related to the mathematical difficulties involved
in a rigorous treatment of discontinuous systems, as for
example, the lack of existence and uniqueness of solutions
for these kinds of systems in a classical sense. However, in
the last years a renewed interest in discontinuous systems
has appeared, and a rigorous treatment is now made pos-
sible by the advances in multivalued differential equations
and differential inclusions. Moreover, besides the intrinsic
interest in mechanical systems, where friction and backslash
nonlinearities, for example, are naturally discontinuous or
multivalued, the increasing interest in switching and hybrid
systems calls for the necessity of studying more deeply the
class of discontinuous dynamical systems.
Although observation issues for dynamic systems is a
basic topic in control theory relatively few work has been
done for general classes of discontinuous or multivalued
systems. There are many publications dealing with the prob-
lem of inserting discontinuities in the observer [14], [9],
[26], in order to obtain a improved estimate. For switching
nonlinearities there is also a big amount of literature, in
particular for the observation of hybrid and switching linear
systems (see for example [18], [8], [4], and the references
therein). However, only few observation results are known
for general nonlinear, discontinuous or multivalued systems.
An exception is the work of Juloski [18], [17], where an
observer design for nonlinear systems of the Lur’e type,
with a linear time invariant system in the forward path and
a discontinuous or multivalued nonlinearity in the feedback
path, is proposed. The basic idea of the method is borrowed
from the circle criterion observers proposed by [1], [2] for
This work has been done with the financial support of DGAPA-UNAM
under project PAPIIT IN111905-2, UPB and Colciencias.
M. Osorio is with Escuela de Ingenier´ ıa, Grupo de Investigci´ on en
Autom´ atica y Dise˜ no, Universidad Pontificia Bolivariana, Cir. 1 Num. 70-
01, Medell´ ın, Colombia mosorio@upb.edu.co
J.A. Moreno is with the Coordinaci´ on de Automatizaci´ on, Instituto de In-
genier´ ıa, Universidad Nacional Aut´ onoma de M´ exico, Ciudad Universitaria,
04510 M´ exico, D.F., Mexico JMorenoP@ii.unam.mx
Lure systems with smooth nonlinearities. Similarly to [1],
[2], hard restrictions are imposed on the systems that can
be treated by the method proposed in [18], [17], heavily
restricting its applicability. The most important requirements
of this method are:
(i) The nonlinearities are restricted to be square, i.e. the
number of inputs and outputs has to be equal.
(ii) The nonlinearities are restricted to be (maximal)
monotone.
(iii) The designed observer is required to have unique
solutions, despite of the fact that the observer is a
discontinuous/multivalued nonlinear system.
Recently, one of the authors [19] has proposed a method-
ology to design nonlinear observers for smooth nonlinear
systems that can be transformed to the Lur’e form, based
on the dissipativity theory, the so called Dissipative Design
Technique. This method generalizes the circle criterion de-
sign [1], [2], eliminating both restrictions (i) and (ii). More-
over, many well-known observer design strategies can be
treated and improved in a unifying manner by the dissipative
method. So, for example, the High-Gain [13], the Thau [21],
the circle criterion [1], [2] and the Lipschitz [20] observer
design methods are special cases of the method proposed in
[19].
The objective of this work is to extend the dissipa-
tive design of [19] to the case of nonlinear discontinu-
ous/multivalued systems. It will be shown that this is pos-
sible and advantageous, so that the restrictions (i), (ii) and
(iii) of the method proposed in [18], [17] are eliminated.
Requirement (iii), in particular, although attractive for the
numerical realization and from a simulation point of view,
is very restrictive. It is well known that for systems with
discontinuous or multivalued nonlinearities the uniqueness
of solutions is more the exception than the rule [7]. So,
a general observation theory for this class of systems has
to consider observers with multiple solutions. Due to this
fact a big amount of effort has been done in [18], [17] to
assure the well-posedness, i.e. the existence and uniqueness
of solutions, of the method. Since well-posedness is not
required in this paper, only the existence of solutions has
to be assured, that is a much easier and good understood
issue for differential inclusions. Of course, the price to be
paid is the difficulty in establishing numerical algorithms that
converge to the solutions of the observer, an issue shared by
the whole field of differential inclusions. A further advantage
of the proposed method is that for the observer design in
most cases Linear Matrix Inequalities (LMIs) can be used,
for which excellent and efficient numerical algorithms exist
Proceedings of the 45th IEEE Conference on Decision & Control
Manchester Grand Hyatt Hotel
San Diego, CA, USA, December 13-15, 2006
FrB05.5
1-4244-0171-2/06/$20.00 ©2006 IEEE. 5400