E-Mail karger@karger.com
Short Report
Eur Neurol 2014;72:271–272
DOI: 10.1159/000364904
Aquaporin-1 Antibody in Neuromyelitis Optica
Patients
Erdem Tüzün
a
John Tzartos
c
Esme Ekizoğlu
a
Christos Stergiou
c
Paraskevi Zisimopoulou
c
Arzu Çoban
a
Erkingül Shugaiv
a
Recai Türkoğlu
b
Murat Kürtüncü
a
Betül Baykan
a
Socrates Tzartos
c
a
Department of Neurology, Istanbul Faculty of Medicine, Istanbul University,
b
Department of Neurology,
Haydarpasa Numune Education and Research Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey;
c
Hellenic Pasteur Institute, Athens, Greece
agnostic biomarker [1]. However, in sev-
eral NMO cohorts more than 40% of NMO
patients have been found Aqp-4 antibody
negative [2, 3], prompting a search for oth-
er antibodies. Aqp-1 has aroused interest as
a potential autoantigen in NMO since it is
one of the major water channels of the cen-
tral nervous system (CNS), is abundantly
expressed by astrocytes and some NMO le-
sions might show reduced Aqp-1 expres-
sion [4–7]. In this study, Aqp-1 and Aqp-4
antibody measurements were conducted in
sera of NMO patients and controls.
Materials and Methods
Thirty consecutive NMO patients ful-
filling Wingerchuk’s revised diagnostic cri-
teria [1], 29 relapsing remitting multiple
sclerosis (MS) patients fulfilling revised
McDonald criteria [8], 29 idiopathic intra-
cranial hypertension (IIH) patients fulfill-
ing the modified diagnostic criteria [9] and
30 healthy individuals were included. Pa-
tients gave informed consent, which was
approved by the local medical research eth-
ics committee. All sera were collected dur-
ing an attack prior to treatment with ste-
roids, immediately centrifuged, stored in
aliquots at −70 ° C.
Antibodies to the extracellular region of
Aqp-4 were measured by cell-based assay
utilizing HEK cells transfected with Aqp-4
Key Words
Aquaporin-1 · Aquaporin-4 · Neuromyelitis
optica · Antibody · Autoimmunity
Abstract
Background/Methods: To find out the prev-
alence of aquaporin-antibody (Aqp-Ab) and
characterize Aqp-Ab associated clinical fea-
tures in NMO, Aqp-1 and Aqp-4-Abs were
examined using radioimmunoprecipitation
and cell-based assays, respectively. Results:
Aqp-4 and Aqp-1-Abs were detected in
20/30 and 8/30 NMO patients, respectively.
One patient was Aqp-1-Ab single-positive,
13 patients were Aqp-4-Ab single-positive, 7
patients were Aqp-4/Aqp-1-Ab double-posi-
tive and 9 patients were seronegative. All
double-positive patients had optic neuritis
during the first attack. Only 2/29 MS patients
and none of the control idiopathic intracra-
nial hypertension patients were Aqp-1-Ab
positive. Conclusion: Aqp-1-Ab is usually de-
tected in Aqp-4-Ab positive NMO patients
and might be involved in optic neuritis
pathogenesis. © 2014 S. Karger AG, Basel
Introduction
Aquaporin-4 (Aqp-4) antibody has
long been described in neuromyelitis opti-
ca (NMO) and been utilized as a useful di-
Received: March 17, 2014
Accepted: May 25, 2014
Published online: September 27, 2014
Erdem Tüzün, MD
Department of Neurology, Istanbul Faculty of Medicine
Istanbul University
TR–34390 Çapa, Istanbul (Turkey)
E-Mail drerdem @ yahoo.com
© 2014 S. Karger AG, Basel
0014–3022/14/0726–0271$39.50/0
www.karger.com/ene
DNA. Aqp-1 antibodies were detected by
radioimmunoprecepitation assay (RIPA).
All sera that were detected positive in RIPA
were further analyzed with ELISA with
Aqp-1 synthetic peptides to ensure that the
antibodies against Aqp-1 bind to the extra-
cellular domain of the protein [4]. Only
sera with antibodies to the extracellular
side of Aqp-1 were considered positive.
Results
Aqp-4 antibody was detected in 20
NMO patients and none of the MS patients,
whereas Aqp-1 antibody was detected in 8
NMO and 2 MS patients. IIH patients and
healthy controls were seronegative for both
antibodies. Only one NMO patient was
Aqp-1 antibody single positive (Aqp-1+), 7
NMO patients were Aqp-1 and Aqp-4 an-
tibody double positive (Aqp-1+/Aqp-4+),
13 NMO patients were Aqp-4 antibody sin-
gle positive (Aqp-4+) and 9 NMO patients
were seronegative (SN) for both antibodies.
Aqp-4+ positive patients had higher
EDSS scores than Aqp-1+/Aqp-4+ and SN
patients and both Aqp-1+/Aqp-4+ and
Aqp-4+ patients had higher attack num-
bers than SN patients. Double-positive pa-
tients had a significantly higher rate of op-
tic neuritis during the first attack than SN
patients. Other parameters were compa-
rable among groups (table 1). Retrospec-
Downloaded by:
Istanbul Universitesi
194.27.138.2 - 10/9/2014 8:19:04 AM