Proceedings of the 2008 International Conference on Electrical Machines Paper ID 844
978-1-4244-1736-0/08/$25.00 ©2008 IEEE
Research on a Simple, Cheap but Globally Effective
Condition Monitoring Technique for Wind Turbines
Wenxian Yang
1
, P.J. Tavner
1
, C.J. Crabtree
1
and Michael Wilkinson
2
1
New and Renewable Energy Group, School of Engineering, Durham University, Durham DH1 3LE, UK
E-mail: peter.tavner@durham.ac.uk
2
Garrad Hassan & Partners Ltd, St Vincent Works, Bristol BS2 0QD, UK
Abstract- Vibration measurement and lubrication oil analysis
are used in wind turbines (WT) as condition monitoring systems
(CMS). However, they do not provide a complete solution to the
WT CMS problem. The former measurement is sophisticated
with high hardware costs, suffering from spurious alarms; the
latter monitors the wear and fatigue of gears and bearings, but
cannot detect electrical abnormalities occurring in the WT
generator and electrical system. So, a simpler, cheaper but
moreover globally comprehensive WT CMS is still needed,
especially if the WTs are to go offshore, where they are
confronted with higher risks and difficulties of access. To meet
this requirement, a new WT condition monitoring technique has
been researched in this paper. As the WT operates over a widely
varying power range, dependant on the stochastic variations of
the wind, the monitoring signals are usually non-stationary. In
view of this, a wavelet-based adaptive filter is designed to extract
the power energy at prescribed, fault-related frequencies which
vary with time. The energy information obtained is then used as
an indicator of WT condition. The central frequency of the filter
is adaptive to the average rotational speed of the generator, and
the filter bandwidth depends upon the fluctuation of wind speed.
By using this filter, fault features can be extracted whether the
WT runs at fixed or variable speed. The proposed technique has
been experimentally validated on a WT Test Rig using both
synchronous and induction generators as exemplars. Experiments
prove that the proposed technique is efficient in assessing the WT
condition for both mechanical and electrical abnormalities.
I. INTRODUCTION
Nowadays, with the extensive use of WTs all over the world,
the condition monitoring of these machines is attracting
attention from both industry and academia. Currently, almost
all condition monitoring techniques being used in the wind
industry, e.g. vibration measurement and lubrication oil
analysis, are borrowed from other industries [1] where they
have achieved success. However, they have not yet proved
their success in the wind industry due to the peculiarities of the
WT, which has a slow and variable speed. The present
vibration-based condition monitoring systems (CMSs) are
sophisticated, costly and not necessarily adapted to all types of
WTs. The oil particle counter designed for detecting the
wear/fatigue of mechanical components is unable to detect
electrical failures occurring elsewhere in the WT. However,
reliability surveys show that WT electrical system has similar
or even higher failure rate than its mechanical system [2, 3].
For these reasons, a simpler, cheaper but moreover globally
comprehensive WT CMS is still needed and this paper will
report such a technique.
From a global view, the mechanical torque and speed of
driving shaft and the generator electric power output can
respectively be regarded as the input and output of a WT. As a
result of the electro-mechanical coupling of the generator, both
energy flows will be disturbed by mechanical and electrical
abnormalities occurring in WT. Therefore, in a theoretical
sense WT condition monitoring and fault diagnosis should be
applicable to either of them. However, the torque signal is
costly and difficult to extract in practice, so this research will
be based entirely on power signal analysis.
II. DESIGN OF A WAVELET-BASED ADAPTIVE FILTER
The Continuous Wavelet Transform (CWT) has
demonstrable merits in processing non-stationary WT signals
[5], therefore a wavelet-based adaptive filter, based on the
CWT, is designed in this work to extract the power energy at
various fault-related frequencies. The CWT of a real-time
signal ) (t x is defined as [6]
∫
∞
∞ -
⎟
⎠
⎞
⎜
⎝
⎛ -
= dt
a
b t
t x
a
a b CWT
*
) (
1
) , ( ψ (1)
where ) (t ψ is the mother wavelet, which is Morlet wavelet in
this work. a and b respectively represent the parameters of
wavelet scale and time-shift. The asterisk ‘*’ stands for the
complex conjugate.
Traditionally, the wavelet function ) (t ψ is dilated or
compressed continuously by changing the parameter a, so that
the signal components within frequency range
ω ∈ [0, half
sampling frequency] are projected onto appropriate frequencies
in the entire time-frequency space. An illustrative example of
the CWT is given in Fig.1.
It can be easily imagined that this conventional use of the
CWT will be computationally intensive. Moreover, most of the
calculations are unnecessary for machine condition monitoring,
because the fault-related frequencies are few, and the other
frequency band does not require analysis. In addition, a
computationally inefficient algorithm is less suitable for on-
line condition monitoring, than for off-line signal processing.
A more efficient algorithm for use on-line would extract only
the fault-related frequency components.
Two more difficulties limit the application of the CWT in
WT condition monitoring. The first is that the conventional
CWT manifests the signal in time-scale, rather than in time-