High-rate Photon Counting with Geiger-mode APDs
Mark A. Itzler, Mark Entwistle, and Xudong Jiang
Princeton Lightwave Inc., 2555 Route 130 South, Suite 1, Cranbury, NJ USA 08512
Abstract—We extend the gate repetition rate of matched
delay line transient cancellation to achieve 50 MHz pho-
ton counting with low afterpulsing and to study after-
pulsing effects in InGaAs/InP Geiger-mode avalanche
diodes using sub-nanosecond gated operation.
1. Introduction
The capability for high-rate detection of single photons
in the near-infrared (NIR) wavelength range from 0.9 –
1.6 µm has become imperative for many applications in
communications and optical sensing [1]. With greater
interest in applying single photon detection to commu-
nications-related fields such as quantum cryptography
and free space laser communications, historical limita-
tions on NIR photon counting rate in the range of 1 – 10
MHz have become a primary concern for many end us-
ers. For low-light-level imaging, detection at the single-
photon level provides the ultimate sensitivity possible,
but low counting rates constrain image acquisition rates
and dynamic range. The replacement of vacuum-tube
based single photon detectors with solid-state alterna-
tives is highly desirable but requires photon detection at
high rates. In this paper, we describe some of the chal-
lenges encountered in high-rate photon counting using
InGaAs/InP Geiger-mode avalanche photodiodes
(GmAPDs) and progress that has been achieved.
2. Challenges related to high-rate photon counting
Geiger-mode operation entails biasing an APD above its
breakdown voltage V
b
by an excess bias voltage V
ex
in a
metastable state in which a single electrical carrier in-
duced by a single photon can generate a macroscopic
pulse of current that is easily sensed using electronic
threshold detection. This avalanche current pulse must
be quenched by lowering V
ex
sufficiently close to zero
by either passive or active circuitry. One approach for
realizing very high counting rates (up to GHz frequen-
cies) is the use of high-speed switching of V
ex
on sub-ns
time scales. The sub-ns rise and fall times associated
with such short “bias gates” generate large capacitive
transients that can couple to the output line when the
gates are imposed on the SPAD. Therefore, fast-gating
circuits require the suppression of these capacitive tran-
sients to allow for the accurate avalanche detection.
Beyond appropriate transient cancellation techniques, the
main challenge to photon counting at high repetition
rates is a rate-dependent increase in dark count rate
known as afterpulsing. During each avalanche event, a
small fraction of avalanche carriers can be become
trapped at defect sites in the avalanche region of the
GmAPD. At a later time, these trapped carriers are then
released by thermionic emission. If the GmAPD is re-
armed while trapped carriers are still being released,
detrapping carriers can trigger additional dark counts.
This “afterpulsing” effect can be avoided by introducing
a sufficiently long hold-off time T
ho
to allow complete
detrapping before re-arming the GmAPD, but the use of
a long T
ho
constrains photon counting rates.
The only recent efforts to effectively mitigate after-
pulsing effects at high counting rates have focused on
reducing the amount of charge trapped per avalance by
minimizing the charge flow per avalanche. One method
for reducing avalanche charge flow is to use extremely
short excess bias gates, and this approach is consistent
with high frequency operation when photon arrival times
are sufficiently well-known. Any other technique used
to rapidly quench avalanches following their detection
would also limit charge flow (and subsequent charge
trapping), and in addition to fast active quenching, the
goal of rapid passive quenching has spawned interest in
developing a variety of “self-quenching” diodes.
3. Transient cancellation by matched delay lines
Bethune and Risk developed a transient cancellation
scheme [2,3] based on the use of two matched delay
lines―one inverting and one non-inverting―to linearly
cancel the parasitic capacitive transients resulting from
ns-scale gates, leaving any induced avalanche signal to
be detected on a flat baseline. Past implementations of
this scheme were limited to ~5 MHz operation [4,5] due
to unacceptably high afterpulsing for gate repetition rates
beyond this frequency. By improving the transient can-
cellation of this approach and achieving reduction in
current flow per avalanche, we have extended this tech-
nique to demonstrate 50 MHz gate repetition rates with
acceptable afterpulsing. The data in Fig. 1 illustrate cu-
mulative afterpulsing probabilities (i.e., total afterpulsing
probability per detected photon) as a function of photon
detection efficiency (PDE) for frequencies between 1
and 50 MHz. The demonstration of 50 MHz operation
with afterpulsing of 2.5% at 10.8% PDE represents a
5-10 X increase in gate frequency relative to past results
with this technique. To obtain these data, we have de-
veloped FPGA-based circuitry to count afterpulse events
in as many as 128 bias gates following a primary photon-
induced avalanche. This circuitry allows us to obtain
data much more rapidly than using traditional time corre-
348
TuS1 (Invited)
2:00 PM – 2:30 PM
978-1-4244-8939-8/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE