Commodification and Westernization:
Explaining Declining Nutritional Intake in
Contemporary Rural China
ZHUN XU AND WEI ZHANG
Despite China’s rapid growth in the past decade, Chinese rural residents suffer from a
continuing decline of both calorie and protein intakes.We investigate the dramatic historical
changes in nutritional intake in the Chinese countryside.There are two main explanations
for the decline: first, the changing demographic and economic structure contributes to a
lower demand for energy compared to traditional rural society; and, second, the rising cost
of non-food essential goods could lead to a squeeze in the food budget. Using both
national-level and provincial-level data, we find evidence for both factors.We further argue
that the current abnormally low level of nutritional intake is mainly due to commodifica-
tion in the context of diet westernization. Rural residents’ nutritional intake declines as
they divert their consumption from relatively cheap sources of energy (grain and vegetable)
to more expensive alternatives (meat and poultry) under a squeezed budget. The shocking
failure of sustaining a healthy rural population is a unique manifestation of the contradic-
tion in the Chinese agrarian relations.
Keywords: decline in nutritional intake, commodification, westernization, rural,
China
INTRODUCTION
China’s rapid growth in recent decades has been accompanied by a decisive increase in both
real per capita income and food consumption. One of the easiest measures of Chinese
people’s welfare is to look at what they have on the dinner table, because ‘food is heaven’,
according to an old Chinese saying. In general, the Chinese have been rapidly moving from a
plant-based to a meat-based diet in recent years (Zhai et al. 2014). Nowadays, China produces
500 million metric tons of grain and consumes even more, as it has recently become a major
importer on the global food market (Xu et al. 2014).
At the same time, however, China’s bon appétit seems not to be evenly shared amongst its
population, at least in terms of nutrition. There is a secular declining trend in nutritional
intake for the more than 600 million rural residents in China over the past decade. Figure 1
Zhun Xu, Assistant Professor, Department of Economics, Howard University, Washington, DC 20059, USA.
Email: xuzhunjune@gmail.com. Wei Zhang (corresponding author), Assistant Professor, School of Labour and
Human Resources, Renmin University of China, Beijing, China 100872. Email: wzhang12@ruc.edu.cn
The authors would like to thank Henry Bernstein, Carlos Oya, HairongYan, JingzhongYe, Qian Zhang, the
participants at the JAC special issue workshop at the China Agricultural University and the editors and
anonymous reviewers for their comments and suggestions.This research receives the support of aYoung Faculty
Research Grant from Renmin University of China.
Journal of Agrarian Change, Vol. 15 No. 3, July 2015, pp. 433–453.
© 2015 John Wiley & Sons Ltd doi: 10.1111/joac.12119