A Quantum Chemical and TST Study of the OH Hydrogen-Abstraction Reaction from
Substituted Aldehydes: FCHO and ClCHO
Nelaine Mora-Diez,
²,‡
J. Rau ´ l Alvarez-Idaboy,
‡,§
and Russell J. Boyd*
,²
Department of Chemistry, Dalhousie UniVersity, Halifax, NS, Canada B3H 4J3, Instituto Mexicano del
Petro ´ leo, 07730 Me ´ xico, DF, Mexico, and Laboratorio de Quı ´mica Computacional y Teo ´ rica, Facultad de
Quı ´mica, UniVersidad de La Habana, Habana 10400, Cuba
ReceiVed: April 18, 2001; In Final Form: May 29, 2001
In the present study, ab initio methods have been used to study the OH hydrogen-abstraction reaction from
two substituted aldehydes: FCHO and ClCHO. A complex mechanism in which the overall rate depends on
the rates of two competitive reactions, a reversible step where a reactant (or prereactive) complex is formed,
followed by the irreversible hydrogen abstraction to form the products, is corroborated. This mechanism was
previously shown to describe accurately the kinetics of the OH hydrogen-abstraction reaction from formaldehyde
and acetaldehyde. Classical transition state theory (TST) rate constants calculated with tunneling corrections,
assuming an unsymmetrical Eckart barrier, agree very well with experimental upper bound values. Activation
energy barriers and enthalpies of reaction have been estimated through CCSD(T) single point calculations
using MP2 geometries and frequencies and the 6-311++G(d,p) basis set.
Introduction
The atmosphere is a very complex chemical system and of
crucial importance to life on Earth. Aldehydes, known to play
an important role in the chemistry of the polluted troposphere,
1
are emitted as primary pollutants from partial oxidation of
hydrocarbon fuels and arise as secondary pollutants from the
oxidation of volatile organic compounds. Once in the atmo-
sphere, aldehydes may either photolyze or react further with
OH radicals, the most important tropospheric daytime oxidant,
or with NO
3
radicals during the nighttime.
The chemistry of the atmosphere is quite complex.
2
The life
cycles of the atmospheric species (including traces) are strongly
coupled, and the results of this are often unexpected. Depending
on their atmospheric lifetimes these species can exhibit an
enormous range of spatial and temporal variability, but every
substance emitted into the atmosphere is eventually removed
so that a biogeochemical cycle is established. To estimate the
lifetimes of pollutants in the atmosphere different removal
options have to be considered, and for this, the development of
a reliable database of atmospheric reactions is extremely
important. However, such reactions are often difficult to study
experimentally.
Since a likely tropospheric removal route for aldehydes in
the atmosphere is by the reaction with OH radicals, we focus
on this reaction that occurs according to the following overall
equation:
Previous calculations on the reaction of formaldehyde with
OH radicals
3
showed why the addition reaction of OH radicals
to the carbonylic double bond does not occur. A discussion
based on activation energy values and also on a comparison of
structural parameters of the TS of this reaction with those of
similar reactions clarified this topic.
Earlier experimental and theoretical studies on reactions
between OH radicals and aldehydes have been performed.
4,5
In
a former study
3
the OH hydrogen-abstraction reaction from
formaldehyde and acetaldehyde was examined by considering
a complex mechanism in which the overall rate depends on the
rates of two competitive reactions: a reversible step where a
reactant (or prereactive) complex is formed, followed by the
irreversible hydrogen abstraction to form the products. TST
6
was applied for the calculation of the rate constants with
successful results. Tunneling corrections were incorporated
assuming an unsymmetrical Eckart barrier.
The consideration of the reactant complex formation has two
important consequences in the kinetics calculations of these
systems since it explains the negative activation barriers
observed (especially for acetaldehyde) and also affects the rate
constant calculations, as it determines the barrier height of the
hydrogen-abstraction process and hence the value of the
tunneling correction. In view of the previous successful results,
we decided to extend these ideas to the OH hydrogen-abstraction
reaction from FCHO and ClCHO, for which only experimental
upper bound rate constants have been reported and activation
energy values are unknown.
4a,7,8
Formyl fluoride (FCHO) is one of the halogenated molecules
in the upper stratosphere and a major product of the degradation
in the troposphere of CH
3
CFH
2
(HFC-134a).
9
It is also a product
of the subsequent dissociation of fluorinated radicals that
originate in the atmosphere. Formyl chloride (ClCHO) is a
reactive molecule that forms as an atmospheric degradation
intermediate of several chlorinated hydrocarbons such as
CH
3
Cl, CH
2
Cl
2
, CHCl
3
, and hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs),
10
as well as from the tropospheric reaction of Cl atoms with
volatile organic compounds such as isoprene.
11
The reaction of
FCHO and ClCHO with OH radicals is supposed to be a
tropospheric removal route for these compounds.
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: boyd@is.dal.ca.
²
Dalhousie University.
‡
Universidad de La Habana.
§
Instituto Mexicano del Petro ´leo.
9034 J. Phys. Chem. A 2001, 105, 9034-9039
10.1021/jp011472i CCC: $20.00 © 2001 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 09/07/2001