The American Journal of Psychoanalysis, 2012, 72, (269–286)
© 2012 Association for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis 0002-9548/12
www.palgrave-journals.com/ajp/
HOW DOES NEUROBIOLOGICAL RESEARCH
INFLUENCE PSYCHOANALYTIC TREATMENTS?—
CLINICAL OBSERVATIONS AND REFLECTIONS
FROM A STUDY ON THE INTERFACE OF CLINICAL
PSYCHOANALYSIS AND NEUROSCIENCE
Svenja Taubner , Anna Buchheim, Roman Rudyk, Horst Kächele
and Georg Bruns
One of the counterarguments against empirical research in psychoanalysis is that research
negatively influences the treatment situation. In this paper, the impact of a neurobiological
study on psychoanalytically oriented treatments is presented from three different perspec-
tives: patients’ views, a study group of participating psychoanalysts and a clinical case
example. Twenty chronically depressed patients, 20 healthy controls and 16 psychoanalysts
participated in the project on research. Results show a clear influence of the neurobiological
study on the course of treatments. Patients consistently reported that study participation had
a positive impact on their treatment experiences. However, study participation was
conflictual for the psychoanalysts and forced them to carefully reflect on their unconscious
and conscious involvement to establish a psychoanalytic stance independent from empirical
research.
KEY WORDS: empirical research; study group of psychoanalysts; impact of research
on psychoanalytic treatment.
DOI:10.1057/ajp.2012.17
Svenja Taubner, Ph.D., Junior Professor, International Psychoanalytic University Berlin and
University of Kassel, Department for Psychology, Psychoanalyst, Germany.
Anna Buchheim, Ph.D., Professor of Clinical Psychology, University of Innsbruck, Institute of
Psychology, Psychoanalyst, Innsbruck, Austria.
Roman Rudyk, Dipl-Psych, Vice Chairman DGPT (German Society of Psychoanalysis, Psycho-
therapy, Psychosomatics and Depth Psychology), Lower Saxony; Supervisor, Psychoanalytic
Institute Bremen; Psychoanalyst in Private Practice, Germany.
Horst Kächele, M.D., Ph.D., Professor, International Psychoanalytic University Berlin, Psy-
choanalyst, Germany.
Georg Bruns, M.D., Ph.D., Professor of Medical Sociology, University of Bremen; Member of
German Psychoanalytic Association (DPV); Psychoanalyst in Private Practice, Germany.
Address correspondence to Svenja Taubner, Ph.D., International Psychoanalytic University
Berlin, Stomstrasse 2, 10555 Berlin, Germany; e-mail: svenja.taubner@ipu-berlin.de