Getting on track: civil service
reform in post-communist Hungary
Jan-Hinrik Meyer-Sahling
ABSTRACT This article explains Hungary’s status as a front-runner of civil
service reform in post-communist Europe and assesses the consequences of the rst
reform outcomes for the institutionalization of the politics–administration nexus. It
examines the degree of formal politicization of the ministerial civil service inherent
in the Civil Service Act of 1992 and argues that the formal legal framework
provides important instruments for political intervention in civil service policy.
Civil service reform had been on the agenda for almost a decade prior to the regime
change, creating strong proponents of reform. The 1992 Act institutionalized a
formally politicized politics–administration nexus and has shaped the practice of
ministerial personnel policy and subsequent civil service reforms until 2001. The
ideological divide in the party system and the absence of a ‘tolerant policy
entrepreneur’ are likely to slow down the process of further civil service reform,
while high levels of formal politicization are preserved.
KEY WORDS Civil service; Hungary; new institutionalism; politicization; post-
communism; public administration .
INTRODUCTION
Observers of the process of administrative transformation in post-communist
Europe have long argued that administrative systems in the region are on a
path towards gradual Westernization (Hesse 1993, 1998; König 1992; for a
critique of this perspective, see Goetz 1995; Goetz and Margetts 1999).
1
More
recent research on the ‘state after communism’ has demonstrated that public
bureaucracies in post-communist Europe ‘have proved strikingly resistant to
wholesale transformation, dashing notions that modern, “western-style” ad-
ministrations could be installed with minimal effort and maximal speed’
(Nunberg 1999: 265). Furthermore, research that explicitly deals with the
relationship between politicians and bureaucrats in post-communist central
executives has found that politico-administrative relations are characterized by
instability, as incoming governments show little willingness to continue to
work with the administrative staff who had served their predecessors (Verheijen
2001).
Journal of European Public Policy
ISSN 1350–1763 print/ISSN 1466-4429 online © 2001 Taylor & Francis Ltd
http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals
DOI: 10.1080/13501760110098305
Journal of European Public Policy 8:6 December: 960–979