PediatrBloodCancer2010;55:1160–1166
Effect of Adapted Physical Activity Sessions in the Hospital on Health-Related
Quality of Life for Children With Cancer: A Cross-Over Randomized Trial
Elodie Speyer, MSc, PhD student,
1
Aline Herbinet, PhD,
1,2
Anne Vuillemin, PhD,
1,
*
Serge Brianc ¸on, MD,
1
and Pascal Chastagner, MD, PhD
3
Background. To assess the efficacy of adapted physical activity
(APA) on health-related quality of life (HRQoL) of hospitalized chil-
dren and adolescents with cancer between 9 and 18 years of age.
Procedure. A two-sequence, four-period cross-over study, Activit´ es
PhysiquesenOncologieP´ ediatrique (APOP), compared hospital stay
with APA sessions versus hospital stay without APA sessions on
children’s HRQoL. Children and parents completed the child and
parent forms, respectively, of a HRQoL questionnaire, the Child
Health Questionnaire, on the last day of hospitalization. We used
mixed linear regression to determine the effect of treatment, of treat-
ment order and whether response to previous treatment influenced
HRQoL. Results. Thirtychildrenwereincluded(meanage13.6 ± 2.9
years; 18 males). Cross-over analysis revealed no effect of period
or interaction between APA and period. HRQoL was higher when
children practiced than did not practice APA during their hospital-
ization, as reported by both children and parents, for the dimensions
physical functioning (P < 0.0001), role/social-physical (P = 0.001),
self-esteem(P < 0.0001),andmentalhealth(P < 0.0001).Inaddition,
APA had a significant effect on the behavior dimension (P = 0.01), as
reportedbychildren,andonthebodilypaindimension(P = 0.0004),
as reported by parents. The highest significant difference in scores
between with and without APA was observed for the self-esteem
dimension (P < 0.0001) for both children and parents. Conclusion.
APA during hospitalization for children with cancer was associated
withbetterHRQoLformostoftheHRQoLpsychologicalandphysical
dimensions. Whether this effect is specific for children with can-
cer should be explored. Pediatr Blood Cancer. 2010;55:1160–1166.
© 2010 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
Key words: adapted physical activity; cross-over design; health-related quality of life; hospital; pediatric
hematology/oncology
INTRODUCTION
In France, cancer is the first cause of mortality due to disease
in young people. Cancer develops in 1 in 500 children before the
age of 15 years and 1 in 1,100 adolescents between 15 and 19
years old [1–3]. Cancer treatment usually requires repeated and/or
prolonged hospitalization. Several qualitative studies identified dif-
ferent hospitalization-related stressors such as invasive procedures,
fear of death, unfamiliar environment, or lack of activities [4–6].
Moreover, cancer treatment often involves painful procedures; chil-
dren undergoing cancer treatment have been reported to have more
acute physical problems (such as weight change, eating problems,
and hair loss) [7,8], psychological distress (such as pain, lack of self-
esteem, tiredness, sadness, and depression) [9], and complications
and/or modifications of health-related quality of life (HRQoL) in
the short-term than do children who have completed treatment [10–
12]. In addition, children with chronic diseases have a significantly
lower HRQoL than do healthy children [13].
Practising physical activity is known to decrease depressive pat-
terns and anxiety [14–16] and increase self-esteem [17] among
children and adolescents in both general and patient populations.
As well, exercise during cancer treatment has been found associated
with improvement of some physiological, physical, and psycho-
logical outcomes in children [18–22]. However, few studies have
explored the effects of physical exercise on children undergoing
treatment for cancer [19–22]. Some specialists consider that phys-
ical activity is inadvisable for children with cancer (especially
children with bone metastases, insufficient platelet count or other
serious deficiencies). Nevertheless, White et al. [23] recommended
that children with cancer practice physical activity during treatment,
assuming an adaptation of the dose, frequency, intensity, and type of
activity according to the phase of treatment. Despite the numerous
benefits of physical activity, children undergoing treatment were
found to have a physical activity level markedly reduced in both
amount and intensity as compared with those of a control group
[24]. Thus, children receiving treatment for cancer should increase
their physical activity. One solution could be to propose some indi-
vidual and/or group physical activity adapted to children with cancer
during their hospitalization course.
Bjork et al. [25] found that children need physical activity during
their hospitalization. Besides, children with cancer are interested
in play and activity during their hospital stay [25,26]. Although
many hospital departments integrate activities into the daily routine,
most of the activities are sedentary. For example, educators pro-
pose manual activities, volunteers bring games and books and play
with children, clowns and/or musicians visit, or volunteers accom-
pany children to activities inside the hospital. Consequently, some
physical activity would supplement the range of activities already
proposed in pediatric hospital departments. The introduction of
physical activity could allow children undergoing treatment to have
a different view of themselves because they would be physically
active, even though they are hospitalized.
1
Nancy-Universit´ e, Universit´ e Paul Verlaine Metz, Universit´ e Paris
Descartes, EA 4360 Apemac, Nancy, France;
2
Association pour la Pro-
motion du Sport chez l’Enfant Malade, APSEM, Nancy, France;
3
CHU
Nancy, Service d’h´ emato-oncologie p´ ediatrique, Nancy, France
Grant sponsors: Association pour la Promotion du Sport chez l’Enfant
Malade (APSEM); Ligue Franc ¸aise contre le cancer; F´ ed´ eration
Hospitali` ere Franc ¸aise.
Conflict of interest: Nothing to declare.
*Correspondence to: Anne Vuillemin, Ecole de Sant´ e Publique, Fac-
ult´ e de m´ edecine, 9 Avenue de la Forˆ et de Haye, BP 184, F-54505
Vandoeuvre-l` es-Nancy Cedex, France.
E-mail: anne.vuillemin@staps.uhp-nancy.fr
Received 4 January 2010; Accepted 18 May 2010
©2010Wiley-Liss,Inc.
DOI10.1002/pbc.22698
Publishedonline29July2010 inWileyOnlineLibrary
(wileyonlinelibrary.com).