Silicalite‑1 As Efficient Catalyst for Production of Propene from
1‑Butene
Palani Arudra, Tazul Islam Bhuiyan, Muhammad Naseem Akhtar, Abdullah M. Aitani,
Sulaiman S. Al-Khattaf,* and Hideshi Hattori
Center of Research Excellence in Petroleum Refining and Petrochemicals, King Fahd University of Petroleum & Minerals,
Dhahran 31261, Saudi Arabia
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Reaction of 1-butene was studied over silicalite-1 and
H-ZSM-5 zeolites with different Al contents (SiO
2
/Al
2
O
3
molar
ratio (Si/Al
2
) = 23, 80, and 280) to explore an efficient catalyst for
the formation of propene as well as to elucidate the reaction scheme
and the relevant acid sites involved in the reaction. The formation of
alkenes, including propene, increased and those of alkanes and
aromatics decreased with decreasing Al content. The percentage of
alkenes other than n-butene isomers was 60 C-wt % over silicalite-1
at 550 °C with 34.1 C-wt % propene. Over H-ZSM-5 with Si/Al
2
=
23, the formation of alkenes was negligible, and the main products
were alkanes and aromatics, the sum of alkanes and aromatics being
65.4 C-wt % at 550 °C. These product distributions are consistently interpreted by the successive reactions of oligomerization,
cracking, and hydrogen transfer. For oligomerization and cracking, in addition to strong acid sites on H-ZSM-5 zeolites, weak
acid sites present on silicalite-1 act as active sites. For the hydrogen transfer reaction of alkenes to form alkanes and aromatics,
strong acid sites are required. The scheme can also be applicable to the reactions of 1-pentene and 1-hexene. The weak acid sites
on silicalite-1 are assumed to be the silanol groups that act as Brønsted acid above 300 °C. The presence of strong acid sites on
H-ZSM-5 catalysts, which are the OH groups bridging to Si and Al, results in the consumption of alkenes by hydrogen transfer.
Removal of a part of Al contained in silicalite-1 as an impurity and enrichment of surface silanol groups on silicalite-1 resulted in
the improvement of the propene yield. It is concluded that silicalite-1 is an efficient catalyst for the formation of propene by the
reactions of light alkenes because of the absence of strong acid sites and the presence of weak acid sites.
KEYWORDS: silicalite-1, H-ZSM-5, 1-butene, propene, alkene cracking, hydrogen transfer, weak acid
H
ighly selective propene production has received much
attention in recent years because of its use in important
derivatives of polymers, intermediates, and chemicals. The
demand for propene is growing very rapidly, primarily driven
by a high growth rate of polypropylene usage.
1
Several propene production technologies have been inves-
tigated including methanol-to-olefin process, steam cracking,
propane dehydrogenation, catalytic cracking of C
4
-alkenes, and
metathesis.
2
Among these methods, the process of butene
cracking has attracted much attention because of the availability
of large and stable supplies of butene isomers from FCC and
stream cracking processes.
3-5
Cracking of C
4
to C
6
alkenes
appears to be a promising technology for production of
propene and ethylene.
6,7
The catalysts studied so far for the purpose of propene pro-
duction by cracking include H-ZSM-5, H-ZSM-48, PITQ-13,
and SAPO-34.
8-15
H-ZSM-5 showed a high propene yield of
35% after modification with phosphorus and lanthanum.
8
H-ZSM-48 showed a higher propene selectivity in C
4
-alkene
cracking compared with H-ZSM-5, although the reasons for the
high selectivity were not certain.
9
Zhu et al. studied the effects of zeolite pore structure and
Si/Al
2
ratio on the cracking of C
4
alkenes to propene.
11
A high
selectivity to propene was observed for the medium-pore
10-membered ring zeolites and the small-pore SAPO zeolite.
The smaller the pore size of the zeolites, the greater the extent
of suppression of the hydrogen transfer reaction of alkenes and
the higher the propene selectivity. The H-ZSM-5 with an Si/Al
2
ratio of 366 exhibited the best performance. Lin et al. reported
that the H-ZSM-5 modified with phosphorus to reduce the
number of strong acid sites showed the best performance in the
reaction of 1-butene to propene.
14
They suggested that
adjusting the acid site distribution is important. Zeng et al.
also reported that the phosphorus-modified PITQ-13 yielded a
high propene yield of 41.6 C-wt %.
15
They reported that the
modification with phosphorus weakened the acid sites to result
in the high yield of propene. Recently, Epelde et al. reported
that K-modified H-ZSM-5 showed a high yield of propene in
the reaction of 1-butene. They explained the role of K to hinder
Received: February 27, 2014
Revised: October 8, 2014
Research Article
pubs.acs.org/acscatalysis
© XXXX American Chemical Society 4205 dx.doi.org/10.1021/cs5009255 | ACS Catal. 2014, 4, 4205-4214