QTu3A.1.pdf Research in Optical Sciences © OSA 2014
Sending Quantum Correlations through Dispersive Media
Paul D. Lett
1
, Jeremy Clark
1
, Ryan Glasser
1
, Tian Li
1
, Quentin Glorieux
2
, Ulrich Vogl
3
, Kevin Jones
4
1 Joint Quantum Institute, National Institute of Standards and Technology
and the University of Maryland, Gaithersburg, Maryland 20899 USA
2 Laboratoire Kastler Brossel, Université Pierre et Marie Curie, 4 Place Jussieu, 75005 Paris, France
3 Institut of Optics, Information and Photonics University Erlangen-Nuremberg, 91058 Erlangen, Germany
4 Department of Physics, Williams College, Williamstown, Massachusetts 01267 USA
paul.lett@nist.gov
Abstract: We send one half of a bipartite entangled state through a dispersive medium and
examine the effects of normal and anomalous dispersion on the quantum entanglement,
correlations and arrival time of quantum mutual information.
OCIS codes: (270.0270) Quantum Optics; (270.65700) Squeezed states
1. Introduction
The propagation of classical information through dispersive media is well-understood. Normal dispersion leads to
“slow light” effects, while anomalous dispersion leads to apparent superluminal propagation or “fast light” effects.
These fast light effects are fully consistent with causality and even though the effects can be somewhat
counterintuitive they logically and consistently obey the familiar laws of physics. It is easy to argue that, in keeping
with causality, classical information cannot be advanced by sending it through an anomalously dispersive medium,
even though it is rather difficult to prove the negative experimentally. On the other hand, there seems to be nothing
to prevent quantum correlations, even in the form of quantum entanglement, from being advanced in an
anomalously-dispersive medium, as no superluminal signaling is enabled in this way. Nonetheless, it seems natural
to argue that quantum information, just like classical information, should not be able to be advanced. We explore
the advancement of quantum correlations by sending one half of a bipartite entangled state through an anomalously
dispersive medium. In this way we investigate the physical mechanisms that seem to act to constrain the system.
Dispersion in an optical system, normal or anomalous, is generated in conjunction with gain or loss. Causal
dispersion relationships, analogous to the familiar Kramers-Kronig relations for linear media, can be written for
nonlinear optical interactions as well. In particular, we can take advantage of the dispersion near a four-wave-
mixing (4WM) gain line in Rb vapor and the resulting rapid variation in the refractive index of the gas to create fast
and slow light conditions. The gain or loss involved in the process results in noise being added to the optical signal.
This noise affects our ability to discern an advance in any sort of signal sent through the medium.
The region of linear dispersion near a gain or loss feature is typically rather small, and generating information
whose spectrum fully fits within such a linearly-dispersive region is difficult. Classical analytic signals carry the
information everywhere; the earliest leading edge carries all of the same information as in a peak that follows. Non-
analytic points carry new information but also entail an infinitely broad spectrum, so that some frequency
components always travel around the linear dispersive region, leading to precursors that travel precisely at the speed
of light.
We address these difficulties by explicitly looking only at narrowband signals, generated by quantum
fluctuations, and measured by homodyne detection. Again taking advantage of a 4WM process in Rb vapor, we
generate quantum-entangled “twin beams,” whose correlations are stronger than classically possible [1]. We then
send one of these twin beams through either a fast or slow light medium and examine the effect on the intensity
correlations, quantum entanglement, and quantum mutual information. While it is not surprising that we find that
information, quantum or otherwise, cannot be advanced through a fast light medium, the manner in which these
measures behave can tell us something about the mechanisms that prevent such advancements.
Four-wave mixing (4WM) near atomic resonance lines in Rb vapor can generate strongly correlated twin beams
of light [1]. The process can also be used to create a nearly quantum-noise-limited phase-insensitive amplifier,
whose gain is associated with a rather sharp dispersive feature. The dispersion near a 4WM gain feature can be used
to generate either slow- or fast- light conditions [2,3]. Dispersion is associated with gain or loss in the system, each
of which will add noise to a signal. It is this added noise that seems to provide the physical means by which nature
prevents the advance of information.