Zamyadi et al | http://dx.doi.org/10.5942/jawwa.2012.104.0114
Journal - American Water Works Association
Peer-Reviewed
E466
2012 © American Water Works Association
Global climate change may have profound effects on water-
shed runoff and phosphorus loads. affecting the ecological state
of water bodies. In addition, potential water shortages from
prolonged droughts and elevated water temperature (Jeppesen,
2009) may enhance the dominance of potentially toxic cyano-
bacteria (CB) and their proliferation in drinking water sources
(Jöhnk et al. 2008; Paul, 2008; Dale, 2006; Elliott et al, 2006).
Infrequent sampling is conducted in most standard field moni-
toring programs (Newcombe et al, 2010; Chorus et al, 1999),
and the recommended frequencies miss many pollutant loading
events (AWWA, 2010; Zamyadi et al, 2007) that occur on
smaller time scales including CB proliferation. The rapid and
more frequent field-monitoring of in vivo concentrations of CB
is required to effectively manage risks associated with the pres-
ence of toxic CB for recreational activities (Pilotto et al, 2008),
drinking water production (McQuaid et al, 2011), and water
reuse (McFarlane et al, 2008).
Currently, the planktonic biomass is monitored by a combina-
tion of laboratory methods, including chlorophyll a (Chla) mea-
surement, microscopic counting, and taxonomic identification
(Bastien et al, 2011; AWWA, 2010; Newcombe et al, 2010). Chla
has been used for many years as an indicator of phytoplanktonic
biomass and is not specific to CB; it is also present in eukaryotic
algae. CB belong to the bacteria Monera and their reproduction
procedure, cell structure, and biochemistry are different from
eukaryotic algae (AWWA, 2010). Microscopic enumeration mea-
surements provide information on the number of cells and their
taxonomic distributions but may be subject to considerable sys-
tematic and operator error, particularly when filaments or colo-
nies are present (Ahn et al, 2007; Lawton et al, 1999). In addition
to being error-prone, microscopic enumerations are tedious—sev-
eral steps must be taken to prepare the samples, requiring special-
ized equipment operated by experts (Ziegmann et al, 2010;
Gregor et al, 2007). Other methods, such as continuous flow
cytometry and high-resolution digital photometry, can be used
for the task of counting and speciation of CB to the level of genus,
and even of species (Daly et al, 2007). Real-time quantitative
polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is also a promising technique
(Fortin, 2010). However, these methods require skilled personnel
and expensive instrumentation and are not yet rapid, cost-effec-
tive online technologies.
Online monitoring tools have been developed to estimate phy-
toplanktonic biomass (including CB, chlorophyta, cryptophyta,
and other algal groups). These tools are equipped with light-
emitting diodes (LED) and use spectral signature differentiation
algorithms to measure photosynthetic pigment’s fluorescence
(Parésys et al, 2005; Wilhelm, 2003; Beutler et al, 2002). The
aforementioned tools excite the accessory pigments and measure
the resulting florescence. The excited pigments transfer photons
to the Chla terminal receptor, which then emits a particular
wavelength (florescence; Krause et al, 1991). More in-depth
analysis of the spectral signatures makes it possible to distinguish
The applications of in vivo probes that can detect the fluorescence
of cyanobacterial phycocyanin are emerging and widely used for
cyanobacterial detection in source waters. The objectives of this
project were to study the sources of interferences involved with the
readings of five probes (three commercially available probes and
two prototype probes) using laboratory cultures and field samples.
To compare the direct readings of different probes, the probe
readings were presented in the form of a biovolume equivalent of
cyanobacteria. Inorganic turbidity and the presence of algal
biomass interfered with probe readings. A correction factor was
developed for the cyanobacteria probes using simultaneous
chlorophyll a measurements. The field data demonstrate that the
potential underestimation of cyanobacterial biomass that
corresponds to alert levels is a major issue with the application of
in vivo probes. These alert levels are used to trigger monitoring
and management actions. This study shows that the correlation
between a probe’s reading and cell count is almost meaningless,
and that the correlation to biovolume is a relevant option for
management purposes. Results show that probe users should be
fully aware of the sources of interferences when applying and
interpreting the results. In addition, the authors offer a novel
procedure that corrects for chlorophyll a interference.
Cyanobacterial detection using in vivo fluorescence probes:
Managing interferences for improved decision-making
ARASH ZAMYADI,
1
NATASHA MCQUAID,
1
SARAH DORNER,
1
DAVID F. BIRD,
2
MIKE BURCH,
3
PETER BAKER,
3
PETER HOBSON,
3
AND MICHÈLE PRÉVOST
1
1
Civil, Mineral and Mining Engineering Department, École Polytechnique de Montréal, Montréal, Québec, Canada
2
Department of Biological Sciences, Université du Québec à Montréal, Montréal, Québec, Canada
3
Australian Water Quality Centre, South Australia Water Corporation, South Australia, Australia
KEYWORDS: cyanobacteria, in vivo fluorescence, interference, phycocyanin probe, source management
Read the Expanded Summary