OIKOS 100: 483–492, 2003
Microgeographical variation in brown trout reproductive traits:
possible effects of biotic interactions
Esben Moland Olsen and Leif Asbjørn Vøllestad
Olsen, E. M. and Vøllestad, L. A. 2003. Microgeographical variation in brown trout
reproductive traits: possible effects of biotic interactions. – Oikos 100: 483 – 492.
This study documents substantial variation in reproductive traits among populations
of stream-dwelling brown trout (Salmo trutta L.) at a very small geographic scale.
Within two streams, we found a parallel pattern of variation, where females living
above major waterfalls produced fewer and larger eggs than conspecifics from below
the waterfalls. Four additional streams were represented with either a below-waterfall
site (n =2) or an above-waterfall site (n =2). When these streams were included in
the analyses, there was no consistent difference in reproductive traits between females
from above- and below-waterfall sites. There was no significant difference in total
reproductive investment among sites within streams, but considerable variation
among streams. Female first-year growth rates was estimated from scales, and
differed significantly among populations. Within streams, females from below water-
falls experienced higher first-year growth rates as compared to females from above
the waterfalls. Within seven out of eight populations, egg size increased significantly
with increasing female body length. Within three populations, we found evidence for
a trade-off between offspring size and offspring number, as a negative association
between fecundity and egg size independently of adult body size. Within three
populations egg size decreased significantly with increasing maternal first-year
growth, independently of adult body size. We suggest that the within-stream differ-
ences in offspring size/number strategies are influenced by population density and
growth effects. Earlier, we have shown that population densities are consistently
lower below the waterfalls in these streams. The Alpine bullhead (Cottus poecilopus )
is found only below the waterfalls and could influence brown trout demography.
E. M. Olsen and L. A. Vøllestad, Di. of Zoology, Dept of Biology, Uni. of Oslo, P.O.
Box 1050 Blindern, NO-0316 Oslo, Norway (e.m.olsen@bio.uio.no).
For a maturing female, limited resources may force
offspring size to be traded off against offspring number
(Sva ¨rdson 1949, Elgar 1990, Sinervo and Licht 1991).
Depending on the shape of the offspring size – off-
spring fitness function, maternal fitness could be maxi-
mized by producing many small offspring or few large
ones (Smith and Fretwell 1974, Lloyd 1987). Large
offspring often have a higher survival probability than
smaller offspring (reviewed by Roff 1992), and theory
predicts that optimal offspring size increases with de-
creasing resource abundance or quality (Sibly and
Calow 1983, Parker and Begon 1986, Winemiller and
Rose 1993, Hutchings 1997). This prediction rests on
the assumption that larger offspring are less affected by
scarcity of food than smaller offspring. As a specific
case, models predict that increasing the intensity of
sibling competition select for the production of smaller
clutches with larger eggs (Parker and Begon 1986).
Strong non-sib competition will select even stronger for
larger eggs. An increase in selective predation on
smaller offspring should give the same result. If off-
spring fitness does not depend on offspring size (above
a minimum physiological size), then fecundity should
be maximised (Hutchings 1997).
Salmonid fishes are excellent study subjects for test-
ing predictions from evolutionary theory. These fishes
often form reproductively isolated populations across a
diversity of environments and exhibit high levels of
Accepted 6 September 2002
Copyright © OIKOS 2003
ISSN 0030-1299
OIKOS 100:3 (2003) 483