Can. J. Earth Sci. 44: 695–705 (2007) doi:10.1139/E07-007 © 2007 NRC Canada
695
Neomorphism of the Middle Devonian Ratner
limestone related to dehydration of gypsum in
south-central Saskatchewan
Qilong Fu and Hairuo Qing
Abstract: The Middle Devonian Ratner Formation in south-central Saskatchewan consists of laminated carbonate and
interlaminated to interbedded carbonate and anhydrite, and the Ratner carbonate is preserved as limestone in many
cored intervals. Medium to very coarsely crystalline (MVC) limestone (up to 4 m in thickness) is dominantly present
in the uppermost part or the upper cycle of the Ratner Formation directly overlain by the Whitkow anhydrite. Gen-
erally, both abundance and size of the MVC calcite crystals decrease downward away from contact between the Ratner
carbonate and the Whitkow anhydrite. The average
87
Sr/
86
Sr ratio of the MVC calcite is 0.7078, comparable to that of
Middle Devonian seawater. The Ratner MVC limestone is interpreted to result from neomorphism of the precursor
microcrystalline lime mudstone in burial environments, and neomorphic fluids might have consisted of gypsum-
dehydration water mixing with minor various ratios of formation waters, based on petrographic observation, O- and Sr-
isotopic data, and stratigraphic evidence. This research provides a case study in which the neomorphism of limestone is
related to gypsum-dehydration water.
Résumé : La Formation de Ratner (Dévonien moyen) dans le centre-sud de la Saskatchewan est composée de carbonate
laminé et d’anhydrite interlaminée ou interstratifiée; le carbonate de la Formation de Ratner est préservé en tant que
calcaire dans des intervalles à multiples noyaux. Un calcaire (atteignant des épaisseurs de 4 m) à cristaux moyens à très
grossiers « MVC » domine la partie la plus élevée du cycle supérieur de la Formation de Ratner, laquelle est directe-
ment recouverte par l’anhydrite de Whitkow. L’abondance et la dimension des cristaux MVC de calcite décroissent générale-
ment vers le bas, en s’éloignant du contact entre le carbonate de Ratner et l’anhydrite de Whitkow. Le rapport moyen
87
Sr/
86
Sr de la calcite MVC est de 0,7078, ce qui est comparable à l’eau de mer au Dévonien moyen. Selon les inter-
prétations, le calcaire MVC de Ratner découlerait du néomorphisme de la calcilutite microcristalline dans un environne-
ment d’enfouissement et, selon les observations pétrographiques, des données d’isotopes de l’oxygène et du strontium
ainsi que des évidences stratigraphiques, des liquides néomorphiques pouvaient comprendre une eau déshydratant le
gypse tout en se mêlant à divers rapports mineurs d’eau de formation. Cette recherche fournit une étude de cas dans
laquelle le néomorphisme du calcaire est relié à l’eau de déshydratation du gypse.
[Traduit par la Rédaction] Fu and Qing 705
Introduction
The term neomorphism was introduced by Folk (1965) to
refer to processes of recrystallization and polymorphic trans-
formations where there may have been a change of mineralogy.
Recrystallization refers to petrographic and geochemical
changes without any change of mineralogy. Because carbonate
sediments may consist originally of low magnesium calcite,
high magnesium calcite, and (or) aragonite and the original
mineralogy of limestone is often difficult to determine (Tucker
1990), the term neomorphism is used here. Neomorphic pro-
cesses always take place in the medium of water, and
neomorphism of limestone is typically associated with crystal
growth and (or) transformations of metastable Mg-calcite
and aragonite to low-Mg calcite (Bathurst 1975; Tucker 1990).
Microspar and pseudospar were interpreted to result from
“aggrading neomorphism” (Folk 1965). Lasemi and Sandberg
(1984) suggested a one-step process of aragonite calcitization
leading to microspar. In some argillaceous carbonates, neo-
morphism took place by precipitation of progressively youn-
ger calcite on crystals at the growing margins of continuous
beds and nodules (Coniglio 1989).
A study of neomorphized rocks can provide information
of related fluid events. Medium to very coarsely crystalline
(MVC) limestone in the Middle Devonian Ratner Formation
is interpreted to result from neomorphism of the precursor
microcrystalline lime mudstone. This work is focused on the
formation of MVC limestone in the Ratner Formation and
provides a case study that neomorphism of limestone is greatly
influenced by gypsum-dehydration water.
Commercial oil has been produced from the Ratner car-
bonate reservoirs since 1997, and the Ratner rocks remain
underexplored (Kissling and Slingsby 1999; Nimegeers 2005).
In some cores of the Ratner Formation, abundant bitumen is
preferentially present in the MVC limestone. Investigation of
Received 19 June 2006. Accepted 30 January 2007. Published
on the NRC Research Press Web site at http://cjes.nrc.ca on
15 June 2007.
Paper handled by Associate Editor D. Lavoie.
Q. Fu
1
and H. Qing. Department of Geology, University of
Regina, Regina, SK S4S 0A2, Canada.
1
Corresponding author (e-mail: fuqilo11@uregina.ca).