Session M2E
1-4244-0257-3/06/$20.00 © 2006 IEEE October 28 – 31, 2006, San Diego, CA
36
th
ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference
M2E-21
Retention Implications of the Use of Hand-Held PC’s
in a First-Year Engineering Intro Course
Jerome Lavelle, Dianne Raubenheimer, and Brian Koehler
First Year Engineering Program, College of Engineering, NC State University
Raleigh, NC 27695
Abstract - This study investigated the effects of early
exposure to mobile technology on the academic success of
first-semester underrepresented populations in
engineering and computer science. Literature and data
show that underrepresented populations (women and
ethnic minorities) enrollment in engineering has been flat
(or slightly declining) over the period of the last 10 years.
The present study is directed at not recruiting more such
students to the pool, rather, it is directed at understanding
elements associated with keeping more of those who enroll
initially. Namely, it involves retention. In this study it was
observed that students using handheld computers
increased their self confidence in using technology and that
technology was not as distracting to them. However, due to
the small sample population, effects on retention and
matriculation rates were mixed.
Index Terms – Retention in Engineering, First Year
Engineering, Technology in Engineering Education.
BACKGROUND
This paper is concerned with the issue of student retention
among populations traditionally underrepresented in
engineering — women and ethnic minorities. At its core,
retention can be viewed as the “yield” activity of the education
enterprise. In engineering education, over the years, many
researchers have endeavored to understand the factors that
influence students’ success in engineering. This research
suggests that we do know a lot about student success in
studying engineering, and many substantial contributions have
been made to the body of knowledge concerning engineering
education. As an example, Felder et al., in a series of studies
which considered longitudinal data on student performance
and retention in engineering, looked at effects in an
introductory course [1], rural versus urban students [2], gender
differences [3], instructional methods [4], and comparisons
with traditionally taught students [5]. Others have focused on
first-semester students, such as Besterfield-Sacre et al. who
developed a model for understanding success of first-semester
students [6]. Hutchinson et al. looked at factors affecting first-
semester engineering students’ self-efficacy beliefs [7], and
Olds and Miller looked at the effects of an integrated first-year
curriculum [8]. Felder and Brent [9] and Spurlin et al.[10]
focused on the effects of how students learn.
What we know is that engineering education has changed,
and continues to change [11] for the better due to influences of
industry and government constituents [12], accreditation
requirements [13], and our increased understanding of student
learning of engineering as an academic field.
Retention Efforts at NC State:
NC State’s college of engineering graduated the second
highest number of BS engineers in the USA in 2004. In
addition, the college is consistently in the top national tier in
enrollment, and graduation of, female and African American
engineers. As the flag-ship land grant engineering school in
the state, we work very hard at creating opportunities for a
broad range of students. Recruitment is only the beginning
chapter of the student success story – retention, matriculation
and graduation are very important follow-on steps. Over the
years the college has been involved with several important
retention activities. Below are a sampling of these:
1. SUCCEED [14]: SUCCEED is a National Science
Foundation sponsored education coalition of eight
southeastern USA engineering colleges who are
committed to revitalizing undergraduate engineering
education. As a member, NC State’s participation has
resulted in the formation of the First Year
Engineering Program, re-design of the E101
engineering intro course, development of faculty/TA
workshops, mentoring and bridge programs, and a
laptop program. All of these efforts ultimately deal
with student success.
2. Minority Engineering Programs (MEP) [15]: The NC
State MEP activities are targeted at recruiting and
retaining students from underrepresented ethnic
populations in engineering. Activities include:
mentoring and bridge programs, a two-semester
student success course, student professional societies
(NSBE, AISES, SHPE), and minority visitation
events.
3. Women in Engineering Program (WIE) [16]: The
WIE Program sponsors activities to enable female
engineers success. Activities include sponsorship of
SWE, peer mentoring, email mentoring, and women
in computer science.
4. Women in Science and Engineering (WISE) [17]:
The WISE program at NC State is a multi-college
collaboration aimed at increasing the number, and