© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved.
Enhancement of anhydrous proton transport by
supramolecular nanochannels in comb polymers
Yangbin Chen
1
, Michael Thorn
2
, Scott Christensen
3
, Craig Versek
2
, Ambata Poe
1
, Ryan C. Hayward
3
*
,
Mark T. Tuominen
2
*
and S. Thayumanavan
1
*
Transporting protons is essential in several biological processes as well as in renewable energy devices, such as fuel cells.
Although biological systems exhibit precise supramolecular organization of chemical functionalities on the nanoscale to
effect highly efficient proton conduction, to achieve similar organization in artificial systems remains a daunting challenge.
Here, we are concerned with transporting protons on a micron scale under anhydrous conditions, that is proton transfer
unassisted by any solvent, especially water. We report that proton-conducting systems derived from facially amphiphilic
polymers that exhibit organized supramolecular assemblies show a dramatic enhancement in anhydrous conductivity
relative to analogous materials that lack the capacity for self-organization. We describe the design, synthesis and
characterization of these macromolecules, and suggest that nanoscale organization of proton-conducting functionalities is
a key consideration in obtaining efficient anhydrous proton transport.
E
fficient and selective transport of protons is critical both in
biological contexts
1
and in materials for renewable energy
2
.
In biological systems, nature has optimized proton conduction
on a nanometre scale by using secondary and tertiary structures of
proteins to arrange precisely the appropriate side chains of amino
acids, for example in the membrane protein M2 (refs 3–5).
Although control of proton transfer on this scale is adequate for
most biological processes, it is essential that efficient proton conduc-
tion be obtained on a micron scale for clean-energy applications
6,7
.
In hydrogen fuel cells, for example, after oxidation of molecular
hydrogen at the anode, the resulting protons must be transported
across a selective membrane to reach the cathode and complete
the conversion of chemical energy into electrical energy. The
proton conductivity of this membrane, often called the proton-
exchange membrane or the polymer electrolyte membrane (PEM),
has been one of the bottlenecks to achieving affordable fuel-cell
technology. Nafion, a poly(tetrafluoroethylene)-based polymer
with sulfonic acid groups arranged at intervals along the backbone,
is one of the most widely used materials for this membrane
8
. The
key to proton transport in Nafion is thought to be nanochannels
of sulfonic acid groups, through which ‘hydrated’ protons can
pass efficiently
9–11
. Although a good proton conductor for hydrated
protons, Nafion suffers from poor conductivity in unassisted proton
transfer, that is Grotthuss or anhydrous proton transfer
12,13
, which
results in low conductivities at temperatures above the boiling
point of water. PEMs with high proton conductivities at tempera-
tures of 120–200 8C are desirable, because operation at higher temp-
eratures can increase fuel-cell efficiency, reduce cost, simplify heat
management and provide better tolerance of the catalysts against
poisoning
14
.
One approach to address this issue is to use amphoteric func-
tional groups that allow anhydrous proton transport
15,16
, for
example imidazole, which is a common motif in biological proton
transport in the form of the amino acid histidine. Several groups
have studied synthetic polymers that contain such amphoteric func-
tional groups as candidates for high-temperature proton transfer
17–22
.
Although a number of interesting candidate materials were
identified, one avenue that was not explored in these anhydrous
proton-conducting systems is the role of supramolecular organiz-
ation in nanoscale ion-conducting channels. This is surprising
because, in the context of hydrated proton-conducting systems,
such as Nafion
9–11
,
and sulfonated block copolymers
12,23–26
, as well
as lithium-ion conducting supramolecular assemblies
27–29
, it is
well-established that the formation of nanoscale domains enriched
in the ion-conducting materials is critical to the resulting macro-
scopic ionic conductivity.
In this paper, we describe the molecular design and synthesis of a
novel class of comb polymers with amphoteric proton-transfer
functionalities that can self-assemble into organized supramolecular
structures. We also show that very subtle changes in the monomer
and analogous polymer provide solid-state structures that lack
such nanoscale organization. By comparing these polymers, we
show that the self-assembled structures yield a dramatic increase
in proton conductivity (by as much as three orders of magnitude),
presumably because of the locally increased concentration of
proton-transport functionalities within the nanophase-separated
domains. These results suggest that a careful consideration of
macromolecular architecture and nanoscale assembly is critical to
optimizing anhydrous proton transport in new materials for PEMs.
Results
To prepare polymers that form supramolecular assemblies with
proton-transporting functionalities concentrated within nanoscale
domains, we made use of comb polymer architectures (Fig. 1).
One of our groups recently used this architecture to prepare amphi-
philic comb polymers by attaching lipophilic and hydrophilic func-
tionalities at the meta-positions of the benzene ring of each styrenic
repeat unit
30,31
. Such polymers were shown to form assemblies of a
micelle type in aqueous milieu and of an inverse-micelle type in
apolar organic solvents. Thus, we hypothesized that similar poly-
mers would also form nanoscale assemblies in the melt state. For
this purpose, we designed a series of styrenic comb polymers in
which one of the meta-positions contained a polar N-heterocyclic
functionality capable of proton transport, and the other contained
1
Department of Chemistry,
2
Department of Physics,
3
Department of Polymer Science and Engineering, University of Massachusetts, Amherst,
Massachusetts 01003, USA. *e-mail: thai@chem.umass.edu; tuominen@physics.umass.edu; rhayward@mail.pse.umass.edu
ARTICLES
PUBLISHED ONLINE: 25 APRIL 2010 | DOI: 10.1038/NCHEM.629
NATURE CHEMISTRY | VOL 2 | JUNE 2010 | www.nature.com/naturechemistry 503