High Voltage Series-Compensated Transmission Line
- Evaluation of New Distance Protection
Eugeniusz Rosolowski,
Jan Izykowski
Piotr Pierz
Wroclaw University of Technology, Wroclaw, Poland
eugeniusz.rosolowski@pwr.wroc.pl
jan.izykowski@pwr.wroc.pl
piotr.pierz@wp.pl
Marek Fulczyk
Przemyslaw Balcerek
ABB Corporate Research Center
Krakow, Poland
marek.fulczyk@pl.abb.com
przemyslaw.balcerek@pl.abb.com
Murari Mohan Saha
ABB AB
Västerås, Sweden
murari.saha@se.abb.com
Abstract—This paper investigates a new distance protection
principle for a transmission line compensated with 3-phase
capacitor banks installed in the middle of the line. Series
Capacitors (SCs) equipped with Metal-Oxide Varistors (MOVs),
when set on a transmission line, create certain problems for its
protective devices. Direct application of the classic distance
protection (designed for traditional lines) to series-compensated
lines results in considerable shortening of the first zone reach
and also in poor transient behaviour. In order to overcome these
difficulties the new distance protection principle for the first
zone has been developed. The detailed model of considered
transmission lines including the SCs&MOVs banks as well as
the measurement channels has been developed. Using this
model, the reliable fault data has been generated for evaluation
of the new distance protection principle under variety of fault
conditions. The study has shown considerable improvement of
series-compensated line protection as a result of applying the
developed new principle.
I. INTRODUCTION
The problems with protective relaying for series
compensated lines are being extensively explored as a series
of studies have been performed by relay vendors and utilities
[3]–[7]. The new distance protection concept relies on
determining the conditional impedances and comparing them
with three characteristics specially shaped on the impedance
plan by additional first zone logic module. For the considered
transmission line one can distinguish the following conditional
impedances: – impedance without compensation (Z), –
impedance with compensation (Zc). The respective
“compensated” impedance Zc is calculated from the fault loop
quantities composed as for the classic distance relays, but with
the compensation in case of the fault loop voltage. The
compensation is performed for the voltage drop across the
capacitor bank. For this purpose the instantaneous voltage
drops across SCs&MOVs have to be estimated on the base of
the parameters of SCs&MOVs and locally measured phase
currents in Bus A. The distance relay algorithm based on
differential equation method with rectangular differentiations
and orthogonal components (by half-period Fourier filtration).
Reconstruction of the waveform of the voltage drop across
SC&MOV based on the fast on-line solving the nonlinear
differential equation combined with multiplying sampling
frequency technique
At the final stage all methods realize the first zone logic
for fault detection in serial compensated line with is detailed
described in [11]. The brief characteristic of the basic idea, is
as follows :
• the algorithm estimates the voltage drops across series
capacitors and MOVs (in all three phases) based on
the currents at the relaying point by on-line solving an
appropriate non-linear differential equation,
• the relay compensates the phase voltages for the
estimated voltage drops across SCs&MOVs,
• two impedances are next calculated: the first one (Z)
results from measured voltages and currents (no
compensation), the second one (ZA) results from
measured currents and compensated voltages
(compensation),
• location of the measured impedances is checked with
respect to three specially shaped regions on the
impedance plane and depending on the checking
results and the trip permission from the impedance
unit is sent,
II. CALCULATION OF THE VOLTAGE DROPS
ACROSS SCS&MOVS
Let’s consider a parallel connection of series capacitor C
and MOV as shown in Fig. 1. The v-i characteristic of the
MOV is commonly approximated by the following
exponential equation:
q
REF
x
MOV
V
v
P i
⎟
⎟
⎠
⎞
⎜
⎜
⎝
⎛
=
(1)
978-1-4244-8286-3/10/$26.00 ©2010 IEEE 513