Progression of cognitive impairment in
stroke patients
P.S. Sachdev, MD, PhD, FRANZCP; H. Brodaty, MD, FRACP, FRANZCP; M.J. Valenzuela, BSc (Hons);
L. Lorentz, M Clin Psychol, MAPS; and A. Koschera, PhD
Abstract—Objective: To examine the progression of neuropsychological deficits in stroke patients with and without
cognitive impairment. Methods: The authors assessed the Sydney Stroke Study cohort 1 year after index assessment with
detailed neuropsychological and medical–psychiatric assessments. The neuropsychological tests were classified into cogni-
tive domains, and composite z-scores adjusted for age and education. Changes in cognitive test scores were compared
between groups and predictors of cognitive change examined. Results: Patients (n = 128) had a mean decline of 0.83 (SD
2.2) points on the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) compared to an increase of 0.76 (1.3) in controls (n = 78) (p
0.0001), and a small but significant decline in informant ratings of function and cognition. The decline on a composite
index of cognitive function was not significantly different in the groups after correction for age, education, and index
assessment cognitive function. Stroke/transient ischemic attack patients, however, had greater decline in verbal memory
and visuoconstructive function. The occurrence of an interval stroke (n = 14) significantly increased the cognitive decline
to a mean 2.0 points on the MMSE. The rate of change had a significant correlation (r = 0.24) with white matter
hyperintensity volume at index assessment. On regression analysis the only predictor of cognitive change was years of
education, which had a protective function. Conclusions: Subjects with cerebrovascular disease have a slow decline in
cognitive functioning in the absence of further cerebrovascular events, although the occurrence of such an event accentu-
ates the dysfunction. Education plays a protective role.
NEUROLOGY 2004;63:1618 –1623
Cognitive impairment is commonly present in stroke
patients, with about a quarter meeting criteria for
vascular dementia (VaD).
1,2
Most published studies
have assessed cognitive function in ischemic stroke
patients at 3 months or more after the stroke, with
the expectation that cognitive deficits have stabilized
at this stage, after a period of initial recovery.
2
The
few studies that have assessed stroke patients longi-
tudinally over extended periods
3-6
report further re-
covery in a few subjects but cognitive decline in the
overall sample. The rate of change and the detailed
neuropsychological profile of this decline, i.e., the
cognitive domains most likely to change, have not
been adequately investigated.
The course of vascular cognitive impairment (VCI)
has been recently reported.
7
VCI is referred to here
as a superordinate construct that includes all levels
of cognitive impairment of vascular origin.
8
Many
but not all patients involved in the studies of pro-
gression of VCI had a history of stroke or TIA. These
studies suggest that deficits of VCI are progressive,
although the changes are variable depending upon
the sample being studied. While earlier studies sug-
gested that mortality rates were higher in VaD com-
pared to Alzheimer disease (AD),
9
the rate of
cognitive decline in VaD appears to be slower than
AD.
10
This is supported by the placebo arms of the
recent trials of cholinesterase inhibitors in VaD.
11-13
A detailed examination of the progression of cogni-
tive deficits in patients with ischemic vascular brain
lesions is therefore of considerable interest.
We report a longitudinal study of stroke patients
who were initially assessed at 3 to 6 months after a
stroke or TIA and followed up a mean 14.6 months
later to determine the profile and determinants of
cognitive decline over 1 year.
Methods. Sample. Subjects were consecutive patients, admit-
ted to two large teaching hospitals affiliated with the University
of New South Wales, who had recently had an ischemic stroke or
TIA and had agreed to participate in the Sydney Stroke Study.
1,14
Subjects were recruited over a 38-month period between May
1997 and June 2000. Subjects were aged 49 to 87 years, did not
have a diagnosis of dementia or other neurologic disorder prior to
the stroke/TIA, did not have severe aphasia as a limiting factor for
assessment, and were well enough to consent to participate.
Healthy control subjects were unpaid age-matched volunteers, re-
cruited from the same neighborhood as the stroke/TIA subjects.
They had no history of stroke, TIA, or other neurologic or psychi-
atric disorder. In all, 1,050 patients were screened and 252 consid-
ered eligible and recruited. At the time of detailed assessment 3 to
6 months later, 210 patients (176 stroke and 34 TIA) and 103
controls were included in the study. Of these, 170 patients and 96
From the School of Psychiatry (Drs. Sachdev and Brodaty, and M.J. Valenzuela and L. Lorentz), University of New South Wales; and Neuropsychiatric
Institute (Dr. Sachdev and M.J. Valenzuela), Academic Department for Old Age Psychiatry (Drs. Brodaty and Koschera, and L. Lorentz), the Prince of Wales
Hospital, Sydney, Australia.
Supported by grants from the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia, the Rebecca Cooper Foundation, and Fairfax Family Foundation,
and a Fellowship from the NSW Institute of Psychiatry.
Received March 16, 2004. Accepted in final form July 8, 2004.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Professor P. Sachdev, NPI, Prince of Wales Hospital, Barker Street, Randwick NSW 2031, Australia; e-mail:
p.sachdev@unsw.edu.au
1618 Copyright © 2004 by AAN Enterprises, Inc.