BER Performance of DPSK Subcarrier Modulated Free
Space Optics in Fully Developed Speckle
W.O. Popoola, Z. Ghassemlooy, Fellow IET, Senior Member IEEE and E. Leitgeb*
(emails: wasiu.popoola@unn.ac.uk ; fary.ghassemlooy@unn.ac.uk and erich.leitgeb@tugraz.at )
Optical Communications Research Group, NCRLab
Northumbria University, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE1 8 ST UK.
*Institute of Broadband Communications, TU, Graz, Austria
Abstract--In this paper a DPSK subcarrier intensity
modulated (SIM) free space optical (FSO) link is considered
in negative exponential atmospheric turbulence
environment. To mitigate the scintillation effect the selection
combining spatial diversity scheme (SelC) is employed at the
receiver. Bit error rate (BER) analysis is presented with and
without SelC spatial diversity, and it is shown that at BER of
10
-6
using four independent PIN-photodetectors, a diversity
gain of not less than 38 dB is achievable.
Key words—Free-space optics, DPSK, turbulence,
spatial diversity, Negative exponential distribution.
I. INTRODUCTION
In today’s access network, the FSO technology is playing
an increasing complementary role to the RF based
techniques. This is attributable to its fundamental feature
of huge bandwidth that is comparable to that obtainable
from optical fibre but with an added advantage of lower
deployment cost and time [1]. In recent years we have
seen a steadily growing research interest in FSO links,
supported by the successful field trials that are now
culminating into commercial deployments. [1-4]. The
earlier scepticism about FSO’s efficacy, its dwindling
acceptability by service providers cum slow market
penetration are now rapidly fading away judging by the
number of service providers, organisation, government
and private establishments that now incorporate FSO into
their network infrastructure [5, 6].
Terrestrial FSO is not free of challenges though; the
atmospheric constituents (gases, aerosol, rain, fog, and
smoke) extinguish and scatter photons traversing the
atmosphere. The most deleterious being the thick fog,
which could result in up to 270 dB/km attenuation
coefficient [1]. This potentially limits the achievable link
range to less than 500 m during such condition. In clear
atmospheric conditions, longer link ranges are palpable.
However, due to atmospheric turbulence effects small but
random changes occur in the atmospheric temperature.
This by extension results in random changes in the
atmospheric index of refraction along the path of the
optical radiation. This metamorphoses into random phase
and irradiance fluctuations (scintillation) of the optical
radiation at the photodetector. Detailed study of the
atmospheric turbulence can be found in [7-9]. The
scintillation effect can be likened to the random fading
effect on radio communication though not caused by the
multipath propagation and can cause severe degradation
in FSO link performance if unmitigated.
Moreover, in terrestrial FSO link; the simple and
widely used on-off keying (OOK) [10] signalling
technique requires adaptive threshold to perform
optimally because of turbulence. This poses a serious
design difficulty, which can be overcome by employing
SIM. The SIM FSO also outperforms OOK with adaptive
threshold [11, 12] and for the full and seamless
integration of FSO into existing networks the study of
SIM becomes compelling because existing networks
already contain subcarrier signals.
In weak turbulence modelled using the tractable log
normal distribution, the spatial diversity has been studied
to mitigate turbulence induced irradiance fading [10, 13].
Likewise, FSO employing various forward error control
techniques have been reported in literature [14-16] with
varying degrees of gain and complexity. In this paper
differential phase shift keying (DPSK) pre-modulated
SIM terrestrial FSO is presented with the selection
combining spatial diversity adopted to ameliorate
scintillation effect. In addition to mitigating scintillation
without introducing additional latency into the system,
spatial diversity also helps to prevent temporary
outage/blocking due to birds or other small flying object
cross the propagation path; and it’s by far simpler/cost
effective than using adaptive optics. The SIM is described
in section II, the system performance metric analysis with
and without selection combining spatial diversity is
detailed in section III while the conclusion is presented in
section IV.
II. DPSK SUBCARRIER INTENSITY MODULATION
A. System description
To achieve SIM, the data to be transported is pre-
modulated on to a radio frequency (RF) signal of
frequency ω
c
. The modulated subcarrier RF signal is then
used to directly modulate the irradiance of an optical
carrier which is either an LED or a laser diode. Since the
subcarrier signal is sinusoidal with both negative and
positive values and since the intensity of an optical carrier
can never be negative, a DC bias is usually applied to the
subcarrier prior to modulating the optical source to ensure
that the driving current of the laser diode is not less than
its threshold current.
After traversing the atmospheric channel, the transmit
978-1-4244-1876-3/08/$25.00 ©2008 IEEE
Proceedings - 273 - CSNDSP08