Hindawi Publishing Corporation
International Journal of Agronomy
Volume 2012, Article ID 163054, 13 pages
doi:10.1155/2012/163054
Research Article
Changes in Soluble-N in Forest and Pasture Soils after Repeated
Applications of Tannins and Related Phenolic Compounds
Jonathan J. Halvorson,
1
Javier M. Gonzalez,
1
and Ann E. Hagerman
2
1
USDA-ARS Appalachian Farming Systems Research Center, 1224 Airport Road, Beaver, WV 25813-9423, USA
2
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Miami University, 160 Hughes Laboratories, 701 East High Street,
Oxford, OH 45056, USA
Correspondence should be addressed to Jonathan J. Halvorson, jonathan.halvorson@ars.usda.gov
Received 15 September 2011; Accepted 7 December 2011
Academic Editor: Dexter B. Watts
Copyright © 2012 Jonathan J. Halvorson et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly
cited.
Tannins (produced by plants) can reduce the solubility of soil-N. However, comparisons of tannins to related non-tannins on
different land uses are limited. We extracted soluble-N from forest and pasture soils (0–5cm) with repeated applications of water
(Control) or solutions containing procyanidin from sorghum, catechin, tannic acid, β-1,2,3,4,6-penta-O-galloyl-D-glucose (PGG),
gallic acid, or methyl gallate (10 mg g
−1
soil). After eight treatments, samples were rinsed with cool water (23
◦
C) and incubated in
hot water (16 hrs, 80
◦
C). After each step, the quantity of soluble-N and extraction efficiency compared to the Control was deter-
mined. Tannins produced the greatest reductions of soluble-N with stronger effects on pasture soil. Little soluble-N was extracted
with cool water but hot water released large amounts in patterns influenced by the previous treatments. The results of this study
indicate hydrolyzable tannins like PGG reduce the solubility of labile soil-N more than condensed tannins like sorghum procya-
nidin (SOR) and suggest tannin effects will vary with land management. Because they rapidly reduce solubility of soil-N and can
also affect soil microorganisms, tannins may have a role in managing nitrogen availability and retention in agricultural soils.
1. Introduction
Tannins are reactive secondary metabolites produced by
plants that affect important biological, chemical, and phys-
ical processes in soil and couple primary productivity to
biogeochemical cycles [1–4]. Tannin effects on decomposi-
tion and nitrogen availability in soil have been a subject of
research for more than fifty years [5, 6]. However, devel-
opment of strategies for use of tannins as soil management
tools has lagged, in part because few studies have specifically
related them to improving plant productivity or soil fertility.
Early tannin research was conducted on temperate agricul-
tural soils [7–9], while recent work has concentrated more on
their role in forest ecosystems [10–12] and tropical soils [13–
15]. These studies, however, have tended to emphasize the
impacts of tannins on microbially mediated processes rather
than on the more immediate abiotic interactions between
tannins and soil and have made little attempt to frame their
findings into the context of landscape effects.
Tannins are believed to affect the nitrogen cycle through
several direct and indirect mechanisms that reduce rates of
net mineralization or nitrification. Some tannins are directly
toxic to plants or microorganisms [16, 17] but their effects
vary with particular tannin chemistry or among taxonomic
groups [18]. Some tannins or related phenolic compounds
are used by soil microorganisms as substrates increasing
microbial demand for nitrogen and immobilization in
microbial biomass [2, 12, 19]. Tannins can also reduce rates
of mineralization or decomposition by affecting the activity
of enzymes [20, 21] or by forming complexes with other
proteins or organic nitrogen compounds via reversible non-
covalent processes such as hydrogen bonding and hydropho-
bic interactions (cf. [2, 22, 23]). The availability of the nit-
rogen sequestered in tannin-protein complexes varies among
species of plants, taxa of microorganisms, or even among
strains of mycorrhizae [11, 24–28]. Tannins and related phe-
nolics may also affect soil-N through interactions with inor-
ganic soil fractions [3, 23, 29]. For example, tannin-related