Journal of Vegetation Science 26 (2015) 360–372
Ecological controls on post-fire vegetation assembly at
multiple spatial scales in eastern North American
boreal forests
Juliette Boiffin, Isabelle Aubin & Alison D. Munson
Keywords
Black spruce; Boreal forest; Fire severity;
Functional traits; MEM; PCNM; Quebec;
Understorey
Abbreviations
COM = consumed organic matter; CWM =
community weighted mean; MEM = Moran
eigen vector maps; PAM = partition around
medoids; PCNM = principal coordinate analysis
of neighbour matrices; RDA = redundancy
analysis.
Nomenclature
Flore Laurentienne (Marie-Victorin et al. 2002)
Received 16 May 2014
Accepted 29 September 2014
Co-ordinating Editor: Stephen Roxburgh
Boiffin, J. (corresponding author, juliette.
boiffin@gmail.com)
1
,
Aubin, I. (isabelle.aubin@nrcan-rncan.gc.ca)
2
& Munson, A.D. (alison.munson@sbf.
ulaval.ca)
1,2
1
Centre d’ etude de la for^ et, D epartement des
sciences du bois et de la for^ et, Facult e de
foresterie, de g eographie et de g eomatique
2405, rue de la Terrasse, Pavillon Abitibi-Price,
Universit e Laval, Qu ebec, QC G1V0A6, Canada.
2
Natural Resources Canada, Canadian Forest
Service, Great Lakes Forestry Centre, 1219
Queen St. East, Sault Ste. Marie, ON P6A 2E5,
Canada.
Abstract
Question: In fire-prone boreal forests, to what extent does fire severity influ-
ence understorey plant community assembly? What are the abiotic and biotic
factors controlling understorey community regeneration at regional, landscape
and local scales?
Location: Black spruce-dominated boreal forest in eastern Canada.
Methods: A taxonomic and a trait-based approach were combined to evaluate
the relative influence of habitat characteristics, burn severity and biotic pro-
cesses on understorey regeneration at multiple spatial scales. Sampling of under-
storey vegetation cover was carried out in 133 recently burned plots located in
14 different fires across a 600-km transect. The spatial hierarchy for sampling
consisted of five fire regime zones (regional scale), two to four fires within each
zone (landscape) and two to four toposequences within each fire (local). The
environmental control of fire severity and habitat characteristics on understorey
regeneration was assessed using a canonical redundancy analysis (RDA) and
variation partitioning. We investigated environmental and biotic filters of spe-
cies traits at different scales by modelling trait–spatial assemblages with Moran
eigen vector maps (MEMs).
Results: In spite of the large variability of environmental conditions covered by
our sampling design, low depths of burn were measured in the large majority of
the studied sites. Incomplete consumption of the forest floor is frequently
observed in eastern boreal forests characterized by long fire cycles. In situ biologi-
cal legacies persisted through the low-severity fires, which conserved the pre-
fire relationships between plant communities and their environment. As a
result, fire severity was neither the unique nor the dominant control on post-fire
regeneration. Habitat characteristics explained a three times higher proportion
of variation in species composition. Biotic controls on trait assemblage increased
at the two finer scales.
Conclusions: Severity alone cannot predict understorey vegetation assembly at
different scales in the low-severity fire regime characteristic of the eastern North
American boreal forest.
Introduction
In boreal forest, understorey vegetation is a key ecosystem
compartment that exerts strong control on both above-
ground and below-ground ecosystem processes (Messier
et al. 1998; Nilsson & Wardle 2005; Kolari et al. 2006).
The heterogeneous and often dense vegetation layer
modulates light transmission, soil temperature and
evapotranspiration, which in turn affect nutrient cycling,
germination, growth and survival of young plant cohorts
(Oechel & Van Cleve 1986; Messier et al. 1998; Aubin
et al. 2000; Nilsson et al. 2000).
In boreal forests of North America, wildfire is one of the
main natural disturbance agents that structure the vegeta-
tion mosaic at the landscape scale, and that initiate and ter-
minate succession at the stand scale. In this biome, fire
Journal of Vegetation Science
360 Doi: 10.1111/jvs.12245 © 2014 International Association for Vegetation Science