ABSTRACT
In this paper pebbles marked by passive integrated transpon-
ders from two artificial coarse-grained beaches at Marina di Pisa
(Tuscany, Italy) were analyzed in order to measure the in situ abra-
sion rate. The beaches (Cella 7 and Barbarossa) were set up in 2006
as a form of coastal protection. They are both composed of pebbles
(30-to-90 mm diameter) and bounded longshore by huge groynes.
They differ in length (250 m and 110 m respectively) and in the
presence of an additional defense structure, a submerged breakwater
50 m off the coastline, at Cella 7. The aim of the study is to reckon
the abrasion rate of individual pebbles and evaluate abrasion
differences of pebbles released on Cella 7 and on Barbarossa. The
RFID technology (Radio Frequency Identification) was used to track
the pebbles due to its reliability and limited costs. The tracers were
released on the beaches in March 2009 along closely-spaced cross-
shore transects. The recovery campaign was carried out in May
2009. A total of 127 pebbles was detected, 83 of which were recov-
ered. Huge beach reworking during the storms determined high
burial rates and consequently the loss of a definite amount of tracers.
The pebbles that were recovered showed a significant increase in
roundness, in particular the tracers that were released on Bar-
barossa. The average pebble weight loss measured at Cella 7 was
slightly lower, which means lower mobilization rate at this site
rather than at Barbarossa. The resulting values are significant
considering the short time frame of the research (two months) and
the limited energy of the storms occurred during the experiment.
KEY WORDS: Abrasion, pebble, replenishment, coarse-clastic
beach, tracer.
INTRODUCTION
Among the textural properties of coarse sediments,
the abrasion rate is one of the most attractive mainly
because it has a direct influence on practical activities,
such as artificial beach replenishments. Gravel and peb-
ble beach fills are progressively more used as a form of
protection from coastal erosion, even where coarse parti-
cles do not constitute the natural sediments of the area.
The efficiency of an artificial replenishment is deter-
mined in terms of the durability of the protection level it
provides. Thus, the use of the most suitable grain-size is
the primary requirement to fulfill the purpose of the
intervention. However, the grain-size is connected to the
abrasion rate to the point that it largely affects the out-
come of a beach fill both in mid- and long-term. Underes-
timating the abrasion rate might lead to a rather quick
inefficiency of the artificial beach, which in turn implies
the recurrence of additional fills along with cost swelling.
The abrasion rate was firstly addressed with labora-
tory experiments (KUENEN, 1964; LATHAM et alii, 1998;
NORDSTROM et alii, 2008). MATTHEWS (1983) measured
beach pebble attrition on pebbles of significantly different
lithology relative to the native sediments using statistical
methods, then compared the results to laboratory tests
performed with the same lithology. Preliminary attempts
on individual pebbles were performed by ZHDANOV
(1958), but the technique implied the breakage of the peb-
bles to identify them once recovered. DORNBUSCH et alii
(2002) provided a remarkable impulse to this topic, mea-
suring the in situ abrasion of individual pebbles without
the need to break them. To allow both recognition and
recovery of the marked samples, the rock types that were
used in the experiment were different from the lithology
of the study site, which constitutes the limit of the
method. Recently the recognition of the pebbles was
attained by means of the Radio Frequency Identification
(RFID) technology, which enables to detect items that
have been coupled to small devices (ALLAN et alii, 2006;
CURTISS et alii, 2009). A later work by BERTONI et alii
(2010) allowed to extend this technique to the underwater
environment. The technique is reliable and cost-effective,
and proved to be suitable for abrasion rate experiments
on individual samples. In addition, it is easily repeatable
on different scenarios.
The aim of this research is to evaluate the in situ
abrasion of individual pebbles that were collected from
the backshore of an artificial coarse-clastic beach and
injected in the very same beach after being marked. The
resulting abrasion rates were sensible and the speed at
which the tracers lost weight in a limited span of time
was significant enough to not be neglected when replen-
ishments are projected and then set up.
STUDY AREA
The artificial pebble beaches at Marina di Pisa (Tu-
scany, Italy) were chosen as the study site because they
match several of the needed requirements, such as the
limited length and the defined boundaries. The Province
of Pisa invested a lot of financial resources to set up these
beaches in 2006 as part of a huge coastal defense scheme
(*) Department of Earth Sciences, University of Pisa, Via
S. Maria, 53 - 56126 Pisa (Italy).
(**) Department of Earth Sciences, University of Pisa, Via
S. Maria, 53 - 56126 Pisa (Italy). Corresponding author: tel.:
+39 050 2215734; fax: +39 050 2215800; e-mail: sarti@dst.unipi.it
(***) Department of Information Engineering, University of
Siena, Via Roma, 56 - 53100 Siena (Italy).
(****) Department of Information Engineering, University of
Siena, Via Roma, 56 - 53100 Siena (Italy).
In situ abrasion of marked pebbles on two coarse-clastic beaches
(Marina di Pisa, Italy)
DUCCIO BERTONI (*), GIOVANNI SARTI (**), GIULIANO BENELLI (***) & ALESSANDRO POZZEBON (****)
Ital. J. Geosci. (Boll. Soc. Geol. It.), Vol. 131, No. 2 (2012), pp. 205-214, 8 figs., 6 tabs. (doi: 10.3301/IJG.2012.04)
© Società Geologica Italiana, Roma 2012
Author’s personal copy