Determination of cobalt and iron in estuarine and coastal
waters using flow injection with chemiluminescence detection†
Vincenzo Cannizzaro, Andrew R. Bowie, Anton Sax,‡ Eric P. Achterberg and Paul J.
Worsfold*
Department of Environmental Sciences, Plymouth Environmental Research Centre, University
of Plymouth, Plymouth, UK PL4 8AA
Received 21st September 1999, Accepted 2nd November 1999
Flow injection with chemiluminescence detection (FI-CL) was used to determine cobalt and iron in estuarine and
coastal waters. Cobalt(II) was determined by means of a pyrogallol–hydrogen peroxide–sodium hydroxide reaction
in the presence of methanol and the surfactant cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB). With pyrogallol, the
sensitivity was enhanced compared with the traditional reagent, gallic acid. The practical limit of detection in
sea-water was 5 pM (3s) and there was good agreement with certified values for the sea-water CRMs NASS-5
(0.16 ± 0.01 nM), CASS-3 (0.60 ± 0.09 nM) and SLEW-2 (0.93 ± 0.13 nM). Results for an Irish Sea sample gave
good agreement with data obtained using cathodic stripping voltammetry. Iron(ii + iii) was determined using a
luminol reaction with dissolved oxygen as the oxidant. The practical limit of detection was 40 pM (3s) and results
from shipboard analysis of the CRM NASS-4 (1.95 ± 0.14 nM) were in good agreement with the certified value
(1.88 ± 0.29 nM). Field evaluation of the instrumentation and analytical methods was achieved through a series of
local surveys in the Tamar Estuary (UK), from which environmental data are presented.
Introduction
The oceanic concentrations of cobalt are extremely low and it
has been suggested that the element may act as a (co-)limiting
nutrient for marine phytoplankton.
1
Cobalt demonstrates a
scavenged-type vertical distribution in the open ocean, typically
18–300 pM in surface waters and 20–50 pM at depth.
2
Cobalt
concentrations in estuarine and coastal waters are significantly
higher. For example, Knauer et al.
1
reported 0.85–20 nM in
north San Francisco Bay and Achterberg et al.
3
found 140–310
pM in coastal waters near the Wash and Humber Estuaries on
the eastern coast of the UK. High concentrations of Co (up to
3.5 nM) have also been reported in hydrothermal plumes
4
and
the element has been used as a chemical indicator of
hydrothermal activity.
5
Cobalt is a co-factor in the vitamin B
12
complex and is known to accumulate in manganese nodules. It
is only toxic to plants and mammals at relatively high
concentrations ( > 17 mM), which are rarely observed in the
aquatic environment.
6,7
Iron has played a key role in oceanographic research over the
past decade and is now thought to act as a limiting micronutrient
regulating biological productivity in ca. 40% of the world’s
oceans.
8210
Consequently, Fe has been intimately linked to the
ocean–atmosphere carbon dioxide exchange
11
and transitions in
climate from glacial to interglacial times.
12
Recent advances in
analytical and sampling techniques for trace metal determina-
tions have led to an increased understanding of the bio-
geochemical role of Fe in sea-water, although its distribution in
many remote seas and across ocean margins is poorly
constrained. Iron has been reported to demonstrate a nutrient-
like profile in many regions of the open ocean, with dissolved
Fe typically existing at < 0.2 nM in surface waters and
converging to 0.7–0.8 nM in deep waters.
13
However, recent
studies suggest that Fe distributions show high temporal and
spatial variability through oceanic provinces where atmospheric
fluxes are high (e.g., in the Atlantic Ocean
14
). In coastal and
shelf seas, trace metals are delivered laterally by rivers and
through diffusion from reductive shelf sediments, resulting in
elevated Fe levels (e.g., 1.7 nM in the North Sea
15
). Estuaries,
however, act as a filter, effectively trapping elevated riverine
concentrations of metals and leading to large property gradients
existing at the land–sea margin.
16
Commonly used laboratory techniques for sub-nanomolar Co
and Fe determinations include electrothermal atomic absorption
spectrometry (ETAAS) following filtration and extractive
complexation
17
and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrom-
etry (ICP-MS).
18
There is a need, however, to develop
shipboard analytical methods owing to the problems of sample
instability and contamination during transport and storage. ICP-
MS and ETAAS are impractical for shipboard use because the
instrumentation is bulky, expensive and sensitive to the ship’s
vibrations, and the preferred methods for Co and Fe are based
on voltammetry,
15,19,20
catalytic spectrophotometry
21
and flow
injection with liquid-phase chemiluminescence detection (FI-
CL).
14,22–30
All require preconcentration utilising solvent
extraction, electrochemical deposition of a metal–ligand com-
plex or chelating resin column separation. Advantages of the FI-
CL approach are the ability to perform in-line matrix removal
and preconcentration, low-cost detection, wide dynamic range,
rapid analysis (seconds), robustness and portability.
In this work, the relative sensitivities of seven polyhydroxy
aromatic compounds were evaluated for the FI-CL determina-
tion of Co(ii). A reaction based on the oxidation of pyrogallol
was optimised to permit a limit of detection of 5 pM in sea-
water. A modified FI-CL method for the determination of Fe(ii
+ iii) in estuarine waters, based on the luminol chemistry, is also
reported. An inert tangential flow device is described for
filtration of waters containing high suspended particulate
matter. The instrumentation was successfully deployed along an
† Presented at SAC 99, Dublin, Ireland, July 25–30, 1999.
‡ Present address: IFA-Tulln, Analytikzentrum, Konrad Lorenz Strasse 20,
A-3430 Tulln, Austria.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2000
Analyst, 2000, 125, 51–57 51