Page 1 of 15
http://spider.apa.org/ftdocs/ccp/1997/april/ccp652278.html 10/12/2000
Effects of Group- Versus Home-Based Exercise in the Treatment of Obesity
Michael G. Perri
Department of Clinical and Health Psychology University of Florida
A. Daniel Martin
Department of Physical Therapy University of Florida
Elizabeth A. Leermakers
Department of Clinical and Health Psychology University of Florida
Samuel F. Sears
Department of Clinical and Health Psychology University of Florida
Morris Notelovitz
ABSTRACT
This study examined the effects of 2 aerobic exercise regimens on exercise participation,
fitness, eating patterns, treatment adherence, and weight change in 49 obese women
undergoing a year-long behavioral weight loss program. Participants were assigned
randomly to weight loss treatment plus either group- or home-based exercise. All
participants were instructed to complete a moderate-intensity walking program (30
min/day, 5 days/week). Group exercise participants were provided with 3 supervised
group exercise sessions per week for the first 26 weeks and with 2 sessions per week
thereafter. Home exercise participants were instructed to complete all exercise in their
home environment. After 6 months, both conditions displayed significant improvements
in exercise participation, fitness, eating patterns, and weight loss. At 12 months, the
home-based program showed superior performance to the group condition in exercise
participation and treatment adherence; at 15 months, participants in the home program
demonstrated significantly greater weight losses than those in the group program.
This study was supported by a Research Development Award from the University of Florida Division
of Sponsored Research.
We appreciate the assistance of Nicole Engel, Tanya Mickler, Jennifer Oglesby, Judy Rudman, Beth
Slomine, and Paula Zuffante, who served as group leaders.
Correspondence may be addressed to Michael G. Perri, Department of Clinical and Health
Psychology, University of Florida, P.O. Box 100165, Gainesville, Florida, 32610-0165.
Received: January 19, 1996
Revised: June 24, 1996
Accepted: August 20, 1996
In recent years, the potential contribution of exercise to the management of obesity has become
increasingly apparent ( Blair, 1993 ; Bouchard, Despres, & Tremblay, 1993 ; Grilo, Brownell, &
Stunkard, 1993 ; Pronk & Wing, 1994 ). Exercise produces physiological, behavioral, and
psychological effects that may facilitate both weight loss and the maintenance of weight loss (for
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology © 1997 by the American Psychological Association
April 1997 Vol. 65, No. 2, 278 -285 For personal use only--not for distribution.