Finite Element Modeling of the Pulmonary Autograft at
Systemic Pressure before Remodeling
Peter B. Matthews, Choon-Sik Jhun, Stephanie Yaung, Ali N. Azadani, Julius M. Guccione,
Liang Ge, Elaine E. Tseng
Department of Surgery, University of California at San Francisco Medical Center and San Francisco Veterans Affairs
Medical Center, San Francisco, CA, USA
Aortic valve replacement with the pulmonary auto-
graft, though originally implanted via a subcoronary
technique, has been most commonly been performed
as a full aortic root replacement since the late 1980s (1).
However, late failure from autograft dilatation
requires reoperation, and this is a critical limitation of
the procedure (2-6). Significant autograft dilatation
leading to aortic regurgitation or aneurysm formation
occurs after biological remodeling when the pul-
monary root, which is accustomed to pulmonary pres-
sures, is subjected to systemic pressures within the
aorta. Biologic remodeling involves reduced elastin
and elastin fragmentation in the media of the wall,
increased collagen and fibrosis, and hypertrophy of
the smooth muscle (7). Remodeling is thought to be
triggered by increases in autograft wall stress from
pulmonary to systemic pressure; however, the auto-
graft wall stress that occurs on an initial exposure to
aortic pressures is unknown. Wall stress may be deter-
mined by computational simulations (8) of the auto-
Presented in part at the 94th Annual Clinical Congress of the
American College of Surgeons, Owen H. Wangensteen Surgical
Forum, San Francisco, CA, 14th October 2008, and as a poster at the
Fifth Biennial Meeting of the Society for Heart Valve Disease, 27th-
30th June 2009, Berlin, Germany
Address for correspondence:
Elaine E. Tseng MD, UCSF Medical Center, Division of
Cardiothoracic Surgery, 500 Parnassus Avenue, Suite W405, Box
0118, San Francisco, California 94143-0118, USA
e-mail: elaine.tseng@ucsfmedctr.org
© Copyright by ICR Publishers 2011
Background and aim of the study: Pulmonary auto-
graft dilatation requiring reoperation is an Achilles’
heel of the Ross procedure, as exposure to systemic
pressure increases autograft wall stress, which may
in turn lead to tissue remodeling and aneurysmal
pathology. However, the magnitude of autograft wall
stress with the Ross procedure is unknown. The
study aim was to develop a realistic finite element
(FE) model of the autograft, and to perform simula-
tions at systemic pressure to determine wall stress
distribution immediately after the Ross operation.
Methods: The porcine pulmonary root geometry was
generated from high-resolution microcomputed
tomography (microCT) images to create a mesh com-
posed of hexahedral elements. Previously defined
constitutive equations were used to describe the
regional material properties of the native porcine
pulmonary root. The anterior and posterior pul-
monary arteries, and each of the pulmonary sinuses,
were best described by non-linear, anisotropic Fung
strain energy functions, and input individually into
the model. Autograft dilatation and wall stress dis-
tribution during pulmonary and systemic loading
prior to remodeling were determined using explicit
FE analysis in LS-DYNA.
Results: The autograft was highly compliant in the
low-strain region, and the majority of dilation
occurred with <30 mmHg of pressurization. During
pulmonic loading, a typical inflation/deflation was
observed between systole and diastole, but the auto-
graft remained almost completely dilated throughout
the cardiac cycle at systemic pressure. Although the
systolic blood pressure was 380% greater in the aortic
than in the pulmonary position, the peak systolic
diameter was increased by only 28%. The maximum
principal wall stress increased approximately 10-fold
during systole and 25-fold during diastole, and was
greater in the sinus than the distal artery for all sim-
ulations.
Conclusion: Under systemic loading conditions, the
pulmonary autograft remained fully dilated and
experienced large wall stresses concentrated in the
sinus. The future correlation of this model with
explanted autografts may lead to an improved under-
standing of tissue remodeling following the Ross
procedure.
The Journal of Heart Valve Disease 2011;20:45-52