Quantification of sewer leakage by a continuous
tracer method
V. Prigiobbe and M. Giulianelli
ABSTRACT
Water authorities interested in the evaluation of the structural state of a sewer must quantify leakage
to plan strategic intervention. However, the quantification of the exfiltration and the localisation of
structural damage are challenging tasks that usually require expensive and time-consuming
inspections. Herein, we report one of the first applications of the QUEST-C method to quantify the
exfiltration in a continuously operating sewer by dosing two chemical tracers, sodium bromide (NaBr)
and lithium chloride (LiCl). The method was applied at the catchment scale in a 14-year-old sewer in
Rome, Italy. Preliminary laboratory tests, field measurements, and numerical simulations showed
that reliable results require the QUEST-C method to be applied to sewers without lateral inflows,
during periods of quasi-steady flow, and that the travel time of the NaBr tracer is minimised. Three
sewer reaches were tested and the estimated exfiltration, as a fraction of the dry weather flow
(DWF), increased from 0.128 in the agricultural area to 0.208 in the urban area. Although our
estimates are at the lower end of the range given in the literature (0.01–0.56 DWF), the exfiltration
was not negligible, and interventions should focus on the sewers in urban areas. This illustrates the
capability of the QUEST-C method to guide strategic intervention at low cost and without an
interruption of sewer operation. However, careful interpretation of the results is recommended for
sewers with many lateral inflows, where leakage may be overestimated.
V. Prigiobbe* (corresponding author)
M. Giulianelli
Water Research Institute,
Via Salaria km 29,300,
00015 Rome,
Italy
E-mail: giulianelli@irsa.cnr.it
*Current address:
Petroleum and Geosystems Engineering,
University of Texas at Austin,
1, University Station C0300,
Austin, TX 78712-0228,
USA
Key words | exfiltration, leakage, rehabilitation, sewer, strategic intervention, urban drainage
INTRODUCTION
Sewer systems may experience major deterioration of infra-
structure due to inadequate and insufficient maintenance
and rehabilitation, allowing sewage to exit these systems
and contaminate the adjacent ground and surface waters
with high levels of pathogenic microorganisms, oxygen-
demanding organic compounds, oil, and other pollutants,
such as endocrine disrupters (Barrett et al. ). Studies
at the catchment scale suggest that the fraction of sewer
flow leaking into the environment by exfiltration can
range from 1% to 56% of the dry weather flow (DWF) of
the sewer (Rutsch et al. ). The impact of exfiltration
is largest during the DWF period, when the natural
recharge of groundwater is low in comparison with sewer
leakage.
In cities served by ageing sewer systems, concerns
about sewer leakage are increasing. To mitigate exfiltration
impacts effectively, strategic interventions to rehabilitate
damaged sewers must be considered and should be based
on reliable leakage quantification and risk assessment.
Quantification methods can be classified into two categories
(Rutsch et al. ):
1. Indirect methods used at the catchment scale to evaluate
the impact of exfiltration based on groundwater monitor-
ing for water and solute balances.
2. Direct methods applied at the pipe and reach scale that
focus on sewer damage, such as pressure tests and
tracer mass balances.
The indirect methods are based on transport modelling
of the sewage contaminants in the groundwater and must
be validated by an extensive experimental dataset of
groundwater velocities and compositions. These methods
have been applied in several cases to monitor various indi-
cators of sewer contamination such as stable nitrogen
132 © IWA Publishing 2011 Water Science & Technology | 64.1 | 2011
doi: 10.2166/wst.2011.639