ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Admission Base Deficit as a Long-Term Prognostic Factor in
Severe Pediatric Trauma Patients
Cle ´mence Hindy-Franc ¸ois, MD, Philippe Meyer, MD, Ste ´phane Blanot, MD, Sophie Marque ´, MD,
Nada Sabourdin, MD, Pierre Carli, MD, and Gilles Orliaguet, MD, PhD
Background: Base deficit (BD) is a prognostic tool that correlates with
trauma scores and mortality in adult trauma patients. Retrospective studies
have shown that admission BD more than 8 mmol/L is associated with an
increased risk of mortality. This is the first prospective European study aimed
at evaluating the prognostic value of admission BD in traumatized children.
Methods: One hundred severely traumatized children were included if an
arterial BD had been calculated on arrival in the trauma room of a university
hospital. Epidemiologic, medical, and biological data (including admission
BD and lactates concentration) were recorded and compared using a univar-
iate analysis. The primary endpoint was in-hospital mortality. Secondary
endpoints were outcome on discharge and at 6 months. Cutoff values for BD
or lactates regarding outcomes were determined using receiver operating
characteristic curves if these data had been isolated on multivariate analysis
(p 0.05).
Results: Sixty-eight boys and 32 girls, aged 6.7 years, were enrolled from
March 2003 to December 2005, mainly after road traffic accidents. Twenty-
two died at the hospital, 34 children and 51 children were classified as having
a good outcome on hospital discharge and 6 months later, respectively. After
the multivariate procedure and receiver operating characteristic curve anal-
ysis, admission lactates more than 2.94 mmol/L and admission BD more than
5 mEq/L were independent risk factors for mortality (odds ratio 2.4 [95%
confidence interval 1.3– 4.6]) and poor outcome at 6 months (odds ratio 2.5
[95% confidence interval 1.13–5.5]), respectively.
Discussion: BD could be used to predict the long-term morbidity and may
not be related to morbidity and mortality at discharge.
Key Words: Children, Trauma, Base deficit, Outcome.
(J Trauma. 2009;67: 1272–1277)
I
n developed countries, trauma is the main cause of death
and morbidity in children older than 1 year.
1,2
As a result,
early prediction of outcome is important to provide adequate
triage and critical care management, and to deliver precise
information to the parents.
Severe trauma patients may present with shock on
hospital admission. From the cellular point of view, shock
represents a situation where oxygen delivery is insufficient,
because of inadequate blood supply, or as a consequence of
poor tissue oxygen extraction. Shock leads to anaerobic
metabolism with lactic acidosis and bicarbonate buffer con-
sumption. Base deficit (BD) has been described since 1960 by
Anderson and Engel
3
. It is a simple measure of the metabolic
acid-base activity and is defined by the amount of strong acid
or base required to return the pH of 1 L of whole blood to 7.4,
assuming a PCO
2
of 40 mm Hg and a temperature of 37°. It
does not quantify acid-base disorder of respiratory origin.
Shock leads to metabolic acidosis and increased BD.
In children, heart rate and arterial blood pressure poorly
reflect the severity of shock because of very effective com-
pensatory physiologic mechanisms. Moreover, normal values
for heart rate and blood pressure vary over a wide range in
children, making interpretation of any modifications more
difficult than in adults. In adult trauma patients, BD has
become an important prognostic tool and correlates with
trauma scores,
4
transfusion requirement,
5
morbidity,
6
and
mortality.
4
Nevertheless, these correlations cannot be extrap-
olated to traumatized children because of the physiologic
differences between adults and children. Specific pediatric
scores
7–9
exist to predict the risk of mortality in pediatric
intensive care units but prove to be difficult to calculate as
they take into account many variables and are not specific to
trauma patients. The BD appears in the pediatric index of
mortality score formula
8
. To date, three retrospective Amer-
ican
10 –12
studies have shown that an admission BD more than
8 mmol/L was significantly associated with an increased risk
of mortality in pediatric trauma patients. In France, trauma
patients, including pediatric patients, are dealt with by phy-
sicians
13
in the field and not by paramedics
14
. Patients are
susceptible to receive more aggressive care that could change
the prognosis threshold associated with BD. We designed a
prospective study to evaluate the prognostic value of admis-
sion BD in French traumatized children. We hypothesized
that an increased BD would correlate with a poorer outcome.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was approved by the ethics committee (Co-
mite ´ Consultatif de Protection des Personnes dans la Recher-
che Biome ´dicale, CCPPRB, ho ˆpital de la Pitie ´ Salpe ˆtrie `re,
Assistance Publique des Ho ˆpitaux de Paris, Paris, France).
Waived parental informed consent was authorized as patients
were treated according to a routine protocol used in our
department without any additional intervention. Confidenti-
Submitted for publication June 12, 2008.
Accepted for publication January 22, 2009.
Copyright © 2009 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
Service d’Anesthe ´sie Re ´animation (P.M., S.B., N.S., P.C., G.O.), Ho ˆpital Necker-
Enfants Malades (C.H.-F.), APHP-Universite ´ Paris Descartes, Paris; and
Service de re ´animation me ´dicale (S.M.), Ho ˆpital Pontchaillou, Rennes,
France.
Address for reprints: Gilles Orliaguet, MD, PhD, Service d’Anesthe ´sie Re ´anima-
tion, Ho ˆpital Necker-Enfants Malades, 149, rue de SEVRES, APHP, Univer-
site ´ Paris Descartes, 75743 Paris Cedex 15. France; email: gilles.orliaguet@nck.
aphp.fr.
DOI: 10.1097/TA.0b013e31819db828
1272 The Journal of TRAUMA
®
Injury, Infection, and Critical Care • Volume 67, Number 6, December 2009