Abstract The evolution of alternative male mating phe-
notypes inevitably involves variation in risk or intensity
of sperm competition. Males that typically mate in disfa-
voured roles (i.e. sneakers/parasitic males) are predicted
to experience higher magnitudes of sperm competition
than males mating in favoured roles (preferred by fe-
males/exhibiting mate monopolisation). Here, we inves-
tigated whether two distinct male phenotypes in cork-
wing wrasse (Symphodus melops) differ with respect to
adaptations for sperm competition in terms of sperm
quantity, sperm motilityand fertilising capacity. We
found that males exhibiting female mimicry (disfavoured
role) had both absolutely and relatively larger gonads
than males with typical secondary sexual characters (fa-
voured role). Moreover, a higher proportion of sperm
from female mimics was motile 5 min after activation
compared to sperm of territorial males. There were, how-
ever, no differences in sperm concentration or in in vitro
fertilisation ability between the two male morphs. We
also examined whether the male phenotypes differed in
some immune parameters and if any such variation is as-
sociated with sperm traits. Current theories predict that
ejaculate quality should be negatively correlated with the
level of immunocompetence. Territorial males had rela-
tively heavier spleens than female mimics, but whether
this reflects differing immunocompetence is uncertain,
since the spleen is also an important organ for erythro-
cyte storage. Furthermore, there were no differences in
the densities of circulating lymphocytes or granulocytes,
and the immune parameters did not covary with the
spermtraits.Differences in immunocompetence are
therefore unlikely to provide a major proximate explana
tion for variations in sperm traits in corkwing wrasse.
Keywords
Symphodus melops · Corkwing wrasse ·
Alternative mating phenotypes · Male dimorphism ·
Sperm competition · Immunology
Introduction
Competition for partners and mate choice may lead to t
evolution of alternative reproductive phenotypes, which
theoretically be maintained through two types of select
(Gross1996). First,by frequency-dependent selection,
which implies that the different reproductive forms
maintained at an evolutionary equilibrium with equ
ness, and second, by status-dependent selection. The la
implies that expression of the different tactics depends
individual status or condition. Alternative reproductive
notypes are found in most major taxa, with at least 140
species belonging to 28 different families exhibiting alt
native mating patterns (Taborsky 1994, 1998; Gross 19
Sperm competition occurs when sperm from differen
males compete for fertilisation (Parker 1970). The evolu
tion of alternative male mating phenotypes inevitably in
volves within-sex variation in the magnitude of spe
competition (Parker 1998). Theoretical models regardin
sperm competition in organisms with external fertil
tion predict that males typically mating in disfavou
roles (i.e. males exhibiting mating behaviours not i
volving mate monopolisation or utilisation of female
preferences) experience higher risk or intensity of sper
competition than males mating in favoured roles (Parke
1998; Petersen and Warner 1998). The disfavoured
males should consequently be selected to offset this dis
advantage by investing relatively more into sperma
genesis (Parker 1982, 1990a, 1990b, 1993; Gage e
1995). More precisely, males exhibiting disfavoured
mating patterns are predicted to have relatively lar
gonads for their size than males mating in favoure
Communicated by J. Krause
I. Uglem (
✉
) · T.F. Galloway · G. Rosenqvist
Department of Zoology,
Norwegian University of Technology and Science,
7491 Trondheim, Norway
e-mail: ingebrigt.uglem@chembio.ntnu.no
Tel.: +47 73-596278, Fax: +47 73-591309
I. Folstad
Department of Ecology, Faculty of Science,
University of Tromsø, 9037 Tromsø, Norway
Behav Ecol Sociobiol (2001) 50:511–518
DOI 10.1007/s002650100392
O R I G I N A L A RT I C L E
Ingebrigt Uglem · Trina Falck Galloway
Gunilla Rosenqvist · Ivar Folstad
Male dimorphism, sperm traits and immunology
in the corkwing wrasse ( Symphodus melops L.)
Received: 15 December 2000 / Revised: 26 May 2001 / Accepted: 6 June 2001 / Published online: 27 July 2001
© Springer-Verlag 2001