Original Research
Electronic Continuing Education in the Health
Professions: An Update on Evidence from RCTs
MARGARITA LAM-ANTONIADES, MD, CCFP; SAVITHIRI RATNAPALAN, MBBS, MED, MRCP, FRCPC, FAAP;
GORDON T AIT,PHD
Introduction: Demonstrating the effectiveness of the rapidly expanding field of electronic continuing education
(e-CE) has important implications for CE in the health professions. This study provides an update on evidence from
randomized controlled trials (RCTs) assessing the effectiveness of e-CE in the health professions.
Methods: A literature search of RCTs was performed in MEDLINE, EMBASE, and CINAHL from 2004 to 2007.
Papers were reviewed separately by 2 of the authors and results were categorized and reviewed according to
study comparisons.
Results: Fifteen studies met our inclusion criteria. Six compared e-CE to no intervention or placebo. Of these 6
studies, 4 showed a statistically significant advantage of the e-CE intervention and 2 showed no significant effect.
Two studies compared e-CE to a lecture. Of these, 1 showed an advantage of e-CE and 1 showed no difference.
Two studies compared e-CE to a small-group interactive intervention. In both studies, the e-CE group outperformed
the control. Two studies compared a multicomponent e-CE intervention to one based on flat text, and both showed
the multicomponent intervention to be more effective. Two of the 15 studies demonstrated a statistically significant
effect on practice patterns. Positive effects of e-CE on knowledge were shown to persist for up to 12 months and
effects on practice up to 5 months.
Discussion: Overall, these studies suggest that multicomponent e-CE interventions can be effective in changing
health professionals’ practice patterns, and improve their knowledge. E-CE interventions based purely on flat text
appear to be of limited effectiveness in changing either knowledge or practice. These results support the use of
multicomponent e-CE as a method of CE delivery.
Key Words: electronic continuing education, education, medical, continuing, computer-based education, Internet,
CD-ROM
Introduction
The number of continuing education initiatives in the health
professions that are offered in electronic form has grown
exponentially in the past decade. E-CE
a
~electronic continu-
ing education! programs offer many advantages including
easy access, flexible timing, the possibility of adaptation to
individual learning styles, and low cost. E-CE has the po-
tential to provide many of the elements that have been found
to be effective in traditional continuing medical education
such as interactivity,
1
multiple sequenced sessions,
1,2
and
reinforcing materials.
1
Interactivity can take many forms such
as e-mail, asynchronous or synchronous discussion boards,
video Web-conferencing, cases with scripted interactivity,
and others.
Several literature reviews on electronic learning in the
health professions have been published in recent years. Wu-
toh et al
3
reviewed randomized controlled trials ~ RCTs!
and retrospective studies of e-CE interventions published
Disclosures: The authors report none.
Dr. Lam-Antoniades: Lecturer, Department of Family and Community Med-
icine, University of Toronto, Staff physician, St. Michael’s Hospital, To-
ronto, Canada; Dr. Ratnapalan: Assistant Professor, Department of
Paediatrics, Department of Public Health Sciences, University of Toronto,
Staff physician, Division of Emergency Medicine, Clinical Pharmacology
& Toxicology, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Canada; Dr. Tait:
Assistant Professor, Toronto General Hospital, Departments of Surgery and
Anesthesia, University of Toronto, Canada.
Correspondence: Margarita Lam-Antoniades, 410 Sherbourne Street,
Ground Floor, Toronto, Ontario, M4X 1K2; e-mail: margarita.antoniades@
utoronto.ca.
© 2009 The Alliance for Continuing Medical Education, the Society for
Academic Continuing Medical Education, and the Council on CME,
Association for Hospital Medical Education. • Published online in Wiley
InterScience ~www.interscience.wiley.com!. DOI: 10.10020chp.20005
a
E-CE is used here to indicate any form of continuing education that is
delivered with the use of either ~1! the Internet, ie, Web, or e-mail, or ~2!
a computer interface, ie, CD-ROM. Studies involving computer-controlled
mannequins as virtual patients were not included in this review.
JOURNAL OF CONTINUING EDUCATION IN THE HEALTH PROFESSIONS, 29(1):44–51, 2009