Materials Research. 2010; 13(3): 395-399 © 2010
*e-mail: hotza@enq.ufsc.br
Measuring and Modeling the Plasticity of Clays
Fernando Augusto de Andrade, Hazim Ali Al-Qureshi, Dachamir Hotza
*
Núcleo de Pesquisa em Materiais Cerâmicos – CERMAT,
Departamentos de Engenharia Mecânica – EMC e Engenharia Química – ENQ,
Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina – UFSC,
CEP 88040-900, Florianópolis, SC, Brazil
Received: April 1, 2010; Revised: June 29, 2010
The measurement of plasticity in clay bodies is crucial in order to get products free of defects and with less
processing time. However, tests which simulate the behavior of the clay during processing and the mathematical
modeling of some of its characteristics, particularly the plasticity, become difficult because many variables are
involved and there is no consensus on the choice of method to be used. This study aimed to develop a mathematical
model based on compression test to evaluate the plasticity of clays. Three types of clays were studied with different
levels of moisture and their indices of plasticity were also characterized by the Atterberg’s and Pfefferkorn’s
methods. The experimental data were well fitted by the theoretical curves for a wide range of clay plasticity.
Moreover, it was possible to observe a correlation between effective stress of compression and paste moisture
within each group of clay.
Keywords: clays, extrusion, plasticity, modeling
1. Introduction
The plasticity in the processing of ceramic materials is a
fundamental property since it defines the necessary technical
parameters to convert a particulate ceramic body to a component
with a given shape by application of pressure.
The plasticity, in this case, and particularly in clay mineral
systems, is defined as a property that shows shape changes without
rupture when a clay body with added water is submitted to an external
force. Furthermore, when the force is removed or reduced below to
a value corresponding to the yield stress the shape is maintained
1
.
The main factors that affect the clay plasticity, according to Barba
et al.
2
and Händle
3
, are related to physical characteristics of the solid,
particularly the particle size distribution and its specific surface area,
the water characteristics (viscosity, surface tension, etc.), the solid
mineralogical composition (clay mineral type, proportion of non-
plastic minerals, etc.), the dispersion state of the particles that depends
on the ionic change capacity and nature and proportion of additives,
as well as on the ceramic body temperature. Relevant process-related
factors affecting clay plasticity are application of pressure, body
temperature and characteristics of additives used
4
.
However, the plasticity determination is not always an easy task
since it cannot be immediately applied and interpreted. In fact, there
are several methods for measurement and characterization of the
plasticity of a clay body, although its experimental determination, in
some cases, is operator-dependent, causing difficulties in interpreting
the results
5
. Among the methods, the Atterberg’s plasticity index, the
Pfefferkorn’s plasticity index, stress/strain curves, indentation and
rheological measurements are the most applied.
The Atterberg’s plastic limit is the lowest water content at which
the body can be rolled into threads without breaking. The Atterberg’s
liquid limit is the water content at which the body begins to flow,
using a specific apparatus. The difference between both values is
called the Atterberg’s plasticity index
6
. Alternatively, the Pfefferkorn
method determines the amount of water required to achieve a 30%
contraction in relation to the initial height of a test body under the
action of a standard weight
7
.
As with other types of materials, a compression test can be
used to evaluate the plasticity of clays. Baran et al.
8
formulated their
workability concept for clays using compression tests in cylindrical
samples, allowing to determine the optimum amount of moisture for
each clay studied. Ribeiro et al.
5
evaluated the plasticity of extrudable
clays by compression tests and found that the measured samples
were ruptured at 50-55% deformation. In a typical test curve, a great
deal of information is obtained: modulus of elasticity, yield strength,
maximum deformation and rupture strength. Those parameters are
strongly influenced by the moisture of the clay and its chemical or
phase composition.
Clays may present a wide range of plasticity values
9
. Typical
values of Atterberg’s plasticity index for Kaolinitic clays range from
5 to 22; for ilittic clays, from 39 to 51; and for montmorillonitic
clays, up to 600.
2
Usually measurements of clay plasticity are undertaken without
considering a formal description of this physical behavior through a
modeling approach. A model would not only describe the process in
a broader and deeper way, but it also might be used for predicting a
system’s behavior with a lower experimental effort.
In this paper, a mathematical model for evaluation of the plasticity
of clay bodies was developed from applied concepts of the plasticity
theory by using the stress/strain diagram under compression.
2. Mathematical Modeling of Compression Test
The mathematical knowledge applied to metallic porous materials
was used as a basic tool for plasticity modeling of clays
10
taking into
account few experimental parameters.
To define the processing parameters, it was assumed that the
clay compact, which has a cylindrical shape, deforms axially and
symmetrically. When the compressive force is applied, the height