Abstract The spatial location of an object can be repre-
sented in the brain with respect to different classes of
reference frames, either relative to or independent of the
subject’s position. We used functional magnetic reso-
nance imaging to identify regions of the healthy human
brain subserving mainly egocentric or allocentric (ob-
ject-based) coordinates by asking subjects to judge the
location of a visual stimulus with respect to either their
body or an object. A color-judgement task, matched for
stimuli, difficulty, motor and oculomotor responses, was
used as a control. We identified a bilateral, though main-
ly right-hemisphere based, fronto-parietal network in-
volved in egocentric processing. A subset of these re-
gions, including a much less extensive unilateral, right
fronto-parietal network, was found to be active during
object-based processing. The right-hemisphere lateral-
ization and the partial superposition of the egocentric
and the object-based networks is discussed in the light of
neuropsychological findings in brain-damaged patients
with unilateral spatial neglect and of neurophysiological
studies in the monkey.
Key words Spatial reference frames · Mid-sagittal plane ·
Object-based · Spatial · Hemineglect · Right hemisphere
Introduction
The spatial location of an object may be, in principle,
represented with reference to two fundamental classes of
spatial coordinate frames: egocentric and allocentric
(see, e.g., Howard and Templeton 1966; Lacquaniti
1997). In the egocentric frames, the position of objects is
encoded with reference to the body of the observer or,
more specifically, to relevant body parts, such as the
head, trunk, and/or arm. Egocentric representations of
objects may be used for the organization of goal-directed
movements, such as reaching a target or avoiding a dan-
gerous stimulus. In the allocentric coordinate frames, by
contrast, objects are primarily represented with reference
to their spatial and configurational properties, such as the
relationships among their different component parts and
among different objects in the environment. Representa-
tions encoding the configurational properties of objects
may be useful for their identification. Objects, in ecolog-
ical conditions, are typically seen from a variety of ego-
centric (observer-based) perspectives, suggesting a close
interaction between body- and object-based reference
frames.
Experimental support for this broad distinction comes
from two main sources of evidence. Neurophysiological
studies in the monkey have demonstrated the existence
of both body- and object-based representations in the
brain. In the posterior parietal cortex, neurons coding vi-
sual information in egocentric (body- and body part-cen-
tered) coordinates have been found in area 7a (Andersen
et al. 1985), area LIP (Andersen et al. 1990), area VIP
(Duhamel et al. 1997), and area PO (Galletti et al. 1993).
Units with similar properties were also found in the pre-
motor cortex (area 6: Fogassi et al. 1992; Graziano et al.
1994). On the other hand, neurons whose firing rate is
modulated by the specific location inside an object,
where a saccade has to be directed independent of the
object position and orientation, have been found both in
the posterior parietal cortex (area LIP: Breznen et al.
1999) and in the frontal lobe (supplementary eye fields:
Olson and Gettner 1995).
G. Galati · G. Vallar · L. Pizzamiglio
Laboratory of Neuropsychology, Fondazione Santa Lucia,
Via Ardeatina 306, 00179 Roma, Italy
G. Galati · E. Lobel · D. Le Bihan
SHFJ, Department of Medical Research, CEA,
Orsay, France
L. Pizzamiglio
Department of Psychology, Università di Roma “La Sapienza”,
Roma, Italy
E. Lobel · A. Berthoz
LPPA, Collège de France and CNRS, Paris, France
G. Vallar
Department of Psicology, Università di Milano-Bicocca,
Milano, Italy
Exp Brain Res (2000) 133:156–164
Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s002210000375
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Gaspare Galati · Elie Lobel · Giuseppe Vallar
Alain Berthoz · Luigi Pizzamiglio · Denis Le Bihan
The neural basis of egocentric and allocentric coding of space
in humans: a functional magnetic resonance study
Received: 26 July 1999 / Accepted: 10 February 2000 / Published online: 11 April 2000
© Springer-Verlag 2000