Time Zone Change and Major Psychiatric Morbidity:
The Results of a 6-Year Study in Jerusalem
G. Katz, H.Y. Knobler, Z. Laibel, Z. Strauss, and R. Durst
Psychiatric morbidity among foreign tourists is usu-
ally connected to external factors such as unfamiliar
surroundings, language problems, and specialreli-
gious experiences, as wellas biological factors such
as dyschronism ofcircadian rhythms. Long-range
flights through several time zones are typically fol-
lowed by symptoms of jet lag such as fatigue, severe
sleep schedule disturbance, impairment of cognitive
functions, and even mild depression. Jet lag is gener-
ally attributed to a conflict between external time
cues and internal biological rhythms. This study ex-
amined the possible association between jet lag and
psychiatric morbidity among long-distance travelers
hospitalized in the Jerusalem Mental Health Center,
Kfar Shaul Hospital between 1993 and 1998. This was
a prospective open-label study.Patients (n ⴝ 152)
were divided into two groups based on the number of
time zones crossed in the flight to Israel:group I,
seven time zones or more (n ⴝ 81); and group II, three
time zones or less (n ⴝ 71). The direction of flight was
mainly eastbound. After controlling the two groups
for demographic and religious background, past psy-
chiatric history, and diagnosis on admission ( P> 0.1,
Fisher’s exact test), the possible association between
jet lag and psychotic or major affective disorder was
evaluated according to the following criteria: (1) ab-
sence of major mental problems before the flight or
good remission of an existing disorder 1 year or more
before flight; and (2) the appearance of psychotic or
major affective syndromes during the first 7 days after
landing. The number of first psychotic/major affective
episodes in both groups presumed as associated with
jet lag was found similar ( P ⴝ .5), whereas the number
of relapses conjoint with jet lag in the seven or more
time zone group was significantly higher ( P ⴝ .04).
The results suggest that the dyschronism of circadian
rhythms and jet lag possibly play a role in the exac-
erbation of major psychiatric disorders.
Copyright © 2002 by W.B. Saunders Company
R
APID DYSCHRONISM of internal circadian
rhythms following long distance flights may
cause a variety of unpleasant symptoms such as
fatigue, headache, irritability, lossof concentra-
tion,and gastrointestinal disorders.
1
These symp-
toms,known as jet lag,lastfor several days and
usually no serious complications are observed.
Generally, jet lag is more severe among older trav-
elers and after eastward flights with multiple time
zone changes.
2
A connection between psychiatric
morbidity and time zone change has been sug-
gested in the literature,
3
although, in general, the
chronobiological aspects of psychiatric morbidity
among travelers have been underinvestigated. In
thisstudy,an attempt is made to evaluate the
possible psychiatric aspects of jet lag.
One of the main problems in conducting con-
trolled and large-scale studies in this area is the
lack of psychiatric institutions specializing in the
treatment of travelers. The Kfar ShaulMental
Health Center is a unique facility in this respect in
that almost all visitors to Jerusalem who succumb
to psychotic breakdown are automatically referred
there for evaluation.
4-6
Research into this phenom-
enon has also been hampered by standardization
problems but these are largely overcome by the
recently introduced syndrome-specific scalefor
measuring severity of jet lag.
7
The aim of the present study was to examine the
relation of jet lag with the appearance of psychi-
atric symptoms among tourists hospitalized in Kfar
Shaul Hospital during the years 1993 to 1998.
METHOD
Demographic and psychiatric data were collected on all for-
eign tourists (n ⫽ 152) admitted to the Kfar ShaulMental
Health Center over a 6-year period (1993 to 1998). The demo-
graphic data included gender, age, marital status, education, and
religious background; the psychiatric data included diagnosis
after referral (according DSM-IV) and information regarding
past psychiatric history and recent psychiatric condition 1 year
prior to the journey and the flight to Israel. Travel history has
been obtained from various sources: the patient, his/her family,
treating doctors, accompanying persons, etc.Patientconsent
was obtained prior to inclusion in this prospective, open clinical
trial.
For geopolitical reasons, foreign visitors to Israel usually
arrive by air and experience a time zone change of 7 hours or
more (from North and South America, the Far East and Aus-
tralia), or 3 hours or less (from European countries). This allows
for two groups (referred to as group I and group II, respectively)
to be distinguished and compared for the possible influence of
jet lag on either the first appearance of a psychotic or affective
From the Kfar Shaul Mental Health Center, affiliated with the
Hebrew University, Hadassah Medical School, Jerusalem, Is-
rael.
Address reprint requests to Gregory Katz, M.D.,Kfar Shaul
Hospital, Givat Shaul, Jerusalem, 91060.
Copyright © 2002 by W.B. Saunders Company
0010-440X/02/4301-0008$35.00/0
doi:10.1053/comp.2002.29849
Comprehensive Psychiatry, Vol. 43, No. 1 ( January/February), 2002: pp 37-40 37