Copyright © 2013 American Scientific Publishers
All rights reserved
Printed in the United States of America
Article
Journal of
Biomedical
Nanotechnology
Vol. 9, 1–11, 2013
www.aspbs.com/jbn
Control of Cytolocalization and Mechanism of
Cell Death by Encapsulation of a Photosensitizer
Daiana K. Deda, Christiane Pavani, Eduardo Caritá, Maurício S. Baptista
∗
,
Henrique E. Toma, and Koiti Araki
∗
Institute of Chemistry, University of Sao Paulo, Av. Prof. Lineu Prestes 748, Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil
The most challenging and wanted development in photodynamic therapy is the control of photosensitizer (PS) cytolocal-
ization and the mechanism of cell death. 5,10,15-triphenyl-20-(3-N-methylpyridinium-yl)porphyrin (3MMe) administered to
HeLa cells as DMSO solution accumulates in the cytoplasmic membrane (CM) where it causes severe photodamage and
cell necrosis. In contrast, when incorporated in marine atelocollagen/xantham gum polymeric nanocapsules, that PS is
shuttled through CM allowing its gradual release and accumulation in mitochondria and lysosomes. Little photodamage
was caused to cells in this case, but compelling evidences are presented showing that encapsulation changes the cytolo-
calization and shifts the cell death mechanism from necrosis to apoptosis. In conclusion, both of those challenges can
be overcome by encapsulation of typical PSs such as 3MMe by using the new concept of photodynamic treatment with
minimal cell damage by targeting specifically some key organelles. We are confident that these findings are important for
the development of more efficient photosensitizers tailored to induce apoptosis while minimizing undesirable side effects
such as over-inflammation.
KEYWORDS: Photodynamic Therapy, Polymeric Nanocapsules, Cytolocalization, Apoptosis, Necrosis.
INTRODUCTION
Photodynamic Therapy (PDT) is an alternative treatment
for several diseases based on the light activation of
photosensitizer (PS) molecules loaded onto the diseased
tissues.
1–3
The first PDT drug approved by FDA has sev-
eral drawbacks such as unknown molecular structure and
unspecific action mechanism, low intrinsic efficiency, and
prolonged photosensitivity.
4
Thus, new PSs and formula-
tions with improved biocompatibility and phototherapeutic
efficiency are being sought.
5–14
However, the general strat-
egy continues to be based on the local generation of the
largest as possible amounts of reactive species rather than
trying to trigger a specific programmed cell death mecha-
nism inducing the minimal photodamage as possible.
The photodynamic efficiency is influenced not only by
the PS concentration in the diseased tissues but also by
its intracellular localization.
15 16
Production of reactive
species at key organelles seems to be more effective on
∗
Authors to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Emails: koiaraki@iq.usp.br, baptista@iq.usp.br
Received: 20 July 2012
Revised/Accepted: 6 January 2013
inducing cell death than simply generating them all around
in a non-specific way.
16–18
In general, drugs that accu-
mulate in the cytoplasmic membrane tend to trigger cell
necrosis, whereas those targeting intracellular organelles
such as mitochondria, endoplasmic reticulum and lyso-
somes tend to favor programed cell death mechanisms
(apoptosis or autophagy) depending on the photosensi-
tizer and light dose.
19–21
Inducing apoptosis is an ele-
gant way of causing cell death avoiding over-inflammation
reactions.
22–25
Ideally, PSs should be able to selectively
trigger apoptosis without generating too much reactive
species and without harming adjacent tissues.
High photodynamic activity is generally associated
with amphiphilic PSs with relatively high lipophilic-
ity and therefore low solubility in biological fluids.
26 27
This limitation has been overcome by encapsulation
in micro- and nano-sized biocompatible vehicles.
5 28 29
Several reports describe efficient drug carriers and
release systems for circumventing in vivo drug deliv-
ery issues.
30–39
We recently showed that meso-triphenyl(3-
N -methylpyiridinium)porphyrin (3MMe) incorporated in
marine atelocollagen/xanthan gum (MAC) polymeric
nanocapsules has higher efficiency than an analogous
J. Biomed. Nanotechnol. 2013, Vol. 9, No. xx 1550-7033/2013/9/001/011 doi:10.1166/jbn.2013.1614 1