1
Journal of Engineering Education
July 2011, Vol. 100, No. 3, pp. 1–24
© 2011 ASEE. http://www.jee.org
Collaborative Learning in Engineering
Students: Gender and Achievement
GLENDA STUMP , JONATHAN HILPERT
a
, JENEFER HUSMAN,
WEN-TING CHUNG, WONSIK KIM
Arizona State University, Indiana University-Purdue University Fort Wayne
a
BACKGROUND
Collaboration is an ABET accreditation required component of the engineering curriculum.
Research has shown that collaborative learning positively influences student achievement. The rela-
tionship between motivation, collaborative learning strategies, and achievement is not well studied in
an engineering education context.
PURPOSE (HYPOTHESIS)
A set of hypotheses were tested that predicted positive relationships between students’ self-reported infor-
mal collaboration, self-efficacy for learning course material, knowledge building behaviors, and course
grade. A second set of hypotheses were tested that predicted gender similarities in reported self-efficacy,
and gender differences in reported collaborative learning activities.
DESIGN/METHOD
One hundred fifty engineering students were surveyed for study 1 and 513 students were surveyed for
study 2. Bivariate correlations were completed to examine relationship between study variables; multiple
regression analysis was completed to examine predictive ability of variables on course grade; MANOVA
was completed to examine multivariate relationship between variables.
RESULTS
In study 1, students’ reported use of collaborative learning strategies and reported self-efficacy for learning
course material were significantly predictive of their course grade. In study 2, female students reported
greater use of collaboration as a learning strategy than their male classmates; among male and female stu-
dents combined, those who received “B’s” in their engineering course reported more collaboration than
their peers who received “A’s” or “C’s” and lower.
CONCLUSIONS
Overall, students’ self reported collaborative learning strategies were associated with increased self-efficacy
for learning course material and course grade, particularly for students who received “B’s” in the course.
Female students reported greater use of collaborative learning strategies than their male peers.
KEYWORDS
achievement, collaborative learning, gender
INTRODUCTION
Traditional engineering educational strategies such as lecture, lab experiences, and
homework have been criticized because they inadequately prepare engineering students to
engage in the collaborative partnerships that are essential for the practicing engineer
(Kalonji, 2005). These methods have also been criticized because they promote passive learn-
ing and a compartmentalized curriculum that may not prepare students for the innovative