ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Heritability of Recurrent Tonsillitis
Ellen Kvestad, MD; Kari Jorunn Kværner, MD, PhD; Espen Røysamb, PhD; Kristian Tambs, PhD;
Jennifer Ruth Harris, PhD; Per Magnus, MD, PhD
Objective: To estimate the relative contribution of ge-
netic and environmental effects on the variance in the
liability of recurrent tonsillitis.
Design: Retrospective questionnaire data from a popu-
lation-based cohort.
Setting: Population-based data from Norway.
Participants: A total of 9479 Norwegian twins born be-
tween January 1, 1967, and December 31, 1979, identi-
fied through the Medical Birth Registry of Norway.
Main Outcome Measure: Recurrent tonsillitis.
Results: The lifetime prevalence of recurrent tonsillitis
was 11.7% (95% confidence interval, 11.0%-12.3%), with
a significant predominance of female cases. The tetra-
choric correlations for monozygotic twins were 0.71 for
males and 0.60 for females. For dizygotic twins, the cor-
relations were 0.12 for males, 0.14 for females, and 0.24
for dizygotic pairs of opposite sex. Structural equation
modeling indicated that genetic effects explained 62% of
the variation in the liability of recurrent tonsillitis. The
remaining variance was attributed to individual environ-
mental effects. There was no evidence of sex-specific ge-
netic effects on the liability of recurrent tonsillitis.
Conclusion: There is evidence for a substantial genetic
predisposition for recurrent tonsillitis.
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2005;131:383-387
T
ONSILLITIS IS A COMMON
childhood infectious dis-
ease that involves the pa-
renchyma of the palatine
tonsils. Although tonsilli-
tis has few long-term effects, recurrent ton-
sillitis causes significant morbidity and
time lost from school or work.
1
The defi-
nition of recurrent may vary somewhat, but
the criteria used recently as a measure of
severity were 5 or more episodes of true
tonsillitis per year, symptoms recurring for
at least a year, and episodes that are dis-
abling and that prevent normal function-
ing.
1
In children, sore throat may be part
of the early symptom complex of upper
respiratory tract morbidity. Although most
other childhood upper respiratory tract dis-
eases tend to improve with time, there is
no evidence of spontaneous resolution of
recurrent tonsillitis.
2
The limited data avail-
able provide no evidence of a difference
between surgical and medical treatment for
recurrent tonsillitis.
1
To date, neither genetic nor environ-
mental risk factors for tonsillitis have been
fully explored. A previous case-control
study
3
reported that parental atopy and pa-
rental history of tonsillectomy predict sub-
sequent tonsillitis in their children. Fa-
milial clustering of tonsillectomy has been
shown in a small clinical study,
4
but the
study was not designed to distinguish be-
tween these 2 sources of variance. An-
other study
5
reported that heritability of
tonsillectomy varies with time, suggest-
ing a cohort effect in the heritability of this
phenotype. To our knowledge, the heri-
tability of recurrent tonsillitis has not pre-
viously been reported. The aim of the
present study is to estimate the relative
contribution of genetic and environmen-
tal effects in the liability of recurrent ton-
sillitis in a population-based data sample
of Norwegian twins.
METHODS
SAMPLE
The Norwegian Institute of Public Health Twin
Study has a dynamic cohort design. The cur-
rent database includes information on twins
born between January 1, 1967, and December
31, 1979, identified through the Medical Birth
Registry of Norway. Two questionnaire stud-
ies have been conducted so far, in 1992 and
1998, with individual response rates of 73%
and 63% and pairwise response rates of 64%
and 52%, respectively. The 1992 question-
Author Affiliations: Division of
Epidemiology, Norwegian
Institute of Public Health, Oslo
(Drs Kvestad, Røysamb, Tambs,
Harris, and Magnus), and
Department of
Otorhinolaryngology, Akershus
University Hospital, University
of Oslo (Dr Kværner).
Financial Disclosure: None.
(REPRINTED) ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG/ VOL 131, MAY 2005 WWW.ARCHOTO.COM
383
©2005 American Medical Association. All rights reserved.
Downloaded From: http://archotol.jamanetwork.com/ on 12/02/2015